Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Books and Magazines (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   New He 219 Book from Wingleader. (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=57648)

Alfred.MONZAT 11th August 2020 09:36

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
So as we are talking about photos and nobody mentioned it... Photos are of awful quality! It's quite an unpleasant surprise for a book at this price.

FalkeEins 11th August 2020 12:17

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
..I don't suppose the original print/copies in a number of instances were that great either and in a few places in the book they are reproduced too small....no artworks either! Scope for Chandos to do better..

richdlc 11th August 2020 12:27

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FalkeEins (Post 293200)
I'm sure there'll be a thread about your book when it appears. Seems a bit churlish of you not to acknowledge that Wingleader and their author have done an excellent job on this. I know you have a 'thing' about 'unpublished' images and there's gonna be far fewer of those now in your book, but I'm sure that won't stop enthusiasts buying it (..as it would not have that JG title...). This book will surely only make yours better..

Nothing to do with the guys at wingleader mate, more to do with Ferguson as a person. Much more going on behind the scenes than you might be aware of, but given my comments on The ‘other thread’ Yesterday I am very wary of airing dirty laundry in public. I am sure wingleader have done a fantastic job, and I have spoken with them extensively about friend Ferguson.

superbee 18th September 2020 19:35

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
Just bought a copy.Great book.I would recommend it.
The only problem is the small, poor quality pictures.
I really enjoyed chapter 5 detailing the combat history.

TigerTimon 18th September 2020 23:03

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
Combat history is a great plus. Something I also thoroughly enjoyed is the report of a tester from Erprobungsstelle Rechlin on testing the ejection seat. First-hand accounts are always great. However, they are scarce in this book.

Stig Jarlevik 19th September 2020 10:38

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
I had a brief look inside when visiting Christian Schmidt earlier this week.

I, for one, will certainly wait for the Chando effort.
Will be very interesting so see what Marcel can do, given a reasonable free hand.... :)

Cheers
Stig

Nick Beale 11th November 2020 13:12

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
There's a bit more about what the Chandos book will include over on the Falke Eins blog in an interview with Dan Sharp. After talking about his own book, "Secret Projects of the Luftwaffe", he mentions what he has contributed to Chandos's He 219 and Bf 109 T projects.

richdlc 12th November 2020 17:25

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
thanks for the heads up Nick

GoranA 3rd October 2024 00:19

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
Few questions about He 219 books (My birthday is coming and my wife & kids want to buy me a book, and He 219 an Illustrated History is one of the candidates - other are Dan Sharp's Me 262 book or the new BC RS vol 1...)

Is the Ferguson/Wingleader book "the best" He 219 book at the moment? It doesn't seem to be that "illustrated", according to reviews posted above...

Also, what's happening with Chandos He 219 project - is there any chance of something coming out in foreseeable future or is it dead?

richdlc 3rd October 2024 10:33

Re: New He 219 Book from Wingleader.
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GoranA (Post 340260)

Is the Ferguson/Wingleader book "the best" He 219 book at the moment? It doesn't seem to be that "illustrated", according to reviews posted above...

Also, what's happening with Chandos He 219 project - is there any chance of something coming out in foreseeable future or is it dead?

I'm afraid my opinion would be purely subjective, given that Ron Ferguson basically screwed us over by breaking contract and then went to Wing Leader. The problem with him, [moderated] , is that he insists on publishing only what he wants. I'm not enough of an expert on the He 219 to know how accurate his book is, but I would say it 80% there.

Our book isn't 'dead', it's just on hold while our expert finishes up the operational history and some other stuff - unfortunately this can't be rushed.

If you want the best book for technical details and loss lists etc, then I'll leave that advice to the experts. For model making, probably one of the Richard Franks books.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 12:57.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net