Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Bf 109 G identity seeked (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=29893)

Harold Lake 1st June 2012 20:18

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Gentlemen,

Without knowing this aircraft's werknummern, it is very difficult to be 100 percent certain of its subtype and, by extension, its role. The only real clue is the enigmatic white wedge atop the rudder. Besides black 17, W.Nr. 463141, another Gustav, yellow 12, W.Nr. unknown, photographed after the war at Kassel-Rothwestern, also had the white wedge and, I recall seeing at least one other Gustav with this marking but can't recall exactly where. I think the odds are in favor of a fighter unit as opposed to reconnaissance because neither black 17 nor Yellow 12 had any visible camera carrying features.

Hal

S Sheflin 1st June 2012 22:18

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Hello everyone,

This beautiful aircraft is of particular interest to me because of the prominent wedge of white on its upper rudder. As Mr. Lake stated, counting this new example, there are four that I have documented so far:

G-? 11+ Bk o/l W, Belly landed, 45/05/08+ Location UNK
G-14 463141, 17+ Bk o/l W, Surrendered, 45/05/08, Fürth
G-14 12+ Y o/l Bk, Captured intact, 45/05/08, Kassel-Rothwesten
G-14? 1+ Bk o/l W, Surrendered, 45/04/26, Faßberg

Interestingly, along with the wedge of white on their rudders, three of the four share white-outlined black plane numbers. Hopefully, we will eventually determine the purpose of this unique rudder marking.

Steve Sheflin

Marc-André Haldimann 1st June 2012 22:59

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Gents,

Thanks so much for your inputs; as you put it Steve, "Schwarze 11" is really a beautiful machine, and this white wedge is of special interest. Is this really a new feature, never seen before? I'll have a look at the F./ and NAG units machines pics I do have under my hand....

Harold,
the issue of seeing cameras fixtures on 109's is truly a discouraging one. I wouldn't dismiss a NAG machine on the only count no camera fixtures are being seen on a photograph. You can check my Bf 109 G-8 section and none of the 32 referenced pictures do ever show the slightest hint of cameras.
http://www.flickr.com/photos/2809206...7625536800422/

On the contrary, W.Nr. 463 141 "Schwarze 11" is officially documented as being on strength of 2./NAG. 14. All doors remain thus open...

Cheers
Marc

Marc-André Haldimann 2nd June 2012 09:36

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Folsk,

Just for the sake of a close-up on one of those white wedges Bf 109 G tails, I've uploaded such a pic of Bf 109 G-14 W.Nr. 463 141 "Schwarze 17" of 2./NAG 14:

http://www.flickr.com/photos/2809206...in/photostream

Still looking for others; there is one similar marking on a tail of a Bf 109 G in Broken Eagles 2, p. 8, taken at Lippstadt.

Will keep you posted.

Cheers
Marc

Marc-André Haldimann 2nd June 2012 12:50

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Just found and added the picture of "Gelbe 12", found in Kassel-Rothwesten, May 1945.

http://www.flickr.com/photos/2809206...in/photostream

Cheers
Marc

ChristianK 3rd June 2012 15:07

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Hi all,
in Revi magazine No.44 there is a collection of photos showing at least three Bf 109s with those white triangles on their rudders. They were found at the war's end in Hodkovice (Liebenau near Reichenberg) and the authors attribute them to III./EJG 1. Apparently this speculation is based on the geographic area and the difference in marking style compared to NAGr 15 (then based at Liberec/Reichenberg).
But even after a quick check some conflicting facts come up. For once, Martin Holm's site sees II./EJG 1 in Liebenau, not III./EJG 1. Secondly, the marking styles of "Black 17" at Fürth and "White 12" at Kassel are different to each other too.
So not much clarity here, but perhaps a small puzzle piece that will lead to a solution.

Regards,
Christian

S Sheflin 3rd June 2012 15:59

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Greeting all,

Can someone scan the photos to which Christian refers in REVI magazine #44? I would love to get a look at them

Steve Sheflin

ouidjat 3rd June 2012 18:52

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Hi all,

If it's so, it's not a unit marking but something else I did suggest in Marc Flickr page under "Schwarze 11" picture... Explanation still open.

Cheers, Franck.

veltro 4th June 2012 00:14

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
2 Attachment(s)
Here they are (bad scan quality is not mine but the arrows are). It seems that we have another small Bf 109 detail still unknown...

Marc-André Haldimann 4th June 2012 07:07

Re: Bf 109 G identity seeked
 
Many thanks, Ferdinando!

The workshop picture does bring closer Franck's theory the wedge bring a manufacturer mark, may e even a wooden tail producer.

If my memory serves me well, the first pic showing a Bf 109 in a hangar its nose on the sun was taken in Skutec, and is also published by Janowsky in 2010 in Kagero's "Bf 109 G/K. Vol III.

As you say Ferdinando, another small piece of the "Beule's" checkered history...

Cheers from Autun, Burgundy
Marc


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 02:39.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net