Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105 (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=48374)

Roger Gaemperle 15th June 2017 14:20

Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
1 Attachment(s)
Hello,

Attached is a - I guess - previously unknown photo of He 219 DV+DA, W.Nr. 190105. The photo comes from the photo album of a KG 26 air gunner. Unfortunately, I don't know where it was taken. But W.Nr. 190105 was attached to NJG 1 in 1944.

Cheers,

Roger

piero 15th June 2017 23:50

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Nice find!
Giampiero Piva

Harold Lake 16th June 2017 00:45

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
According to my data, DV+DA was the He 219 A-034, W.Nr. 190105. Many other preproduction examples, close to this aircraft, were assigned Versuch numbers so it would appear that this machine was probably delivered to the front soon after manufacture.

Hal

Marcel Hogenhuis 17th June 2017 00:13

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Roger,

Harold is right: He219A-0 W.Nr. 190105 was the 34th series produced A-0. It was transferred to Venlo airfield on 24 February 1944, the Stammkennzeichen changed into Verbandskennzeichen G9+DK. On 12 May 1944 this bird moved to the 4./NJG 1 were it was involved in a crashlanding on 4 June 1944. It's final fate is not known yet.

If you could sent me a high resolution scan for my He219 project, I would be very grateful: info(at)hogenhuis.info

All the best, Marcel Hogenhuis

S Sheflin 17th June 2017 04:21

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello,

First, thanks for posting this exciting new photo.

Second, are my old eyes fooling me or is there some form of linear equipment (other than the prop blade) extending out of the rear cockpit? Could it possibly be something related to ejection seat testing?

Respectfully,

Steve Sheflin

piero 17th June 2017 07:17

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by S Sheflin (Post 234967)
Hello,

First, thanks for posting this exciting new photo.

Second, are my old eyes fooling me or is there some form of linear equipment (other than the prop blade) extending out of the rear cockpit? Could it possibly be something related to ejection seat testing?

Respectfully,

Steve Sheflin

Radar boxes (2) with glare guards?
HTH
Giampiero Piva

Merlin 17th June 2017 15:05

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Marcel,

isn't the final fate not that event from 9.09.44: G9+DK shot down near Hopsten and reported as WNr. 290105?

Marcel Hogenhuis 17th June 2017 23:37

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Dear Gerhard,

You can scare someone (:-) but the Werkenr. 290105 first appeared in the lists of Verluste der Nachtjagdverbände from the late Hans Höhler (Gemeinschaft der Jagdflieger). This Werkenummer was copied into Roland Remp's wellknown He219 book.

First of all, the first He219 with a Werkenummer in the range 2901xx was actually 290110 and not sooner delivered then end of September 1944. Therefore 290105 cannot be correct.

Secondly, the Namentliche Verlustmeldung of the He219 which crashed near Hopsten gives another, more credible option: 210905, one of the first five, seriesproduced He219A-0's from Heinkel Rostock.

Case closed? One would say so but I have some contradictive references for 210905:

20 May 1944 : 1. Werkflug in Rostock (Flugbuch Lietsche)
13 June 1944 : transferred from Rostock to 2./NJGr.10 in Finow (EHW archive)
28 July 1944 : I./NJG 1, G9+EK, selbstbeschuss, belly landed Erbenheim (EHW archive)
31 July 1944 : 2./NJGr.10, 28 July 1944 selbstbeschuss, belly landed Erbenheim (EHW archive)
9 Sept.1944
: 2./NJG 1, G9+DK, Hopsten, 3 Tote (NVM= 210905)

Therefore, there might be a mix-up somewhere and there is still some margin of error.

Herzlichen Grüssen aus Venlo, Marcel

Marcel Hogenhuis 17th June 2017 23:59

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Dear Steve,

He219 A-0(34), DV+DA was not involved in any ejection seat tests. This was done with the preproduction He219V-6 (Werkenr. 190006, DH+PV) and later the series produced He219 A-042 (Werkenr. 190113, DV+DI)

Best regards, Marcel

Stig Jarlevik 18th June 2017 17:37

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Marcel

I am a bit confused over your WNr 210905 data
First of all can you recheck the dates 28 July 1944 and 31 July 1944.
Why do you again mention 28 July after 31 July on line 4?
Also why was this 219 moving almost like a jojo back and forth between NJGr 10 and NJG 1?

I also find Gerhard's comment very valid. Hadn't it been for the NVM details you quote, I would have said Gerhard was spot on. Since many of you find NVM far more reliable than the GQM lists I guess it should outweight anything else, but I have a nagging feeling this loss is not that easy....

Cheers
Stig

edNorth 18th June 2017 18:05

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stig Jarlevik (Post 235041)
Since many of you find NVM far more reliable than the GQM lists

Not arguing the point here. In 1944 they are THE source, due lack of comparable GQM reports, other periods both the GQM and NVM have errors - but as I am aware of, no real statistical survey has been performed on these documents accuracy. Am I right, NVM never have errors corrected but GQM have. -Ed

Marcel Hogenhuis 19th June 2017 11:03

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Stig

You are not the only one which is confused about the 210905 data and the 'jojo' like movements of this bird.

This confusion is caused by the Heinkel Archives in which two reports survived, referring to the same incident with 210905 in Wiesbaden Erbenheim:
- the first report (of 28 July 1944) refers to 210905, being an aircraft of the I./NJG 1 and even adding the Verbandskennzeichen G9+EK while their
- second report (of 31 July 1944) refers to the incident on 28 July, but now saying that the He219 belonged to the NJGr.10.

This second report has not been written as a correction to the 1th report but I think we should take it as a correction: this would be in line with the transfer from production to the NJGr.10 and so far I haven't been able to discover whether a He219 of the I./NJG 1 was flying operations in the direction of Wiesbaden.

That 210905 finally moved to the I./NJG 1 is not strange, I have several transfers of He219's from I./NJG 1 to Ekdo.Rechlin or II./NJG 1 as well.

Summaring it all: it is sometimes easier to rule out certain options (like the non existing 290105) than to present the truth what it correct. We struggle on...

Best regards, Marcel

Stig Jarlevik 19th June 2017 13:39

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Thanks Marcel

Well, not sure which foot I should rest on in this case. :)
Nice to see I am not the only one who is confused.... But I agree with your conclusion that the two dates refer to the same incident on 28 July.

Checking Michael Balss' two books, this incident is only mentioned in his first one, as WNr 290105, which we know is wrong!
Since Balss does not mention Höller in any of his books, I can only assume he has found the WNr outside his list, possibly or probably from the GQM lists, since if he had found the NVM he would at least have hesitated what to write.

What we now have are two aircraft with basically the same background and damage history.

190205 G9+DK 4./NJG 1 dam 4 June 1944 (no further records) BTW was it common that when aircraft were transferred between units, they kept their old unit codes? In this case G9+DK is a 2./NJG 1 code.
210905 G9+EK? 2./NJGr 10 dam 28 July 1944 (why would an aircraft delivered to 2./NJGr 10 from the outset be painted with a NJG 1 unit code?)

The question arises on what background information the two 'bodies' GQM and NVM based their statements on, and why they differ in this case.
If we move back to the two damage reports (4 June and 28 July) are they mentioned anywhere else beside the Heinkel documents you have, such as GQM? If yes, what WNrs are used and how grave was the actual damage in %? If no GQM reports are available, are there other sources available?

If the damage was rather small, my logic would have it that both aircraft should be brought back on line with the units they already served with. Whatever really happened, my logic of course means very little anyway :)

If I put out a hypothetical question here.
What would a clerk writing the NVM have done if he received the report that WNr 290105 had been destroyed? Since most individual on TOCH prefers the NVM I presume the clerk had to check all details received such as names, circumstances and presumably also aircraft details? Depending on how far such checks went is it possible he may have received the wrong info and made a mistake?

To me it is far easier to make a mistake and write 290105 instead of 190205 than having 210905 and write it as 290105. If you try it on a typewriter (not computer) you will see what I mean.

Cheers
Stig

he219research 19th June 2017 13:54

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
To further confuse matters...

Wasn't WNr 210905 shot down together with WNr 190128 during that training flight on 9/9´44?
In my records, I have 210905 listed as being shot down 9/9´44 at approx. 17:55 by P-51 Mustangs from 353rd FG, during a training flight to Rheine. Three fatalities: Ofw. Heinz Jadatz, Uffz. Alfred Schindler and Uffz. Heinrich Wennholz.

Just a few minutes later, at approx. 17:58, I have WNr 190128 listed as "crashed on landing" at Hopsten airbase (after presumably the same attack by US fighters).
Were both these He210A-0s indeed shot down during the same flight?

Stig Jarlevik 19th June 2017 17:58

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Yes He219research

That is correct and neither that date, action, individuals etc are in doubt.
What we are interested in is which aircraft WNr 290105 actually was.

Was it 210905 (as the NVM states) or 190105 (which Gerhard so wisely suggested)?

Cheers
Stig

Marcel Hogenhuis 20th June 2017 00:26

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Dear all,

Stig:
I have checked the sometimes quite difficult to read handwritten KTB of the I./NJG 1 and a diary of a Bordfunker from the 2./NJG 1. Now it gets interesting: the I./NJG 1 brought 14 aircraft in the air, 5 aircraft could not proceed with their mission because of technical malfunctions (one of these He219's was flown by this Bordfunker and his pilot), the majority of the He219's landed in 'Raum Wiesbaden' (!)
This makes it more credible that the incident at Wiesbaden-Erbenheim was indeed related to a He219 from the I./NJG 1. Now I must try to find documentary evidence when 210905 was transferred from the first operator NJGr.10 to the I./NJG 1...

He219research:
Your info is not in doubt, the purpose of the flight ("training") is unlogical: for which training purpose would they stuff 3 men (in 210905) and 4 men (in 190128) ? The NVM gives away the real purpose of these flights > both Heinkels were on a transfer flight from Münster-Handorf to Hopsten ("Überführung") for a temporary posting there. In such cases it was practice to take the first mechanic with them in the rear fuselage which had an emergency seat ('Notsitz') for such occasions.

Best regards, Marcel

Stig Jarlevik 20th June 2017 10:30

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Thanks Marcel

Hope you can clinch this one... :)

Cheers
Stig

Marcel Hogenhuis 20th June 2017 11:05

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Stig,

Sometimes one can have too much information but in this case it helps us to find the answers:

On an inventory of He219's from NJGr.10 in Finow 210905 is listed there. 210905 was slightly damaged on 28 July 1944 but 31 July 1944 'Einsatzklar'

The He219 which belly landed on Wiesbaden-Erbenheim airfield was actually 190178 and flown by Maj. Karlewski. This combat flight and landing on Erbenheim is recorded in his Flugbuch.

Best regards, Marcel

he219research 20th June 2017 16:24

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Thank you all for good information and an excellent discussion!

Stig Jarlevik 20th June 2017 18:46

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Thanks Marcel

I know what you mean :)

Also thanks for updating WNr 190128 into 190178.
May I ask from where WNr 190128 originates? Reason I ask is if NVM actually lists that loss as 190128? If it does then it would show that NVM is not always foolproof.....

Cheers
Stig

ju55dk 20th June 2017 20:31

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
NWM are not foolprof, but does have much less faults than the GQM.

Junker

Marcel Hogenhuis 24th June 2017 10:30

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Jörn,

I agree and one wonders where the GQM got their data from: apparantly not the units but the Luftflotten, whereas the NVM's were written (and signed!) by the unit commander or his deputy like the Major beim Stabe.

Best regards, Marcel

Rottler 24th June 2017 13:01

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Marcel,

the Luftflotte summarized the loss reports of the units and sent a telex (Fernschreiben) to the OKL, Gen.Qu. 6. Abteilung, a so called "Qu-Meldung". The loss report of the Gen.Qu. was an extract from the "Qu-Meldung".

For example:

Luftflottenkommando 6
Fernschreiben vom 1.2.45 an OKL Gen.Qu. 6. Abt.
Qu-Meldung Nr. 1022

Nr. 4 19.1. 3./N.S.G. 4 Feindflug, Halba bei Sagan. Notlandung wegen Verorientierung und Kraftstoffmangel, nicht feindbeobachtet.
Ju 87 D-3 W.-Nr. 110350, 1K+PM, 35%, (Ers.).
Vermisst: (F) Fw Such, Gerhard, (Bf) Ogefr Lenker, Hans.

This loss was published in the Gen.Qu.-report from 3.2.45 Nr. 56:

19.1. 3./N.S.G. 4 F Halba/Sagan Notlandung inf. Verorientierung
Ju 87 D-3 110350 35 Er
Fw Such, Gerhard F vermisst
Ogefr Lenker, Hans Bf vermisst.

Regards
Leo

Marcel Hogenhuis 24th June 2017 14:54

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Leo,

Thank you for your explanation which makes perfectly sense. Reading this I got an idea whether there are such Luftflotte Meldungen for the year 1944 ? I sure you know that just a small part of the GQM loss lists for 1944 survived WW-2. A small chance, but IF the Luftflotte Meldungen survived, this source could fill in that big gap.

Best regards, Marcel

Rottler 24th June 2017 18:20

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Marcel,

unfortunately there are no "Qu-Meldungen" for 1944.
Only some documents of the Luftflotte 6 from 1945 concerning the Eastern front survived the war.

Regards
Leo

edNorth 25th June 2017 03:34

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Thanks Leo for your post above. One interesting aspect unearthed. There were often 13 copies of GQM made, some of two sets survived (LFV and Schulen are in duplicatee). So there is still chance of one more koffort (wooden box) stashed in obscure place. France has been my best bet so far. Year 1944 was Battle for liberating France! -Ed

Marcel Hogenhuis 25th June 2017 09:28

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Hello Ed,

Well, let us not start that most puzzling theme in this thread :D
It once has been discussed what could have happened. Two options: 1) the original documents (if not deliberately destroyed) have been lost when they were still in German hands or 2) they were lost when in Allied posession.

Never give up any hope, after all the wooden panels with all victories of NJG 1 have been found in a German barn years ago...

Best regards, Marcel

TigerTimon 17th July 2019 17:42

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by he219research (Post 235152)
Thank you all for good information and an excellent discussion!

Quote:

Originally Posted by he219research (Post 235094)
To further confuse matters...

Wasn't WNr 210905 shot down together with WNr 190128 during that training flight on 9/9´44?
In my records, I have 210905 listed as being shot down 9/9´44 at approx. 17:55 by P-51 Mustangs from 353rd FG, during a training flight to Rheine. Three fatalities: Ofw. Heinz Jadatz, Uffz. Alfred Schindler and Uffz. Heinrich Wennholz.

Just a few minutes later, at approx. 17:58, I have WNr 190128 listed as "crashed on landing" at Hopsten airbase (after presumably the same attack by US fighters).
Were both these He210A-0s indeed shot down during the same flight?

Actually, they were not P-51 Mustangs, but P-47 Thunderbolts. The 353rd did only operate Mustangs from October 1944 on (source: http://www.americanairmuseum.com/unit/296).

Snautzer 24th February 2022 14:02

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
https://ww2aircraft.net/forum/thread...3#post-1713028


shot up Tail with 190128

Revi16 24th February 2022 15:32

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Snautzer (Post 316869)


That's an Me 210/410 tail.
https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/...762f5aa0_b.jpg

Stig Jarlevik 24th February 2022 16:17

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
As per Petrick/Stocker Me 410B-3 WNr 190128 was found on 5 April 1945 at Hanau/Langendiebach

Cheers
Stig

PS: At least one more photo has appeared on the net showing it to have the last two letters 'NH' on its rear
Possibly assigned to 2.(F)/122 like its "sibling" WNr 190127 as F6+NH?

Nick Beale 24th February 2022 17:10

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stig Jarlevik (Post 316878)
As per Petrick/Stocker Me 410B-3 WNr 190128 was found on 5 April 1945 at Hanau/Langendiebach … Possibly assigned to 2.(F)/122 like its "sibling" WNr 190127 as F6+NH?

No such aircraft appears in the operations diary of 2.(F)/122 during 1944 and 1945, all those mentioned were F6+_K.

190128 served with 1.(F)/121 in 1944, for example:
CX/MSS/R339(A),12

Strength return time-stamped 1030/15/10 signed Technical Officer:

Crews: 15 (11) 2 sick, 2 detached
1 EICHE ((Me 410)) W.Nr. 190128 under 32
9 FARN ((Me 109)) ((serv.)) 7
W.Nr. 20724 under 21, W.Nr. 163568 under 32
1 DAHLIE ((Fw 190)) ((serv.)) 1
1 Arado 96 ((serv.)) 1
NOTE: Source believes above from 1.(F)/121 to Recce Group 123.

Stig Jarlevik 24th February 2022 17:32

Re: Unknown photo He 219 DV+DA W.Nr. 190105
 
Thanks Nick

Answers my request for unit details on the other topic.
Got my wires crossed a bit in my PS. With your unit details the complete code is more likely 7A+NH

Cheers
Stig


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 07:06.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net