Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Wrecked Soviet Aircraft (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=50022)

Richard Mills 19th December 2017 22:01

Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
These 2 photographs of wrecked Soviet aircraft came as part of a lot which was the former property of a KG 1 DKiG Bordfunker.

I appreciate there is not a great deal of detail to go on however, if anyone can identify either or even both of these, I really would be very grateful.

Regards Richard.

kirche 19th December 2017 22:29

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
2th - it's Il-2

researcher111 19th December 2017 23:14

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
The acfts wrecks depicted are beyond any doubt IL-2 somewhere
in Germany or Poland by the end of 1944 or 1945 ( see the German DR oil cars
destined for Brandenburg or Nuerenberg )

Richard Mills 19th December 2017 23:30

Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kirche (Post 244424)
2th - it's Il-2

Quote:

Originally Posted by researcher111 (Post 244427)
The acfts wrecks depicted are beyond any doubt IL-2 somewhere in Germany or Poland by the end of 1944 or 1945 ( see the German DR oil cars destined for Brandenburg or Nuerenberg )

Thank you both very much indeed, it is much appreciated!

Regards Richard.

HGabor 19th December 2017 23:58

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
With due respect, I doubt this would be Poland or Germany, especially in 1944, or 1945. Soviet AC red stars were not used without white outline in those late years, so this must be still in 1941 or 1942 somewhere in the Soviet Union with a German supply train.
Gabor

Mihai Pica 20th December 2017 10:30

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
Agree with HGabor, especially as the first wreck looks like a Sukhoi Su-2 which has no place in 1944/45

kirche 20th December 2017 17:24

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
1st - it's really Su-2
Il-2s - 1941-1942 - early

Richard Mills 20th December 2017 18:26

Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
Thanks to all who have replied.

Sukhoi Su-2 and Il 2 it is then, and I am really pleased to of been able to positively identify them.

As a point of interest I will re-scan, enlarge and re-post the destination sign of the DR oil car over the next few days.

Thanks again, Richard.

researcher111 20th December 2017 21:58

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
Gabro

If the 1st is a SU-2 then definitely year was 1941 or 1942 .

HGabor 20th December 2017 22:40

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
Yes, these are Su-2 and IL-2 wrecks in the Soviet Union still in 1941 or 1942, most likely with a German military supply train.
Cheers,
Gabor

researcher111 21st December 2017 11:23

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
If we go by the owner of the photo from Luftflotte I the SU-2 originated from Baltics
or Stalingrad area Regiment ,though on Baltics there were no SU-2's, also looked into my
numerous books on SU-2 trying to identify the paint, perhaps Richard could rescan the
photo along with clearer DR car destination tag.

There is a possibility that above SU-2 belonged to a Stalingrad Regiment possibly
in 1942. I did scan you a page from my book as into your remark that the year
in question was 41 or 42 .

Alex K

PS : Note that by 1943 several SU2 regiments still operated with no white outline
on the star in addition the SU-2 was removed from active front duties
by early 1944.

HGabor 21st December 2017 14:39

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
Either-or, still in the Soviet Union.

researcher111 21st December 2017 15:24

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
My original statement indicated Soviet Union or Poland and that
still applies

HGabor 21st December 2017 15:27

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
??? No. Your original statement indicated Poland or Germany by the end of 1944, or 1945. But never mind.

researcher111 21st December 2017 15:38

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
No,my revised statement once we spoke about SU2 states Stalingrad or Baltics, so as you say never mind !

Richard Mills 11th January 2018 21:38

Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
I finally got around to having another look at the photo with the rail car destination/information sign, the problem is the photo is actually not in very sharp focus.

Anyway, I have re-scanned the pertinent part (600 dpi, I tried 1200 dpi but it was just mush) however, with the image not being in focus I am not sure if anything can be gleaned to be honest.

Regardless of that, thanks to all who have contributed and it is much appreciated.

Regards Richard.

researcher111 11th January 2018 22:42

Re: Wrecked Soviet Aircraft
 
It looks like destination Brandenburg


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 22:51.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net