Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum - Market research

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)

- Books and Magazines (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=16)

- - Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=62091)

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by MW Giles (Post 319704)

My only bugbear - histories that take 450 pages to get to the end of 1942 and then 20 pages to complete the path to 1945
Martin

Very good point! :) Agree.

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by alessandro bray (Post 319755)

Hallo,
Personally i'd like to see unit histories on Schlachtgeschwader units with good test coverage for the 43-45 timeframe. Maybe the availability of russian archives can give a better pictures of their real impact in term of effective tactical support, tank disable etc....
Alessandro

Amen! Larry deZeng's compendium is groundbreaking but complete unit histories of Schlachtgeschwaders like SG10, SG4 and SG3 are missing.

Best

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by hucks216 (Post 319741)

Totally agree. A multi volume series of flak unit histories, not necessarily one unit per book but a history of their deployments etc.

Hucks - you mean like this?

le.Flak-Abt. 911 (v)
Formed c. 26 August 1939 in Wien (Vienna) as le.Reserve-Flak-Abt. 911 with a Stab and 3 batteries numbered 1.-3. Redesignated le.Flak-Abt. 911 (v) c. July 1942. A 4. Batterie was added c. October 1942.
Lineage and Subordination: see: Tessin or (www.ww2.dk).
History
1939-40: west-central Germany (Luftgau XII area). www.ww2.dk)
10 May 40: attack on France and the Low Countries followed by the occupation of France.
26 Nov 40: Garges-lès-Gonesse/3 km NW of Paris-le-Bourget airfield under Festungs-Flak-Rgt. 32 with 2 heavy and 2 medium/light batteries. (NARA T-1022/PG80318)
18 Feb 41: in the Luftgau Westfrankreich area. (NARA T-321)
Oct/Nov 43 – Jun 44: W France under Flak-Rgt. 59 (Paris)/13. Flak-Div., then 5. Flak-Brig., then 1. Flak-Brig. (Tessin)
Mar 44: W France under Flak-Rgt. 59 (Paris).
8 Jun 44: Stab, 1. and 3./911 ordered to move forward by road from Paris to protect bridges in the Elbeuf area/18 km SSW of Rouen on the Seine. (ULTRA KV7017)
22 Jun 44: Stab and 3./911 reported their arrival and operational readiness at Elbeuf. (CX/MSS/T223/98)
Jun/Jul – Sep 44: under Flak-Rgt. 100/13. Flak-Div., then 1. Flak-Brig. (Tessin)
15 Jul 44: Elbeuf under Flak-Rgt. 100/13. Flak-Div. (NARA T-971 roll 18/f.053)
21 Aug 44: Stab/911 trf to Freneuse/59 km NW of Paris. (CX/MSS/T283/126)
26 Aug 44: 1. and 3./911 and 2./344 being investigated for blowing up their guns prematurely without authorization. (BNA HW 5/574)
27 Sep 44: 4./911 was protecting Niedermendig airfield/25 km WNW of Koblenz. (Schnatz: p.211)
Oct 44 – 1945: Central Rhine area (west-central Germany), initially under Flak-Rgt. 15 (Trier area). (Tessin; NARA T-405 roll 17)
8-9 Mar 45: le.911 lost a significant number of men KIA, WIA or taken prisoner at Unkel am Rhein/17.5 km SE of Bonn and 3.25 km NW of Remagen. (Nicolaisen:I/271)
FpNs: Stab (L 38859), 1. Batterie (L 37971), 2. Batterie (L 37029), 3. Batterie (L 32921), 4. Batterie (L 54513).
Kommandeur:
Hptm. (Tr.O.) Georg Lyncker: (? - 5/41)
Obstlt. Dr. Carl Walbrach: (? - ?) 8/42
Hptm. (d.R.) Hasso von Bose: (? - ?) 7/44

This is about as detailed as the surviving records permit. As Nick B. noted, the opportunity to work with veterans has come and gone. Besides, how would a researcher/author ever have managed to correspond back and forth with multiple veterans from the approx. 1,200 Flak-Abteilungen of various types that were formed during the war?

L.

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by Siko54 (Post 319728)

Surprised there isn't more on the BF110 tbh (I know John's highly-regarded book is very expensive now!). Maybe do a reprint of that?

Which book is that?

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by MW Giles (Post 319740)

You need to look a little bit harder, Martin...

John

I have nearly all your books; Zerstorer is one of my favourites that I re-read from time to time.

If only you could do something like that for the whole war I would be a very happy man.

Martin

Already been done for the day fighters. Both are now out-of-print.
https://i.imgur.com/AFMl11Q.jpg
https://i.imgur.com/B1NwMZH.jpg
The original publisher sold the rights on to another publisher, who is not interested in a reprint. So now they are up on a certain site for funny money...

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Vasco (Post 319775)

Which book is that?

The illustrated study Classic publications from 2008 - only available secondhand at exorbitant prices. Looks fantastic btw :)

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by John Vasco (Post 319776)

The original publisher sold the rights on to another publisher, who is not interested in a reprint.

I wish they would do a reprint like they did with the Nachtjagd.

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

I would welcome unit histories for the SG units, especially late war.

Concerning JG 6 I will try to fill that void....:-)

John

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Quote:

Originally Posted by Larry deZeng (Post 319768)

Exactly. I might be the odd one out on this but I prefer the nitty gritty details such as above rather than first person accounts. Not saying it wouldn't be a monumental effort as obviously it would be but the flak service is barely covered in any detail other than in the few unit specific books such as 'Die Flakabteilung I./12' by Günter Soltau and the Luftwaffe 1933-45 and Lexikon der Wehrmacht websites.

Re: Market research - 'Most Wanted' Luftwaffe books

Roger that, Hucks.
Another source that would have to be addressed is the Flak Abschuss claims. These would add significant information to each of the mini-histories, but the microfilmed daily log entries for these were handwritten by Luftwaffenhelferinen assigned to the Luftwaffenpersonalamt using colored pencil, and in many cases Sütterlin scroll, and at least 50% of these entries have faded over time to such a degree that they are illegible.

The most valuable publications on the Lw.-Flakartillerie are:

Great Britain: MI15/War Office, May 1946, Handbook of German Anti Aircraft Artillery (Flak), 14 volumes of mimeographed manuscript.
Koch, Horst-Adalbert, Flak: Die Geschichte der deutschen Flakartillerie und der Einsatz der Luftwaffenhelfer. (Podzun Verlag: Bad Nauheim, 1965). 682p.
Nicolaisen, Hans-Dietrich. Gruppenfeuer und Salventakt: Schüler und Lehrlinge bei der Flak 1943-1945. Büsum, 1993. 2 Bde.

Only Koch has mini-histories, but these are no more than one or two short sentences for each one. The Michael Holm website aqnd Lexikon der Wehrmacht are much better.

L.