Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!! (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=29125)

Kurtl12 23rd March 2012 18:03

Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Gentlemen,

Now I have a question for real Bf 109 experts: Please figure out an field aerodrome in 1944, base of a 109 unit. The planes are getting fuel on ground while suddenly Lightnings appear overhead the field. The group commander asks for an immediate take off. Drop tanks has to be dropped shortly after the take off because the P-38 Lightnings are still around. As a pilot of that group you find yourself in the middle of a dog fight. You are sitting in a Bf 109 G-6, your main tank is full so you have about 400 liters left. Your drop tank is gone...

A.) What is your maximum range you can fly out under such circumstances if you have to return to the same base?
B.) What is your maximum endurance in the same situation?

Thanks for an active discussion! - Kurtl

Oberst 23rd March 2012 20:49

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Based on what I know, and what Luftwaffe pilots I've spoken with told me, albeit not in absolute terms, about 300km & 60mins based on your criteria. Though not necessarily hunting P-38's, and dependant on E/A altitude.

Juha 24th March 2012 14:41

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
I agree with Oberst, 109 G-6, DB 605A engine, 1944: 400L fuel tank, take-off and emergency power 1475 Ps (a bit smaller unit of power than anglo-american hp used by Germans) max allowed time for continuous use 3 min, consumption 480L/h, climb and combat power 1310 Ps, max allowed continuous use 30min, consumption 400L/h, max continuos power 1075 Ps, consumption 320L/h, all figures are those at SL, at FTH (5500-5800m) figures were 1355, 1250 and 1080 Ps and 450, 390 and 320L/h.

Juha

Kurtl12 25th March 2012 21:29

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Cool. So the endurence would be about 1 hour +. I guess the radius around the base would be about 200km if you think about to attack the enemy aircraft at all heights. - Kurtl

Kurfürst 26th March 2012 20:58

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
You can work out the details for just about any combination using the F-4 range table at Beim Zeugmeister - the G-6 had very similiar :

http://www.beim-zeugmeister.de/zeugm...are%20found%3B

It should be pretty simply assume a full tank, as in your example, of 400 liters. Say 3 minutes is spent on maximum power, 1475 PS, that is 480 lit consumption per hour, or 24 liters in 3 minutes. Say another 10 minutes is spent 30 minute rating - 400 liters/h - which is another 67 liter consumed. That is 91 liter in total, leaving 309 liters for other purposes.

The F-4, at the engine power best for range consumed 120 liter/h, and could fly 315 km/h at 1 km altitude while doing so. 309/120 is 2,57 h duration, during which the aircraft can cover 2,57 x 315 = 811 km. So, about 400 km radius in an optimum case, or 300 km radius for a pretty safe bet.

Juha 27th March 2012 00:11

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Hello Kurfürst
IMHO not very similar, only fairly similar, after all G-6 had an engine with more internal volume and more draggy airframe. And in the situation Kurtl described ie enemy fighters around, pilots probably would have used higher power and speed than which gave 315km/h even if 109 had very good acceleration. IMHO at least Dauersparleistung 1,05 ata 890 PS at 5700m giving probably around 500km/h TAS and consumpting 250L/h.

Juha

Kurfürst 27th March 2012 10:37

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Well that's as good as it gets as far as data go, because I don't know of any similiar German range table for the G or K series. However datasheets give almost exactly the same max. ranges for G and F as about 600/1000 miles w. or w/o a droptank. Some British G datasheet give as high as 1200 miles.

As a matter of fact, the mid-1942 on the Zeugmeister notes the F-4's range as 1600 km, and the early G-series as 'vorausichtig(sp?) besser' (foreseen to be better).

Re: DB 605A vs 601E the former was an improved version of the latter, and the 605A had better fuel effiency (greater CR and other improvements). For example the 605A at max. cruise seem to develop about 50 HP more with the same amount of fuel used. You are of course right about the increased drag of the airframe, I guess the better engine just evened that out.

Other than, feel free to play with any condition, combination and power setting you deem realistic, that's why I gave the link to the table. ;)

BTW it would also be interesting to know how long Lightning could last over an enemy airbase and still return, preferably while disengaging at high speed.

Jukka Juutinen 27th March 2012 13:16

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Kurfürst, how far would the P-38 base be?

yogybär 27th March 2012 15:41

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
The discussion's topic "109G-6 takes off to hunt a Lightning" is totallly academic because a clean Lightning is faster than a clean 109G-6 at all altitudes.
==> If the Lightning wants to run away, it can easily do so. And if it wants to return later to fight, it could also :).

That was part of 1943's reality - sad for Luftwaffe pilots, good for the Americans.

Oberst 27th March 2012 16:58

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
But the OP is talking 1944.. So I like to think perhaps a G6/AS would make the P-38 life a bit more difficult.

Graham Boak 27th March 2012 17:24

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
However, the whole idea seems a little unreal. If the P-38s were just passing over, they'd be gone before the 109 unit could be scrambled and climb to altitude. The 109s would then have to travel at greater than optimum range speed in order to catch up. On the other hand, if the P-38s were attacking the base, they'd be at low-level and it would be suicidal for the German unit to attempt to take-off.

drgondog 27th March 2012 17:59

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kurfürst (Post 145157)
You can work out the details for just about any combination using the F-4 range table at Beim Zeugmeister - the G-6 had very similiar :

http://www.beim-zeugmeister.de/zeugm...are%20found%3B

It should be pretty simply assume a full tank, as in your example, of 400 liters. Say 3 minutes is spent on maximum power, 1475 PS, that is 480 lit consumption per hour, or 24 liters in 3 minutes. Say another 10 minutes is spent 30 minute rating - 400 liters/h - which is another 67 liter consumed. That is 91 liter in total, leaving 309 liters for other purposes.

The F-4, at the engine power best for range consumed 120 liter/h, and could fly 315 km/h at 1 km altitude while doing so. 309/120 is 2,57 h duration, during which the aircraft can cover 2,57 x 315 = 811 km. So, about 400 km radius in an optimum case, or 300 km radius for a pretty safe bet.

Hello Kurfurst - do you happen to have any Bf 109G/K performance tests which include rated Hp at critical altitudes along with the speeds attained?

drgondog 27th March 2012 18:01

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham Boak (Post 145219)
However, the whole idea seems a little unreal. If the P-38s were just passing over, they'd be gone before the 109 unit could be scrambled and climb to altitude. The 109s would then have to travel at greater than optimum range speed in order to catch up. On the other hand, if the P-38s were attacking the base, they'd be at low-level and it would be suicidal for the German unit to attempt to take-off.

Not only true regarding the fuel consumption but depending on the P-38 speed, the 109s might never catch up.

Oberst 27th March 2012 21:49

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by drgondog (Post 145224)
Not only true regarding the fuel consumption but depending on the P-38 speed, the 109s might never catch up.

Others 109's however, will.

yogybär 28th March 2012 12:53

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oberst (Post 145215)
But the OP is talking 1944.. So I like to think perhaps a G6/AS would make the P-38 life a bit more difficult.

No. A G-6/AS is even slower then a standard G-6 at altitudes below VDH/FTH and also climbs slower there.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Oberst (Post 145236)
Others 109's however, will.

No. Even if we would have a 109K and the P-38 flies at altitide "0", then
- the 109K-4@1,3ata is slower then a late Lightning@100% between 0 and min. 9000feet
- the Lightning has a certain lead of say 2-3 minutes because the 109 has to warm up engine, take-off, go in the right direction and accelerate
2,5 minutes at 450km/h would be ca. 20km ;)

Also, no pilot would use his MW-50 just to catch up with the enemy and then begin a fight just as he has to cool down his engine.

PS: If it calms you: I guess, a Lightning group sitting on its AF would also not try to catch up with a German fighter group passing - chance of finding them are just very low.

Kutscha 28th March 2012 13:55

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Scroll down and the fuel consumption of DB605 engines can be found.
http://mitglied.multimania.de/luftwa..._varianten.pdf

For example for the DB605A - C

At 5.7km, 2100rpm, 1.00ata fuel consumption is 250l/hr. At the same altitude but 2800rpm, 1.42ata, the consumption is 450l/hr.

Oberst 28th March 2012 16:26

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by yogybär (Post 145256)
No. A G-6/AS is even slower then a standard G-6 at altitudes below VDH/FTH and also climbs slower there.

No. Even if we would have a 109K and the P-38 flies at altitide "0", then
- the 109K-4@1,3ata is slower then a late Lightning@100% between 0 and min. 9000feet
- the Lightning has a certain lead of say 2-3 minutes because the 109 has to warm up engine, take-off, go in the right direction and accelerate
2,5 minutes at 450km/h would be ca. 20km ;)

Also, no pilot would use his MW-50 just to catch up with the enemy and then begin a fight just as he has to cool down his engine.

PS: If it calms you: I guess, a Lightning group sitting on its AF would also not try to catch up with a German fighter group passing - chance of finding them are just very low.

Thats some funny stuff!

Proof a G-6/AS is slower then a standard G-6? I'd like to see that if you don't mind.

And I don't understand how what will calm me? I'm not nervous.

innocenti 28th March 2012 17:46

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Oberst (Post 145264)
Thats some funny stuff!

Proof a G-6/AS is slower then a standard G-6? I'd like to see that if you don't mind.

the bigger supercharger needs more power from the crank at dense air.
innocenti

Oberst 28th March 2012 18:06

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Well I changed the blower (supercharger) on my car from a 4-71 to a 6-71 and it still went faster at the expense of more horspower to turn the new supercharger. All at 200 meters above sea level (very dense air). Its the same priciple.

innocenti 28th March 2012 19:13

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
after changing the supercharger on your car you had got a higher boost and therefore a higher power. At a aircraft motor below the FTH the boost was limited to a certain amount (eg 1,42ATA) and you’ll get not more power, just need more power to drive the supercharger.
innocenti

Oberst 29th March 2012 00:51

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Hey thanks for that!

Which one can spin a bigger prop? The DB 605A or the DB 605AS? Many Thanks! I think this is a product of which makes more Torque?

Leo Etgen 29th March 2012 03:30

Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Hello Oberst

It is my understanding that the Bf 109 G-6 utilized the VDM 9-12087A whereas the Bf 109 G-6/AS was normally fitted with the VDM 9-12159A. The latter featured broader chord blades more suitable for the high altitude role that the AS powered type was envisioned for. I hope this helps.

Horrido!

Leo

Oberst 29th March 2012 04:15

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Hello Leo!

Helps tremendously my friend! :D

From what I understand, Daimler Benz DB 605 ASM made 1800 PS with a maximum height of 7,8km 1944:
bei 2800 U/min in 0m Hohe.....: 1800PS
bei 2800 U/min in 6400m Hohe: 1500PS
bei 2600 U/min in 7800M Hohe: 1150PS

Jukka Juutinen 30th March 2012 12:22

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
What would be the distance the P-38 would have to cover on the return trip?

Oberst 31st March 2012 17:34

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
The P-38 has about a 500-1000 mile combat radius (load dependant).

Jukka Juutinen 1st April 2012 04:18

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
That is not the point. Kurürst asked:"BTW it would also be interesting to know how long Lightning could last over an enemy airbase and still return, preferably while disengaging at high speed."

So, one cannot answer this question without knowing the distance between that enemy base and one's own base.

Kurfürst 3rd April 2012 12:07

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by drgondog (Post 145222)
Hello Kurfurst - do you happen to have any Bf 109G/K performance tests which include rated Hp at critical altitudes along with the speeds attained?

Hi Bill!

You can find the details on my site: http://kurfurst.org/
You can find the relevant engine output (in all cases, static power) here: http://kurfurst.org/#engines

The tests themselves note the power regimes, so its a matter of putting 2 and 2 together.

But a quick recap - I am not sure what G types are you interested in, or is it cruise/max power, SL or rated alt?

Anyway, here it is:

G-2 (605A) - Mtt. calculation/official figures for early type:
max. 537 kph @ SL, 660 kph @ 7000m. 1310/1250 PS (static)*
max cruise. 600 kph @ 6000m, 1090 PS (rammed), 225 gram/PS/h fuel consumption

G-6 (605A) - flight trials:
510 kph @ SL, 625-630 kph @ 6700m. 1310/1250 PS (static)*
530 kph @ SL, 640 kph @ 6700m. 1475/1310 PS (static)
max. cruise. 480 kph @ SL, 585 kph at rated alt (ca 6 km), 1075 / 1080 PS

G-14/U4 (605AM w. MW boost)

568 kph @ SL, 665 kph @ 5000m. 1740/1700 PS (dynamic), datasheet, impossible to make out wheter calculation or test flight
max. cruise. 468 kph @ SL, 590 kph at rated alt (6 km), 1000 / 1080 PS (dynamic)

G-5/AS G-6/AS (605AS) - flight trials at 30 min rating:
507 kph @ SL, 654 kph @ 8300m. 1275/1150 PS (static)*

* at 30 min ratings

G-6/AS (605ASM w. MW boost)
560 kph @ SL, 675 kph @ 7500m. 1800/1500 PS (static), test flight
560 kph @ SL, 690 kph @ 6800m. 1800/1500 PS (static), another test flight
max. cruise. 480 kph @ SL, 610 kph at rated alt (8,4 km), 1030 / 1050 PS

G-14/AS (605ASM w. MW boost)
560 kph @ SL, 680 kph @ 7500m. 1740/1495 PS (dynamic), datasheet, impossible to make out wheter calculation or test flight
max. cruise. 460 kph @ SL, 620 kph at rated alt (8,4 km), 1000 / 1040 PS (dynamic)

G-10/U4 (early 605DM w. MW boost)

560 kph @ SL, 690 kph @ 7500m. 1750/1570 PS (dynamic), datasheet, calculation from August? 1944
max. cruise. 465 kph @ SL, 628 kph at rated alt (8,4 km), 1020 / 1030 PS (dynamic)

K-4 (early 605DM w. MW boost)
580 kph @ SL, 710 kph @ 7500m. 1750/1565 PS (dynamic), datasheet, possibly calculation from August 1944
max. cruise. 477 kph @ SL, 645 kph at rated alt (8,4 km), 1020 / 1030 PS (dynamic)

K-4 (605DB and DC w. MW boost)
DB : 595 kph @ SL, 710 kph @ 7500m. 1850/1600 PS (static), calculation from January 1945
DC : 607 kph @ SL, 710 kph @ 6000m, 710 kph @ 7500m.. 2000/1800/ca. 1600 PS (static), calculation from January 1945

max. cruise. probably the same or a bit better (DB/DC max. cruise power 1100/1140 PS).

Hope this helps.

drgondog 3rd April 2012 18:35

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Kurfurst - Thanks again and keep up the great website. SL and mid altitude high speed runs are best for triangulating parasite drag absent compressibility then gives me insight to the compressibility components at altitudes >20,000 feet

I was also really interested at the tip (propeller) compressibility questions in one of the P-51B-1/Merlin 1650-3 reports at 29000 critical altitude... and wondered if you have seen any German references to the same questions?

Bill

Graham Boak 3rd April 2012 20:12

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
As I recall it, and it has been a while, compressibility (wave drag) effects are a function of Mach Number only. Can you explain why it should vary with altitude for this class of aircraft?

drgondog 4th April 2012 04:47

Re: Performance/Endurance of Bf 109 G-6 during aerial combat - questions for experts!!!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Graham Boak (Post 145618)
As I recall it, and it has been a while, compressibility (wave drag) effects are a function of Mach Number only. Can you explain why it should vary with altitude for this class of aircraft?

Graham - as you probably recall compressibility occurs around .5M and is a significant factor in Parasite drag even before boundary layer separation occurs and leads to wave drag.

The Speed of sound is purely a function of temperature, which is calculated as 33.42*Sqrt(T) where T=degrees Rankin when calculating M=1 in mph.

Hoerner references even the .54M speed of 380mph for the Me109G at 22000 feet with 1200 hp as entering into the compressibility range. As you well know 380mph is even a higher percentage at 29 and 35000 feet

Abbott and Doenhoff (from vague memory) have a chapter on drag rise =>5% as the trip point for describing the compressibilty flight regime and for a Mustang that region was in the .63M to.65M range - which is 441mph at 29000 feet for STP

For other a/c like a 109G/K or P-38 or P-47 or FW 190D that Parasite drag growth of 5% due to compressibility occurs at a lower speed than the 51, the P-38 being a wonderful example of quickly moving from compressibility to all out wave drag in seconds when entering a dive at 20,000 feet when already at near max speed.

You are probably thinking what I was referencing was more aong the lines of wave drag caused by boundary layer separation in the transonic to sonic flight regime range. I wasn't. I was commenting on Hoerner's comments in Fluid Dynamic Drag in section 14-7 on 'Aerodynamic Efficiency" ----> where influence of compressibility was about the same magnitude (6%) as induced drag at max speed (7%)

The reason I brought up Compressibility effects to parasite drag is to further reference Hoerner's discussion in the last paragraph of 14-7 when he illustrated the 109G drag build up in his Fluid Dynamic Drag example.

Folks that attempt to extract CDo from top speeds of fast WWII fighters at altitude should get a higher Total Drag component at 30,000 feet than SL because compressibility is adding incremental drag over that which is calculated assuming incompressible flow...an additional delta less significantly present at SL dash speeds.

I mentioned the transonic/supersonic tip speed study based on NAA/USAAF reducing data from the P-51B-1 w/1650-3 engine test runs at 441mph at 29000 feet. They were dealing not only with raw compressibility drag rise due to the wing/body but also propeller effects on drag rise.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 02:28.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net