Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Post-WW2 Military and Naval Aviation (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=35)
-   -   USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I' (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=21922)

NickM 7th August 2010 04:56

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Thanks;

I got Michels' book in front of me: The June 24 losses were one close escort F4 & one Strike F4(post bomb drop) were lost to Mig 21s & on June 27 a MigCAP F4 & two F4s diverted for 'SAR' work were shot down by Migs.

I guess I better read closer...I think MAYBE Michel's math is a bit off---

Speaking of which, the May 18 F4 loss to the J-6/MiG19--do you know if it was it shot down by cannon fire or by Atoll missiles?

Thanks

mars 7th August 2010 06:13

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
As far as I know, only Mig-21s were armed with Atoll missiles. And Michael is correct of the F-4 losses on Jun 24 and June 27

NickM 7th August 2010 07:05

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mars (Post 111529)
As far as I know, only Mig-21s were armed with Atoll missiles. And Michael is correct of the F-4 losses on Jun 24 and June 27

For those two days yes they were...I'm trying to sift thru 'Clashes' slowly & methodically...the bit that has me curious is that he said of the 24 planes lost by the USAF 18 where F4s...so far I only see one F105 & the rest seem to be all F4s;

Anyhoo...it's interesting that The F4s downed by the J-6/Mig19s had no survivors except for Robert Lodge; Must be those huge 30mm cannons they carried.

NM

Leendert 7th August 2010 14:11

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
The single F-105G was downed on 11 May 72 (62-4224, 17 WWS, 388 TFW), crew Maj William Talley and Maj James Padgett, both POW.
Distracted by SAMs and shot down by Mig-21.

The two F-4s that were lost in the strike elements were 66-7636 on 24 Jun72 and 66-8738 on 5 Oct 72.

The "indirect" F-105G (own Sidewinder exploded a bit too soon..) was on 29 Jul 72 (62-4443, 17 WWS, 388 TFW). Both crew survived (Maj Coady and Maj Murphy).

Regards,

Leendert

John Beaman 7th August 2010 19:18

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Leendert (Post 111398)
From he very detailed book Vietnam Air Losses by Chris Hobson that describes each and every USAF, USN and USMC fixed-wing a/c loss I could make out the following.


Leendert

Leendert: Was this a privately published book? Amazon lists an exactly titled "article" in Air and Space Power magazine by a different author.

NickM 7th August 2010 19:23

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Leendert (Post 111553)
The single F-105G was downed on 11 May 72 (62-4224, 17 WWS, 388 TFW), crew Maj William Talley and Maj James Padgett, both POW.
Distracted by SAMs and shot down by Mig-21.

The two F-4s that were lost in the strike elements were 66-7636 on 24 Jun72 and 66-8738 on 5 Oct 72.

The "indirect" F-105G (own Sidewinder exploded a bit too soon..) was on 29 Jul 72 (62-4443, 17 WWS, 388 TFW). Both crew survived (Maj Coady and Maj Murphy).

Regards,

Leendert

Hmmmm...the October 5 striker loss was not in Michel's book; but the entries before & after this date are replete with Migs being able to get thru to the strikers & harass them into dropping their payloads;

NM

NickM 7th August 2010 20:55

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by John Beaman (Post 111574)
Leendert: Was this a privately published book? Amazon lists an exactly titled "article" in Air and Space Power magazine by a different author.

John it's a REAL book; I saw it once at my local Barnes & Noble...I even thumbed through it for a bit.

NM

mars 7th August 2010 20:58

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Leendert (Post 111553)
The single F-105G was downed on 11 May 72 (62-4224, 17 WWS, 388 TFW), crew Maj William Talley and Maj James Padgett, both POW.
Distracted by SAMs and shot down by Mig-21.

The two F-4s that were lost in the strike elements were 66-7636 on 24 Jun72 and 66-8738 on 5 Oct 72.

The "indirect" F-105G (own Sidewinder exploded a bit too soon..) was on 29 Jul 72 (62-4443, 17 WWS, 388 TFW). Both crew survived (Maj Coady and Maj Murphy).

Regards,

Leendert

You are right, I missed that one, that is a thick book

Frank Olynyk 8th August 2010 02:43

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
John,
Go to addall.com, and put in Chris Hobson, and Vietnam, and you will find a number of copies. One of the bookstores is actually in North Carolina!

Enjoy!

Frank.

John Beaman 8th August 2010 20:28

Re: USAF air to air losses during 'Linebacker I'
 
Thanks Frank


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 11:59.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net