Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Pre-WW2 Military and Naval Aviation (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=34)
-   -   Photo Nieuport (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=56438)

musec04 27th February 2020 21:06

Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of Nieuport 17 N1420 of Escadrille N103 at :


https://www.ebay.de/itm/FOTO-FLUGZEU...AAAOSwQC9eVpY-


Regards,


Clint

Buckeye30 28th February 2020 14:59

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Clint. The star was formerly carried by VB103, the Nieuport captured in 1916; there are several other photos of it showing the big spinner. N103 used Roman numerals, the "V" was repeated on top left wing.
Regards
Nick

musec04 28th February 2020 20:54

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Nick,


Thanks for the further info. Looks like I could have posted the photo in my captured french aircraft thread based on your information.


Another two Nieuport photos are currently on ebay at :


https://www.ebay.de/itm/RP-Realphoto...sAAOSwmAheWVs8


and :


https://www.ebay.de/itm/RPPC-Soldate...wAAOSw33FeWVrL


I note in the time it has taken to post the auction on the first of these has already ended. Hopefully it can still be seen. I also note German aircraft in the background, so presumably also captured.



Regards,


Clint

Col Bruggy 29th February 2020 07:11

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,

More photos and information on Nieuport XVII Nr.1420, here:

http://albindenis.free.fr/Site_escad...adrille103.htm

and ...

KEK Vaux (-En-Vermandois) (Chapter 8).

The seventh victory for von Althaus came on 2 July (1916), when he shot down a Nieuport 11 'Bebe' (Baby) or scout of Escadrille F 114. On the same day, Escadrille N 103 reported a Nieuport 17 as missing; both aircraft were operating in the same area. The plane had the serial number 1420 and seems to have been pictured in a photo album of a member of FFA 23. The Nieuport piloted by MdL (Andre) Seigneurie, was captured intact.

See:
KEKs and Fokkerstaffels The Early German Fighter Units in 1915-1916
Ryheul,Johan
N.p.:Fonthill Media,2014
p.88

Col.

Buckeye30 29th February 2020 15:18

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Clint. I know you are interested in A-H in WW1, I have an old article in FLYING REVIEW (Jan. 1960) on Frigyes Hefty's baling-out from his Albatros (Flik.42J) on 22 Aug. 1918 shot down by a Hanriot; would you like me to scan it in sometime?
Nick
Col. thanks for the additions.

Stig Jarlevik 29th February 2020 15:48

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Buckeye30 (Post 283688)
Hi Clint. The star was formerly carried by VB103, the Nieuport captured in 1916; there are several other photos of it showing the big spinner. N103 used Roman numerals, the "V" was repeated on top left wing.
Regards
Nick

Nick
Just so nobody misunderstands your statement. The unit was Esc 103 all the time. The French used a prefix to emphasize their units main equipment.
When using Voisin bombers, thus VB103 and when the Nieuport became the main equipment the prefix (only) switched to N.
Cheers
Stig

Stig Jarlevik 29th February 2020 15:51

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by musec04 (Post 283703)
Hi Nick,


Thanks for the further info. Looks like I could have posted the photo in my captured french aircraft thread based on your information.


Another two Nieuport photos are currently on ebay at :


https://www.ebay.de/itm/RP-Realphoto...sAAOSwmAheWVs8


and :


https://www.ebay.de/itm/RPPC-Soldate...wAAOSw33FeWVrL


I note in the time it has taken to post the auction on the first of these has already ended. Hopefully it can still be seen. I also note German aircraft in the background, so presumably also captured.



Regards,


Clint

The first Nieuport looks like a 17 and carries the serial N1831 (or possibly N1834. Another photo has been sold on e-bay where the serial can be seen much more clearly.
I also believe the unit is N86 but with the shooting star painted a bit more flamboyant than usual.

The second one looks like a two-seater. Any taker for an ID?

Cheers
Stig

Buckeye30 29th February 2020 19:46

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Stig. The Nieuport XVII N1831 in the photo was from N.77 (SPA.77 from August 1917),their insignia was a cross of Jerusalem on a pennant but some XVIIs had elaborate personal emblems, the comet was Ltt. Jose Maria ( POW). It was repeated on top of the fuselage.

N.86 had a winged star rather than a comet, mostly on SPADS.
I hope I havn't got my facts wrong !!!
Nick
The other looks like a Nie.10 or early 12, later had different cowlings.

Stig Jarlevik 29th February 2020 21:30

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Buckeye30 (Post 283770)
Hi Stig. The Nieuport XVII N1831 in the photo was from N.77 (SPA.77 from August 1917),their insignia was a cross of Jerusalem on a pennant but some XVIIs had elaborate personal emblems, the comet was Ltt. Jose Maria ( POW). It was repeated on top of the fuselage.

N.86 had a winged star rather than a comet, mostly on SPADS.
I hope I havn't got my facts wrong !!!
Nick
The other looks like a Nie.10 or early 12, later had different cowlings.

Thanks Nick
So it was a personal emblem. Oh well, the aircraft is certainly not carrying any N77 unit markings. The French obviously did pretty much as they wanted to.... :)

Indeed the second one is a 10 or 12, but which one?

Cheers
Stig

Bertrand H 1st March 2020 09:20

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
#4

Many thanks Col. for having matched the loss of this captured Nieuport with the info put in the book of Johan Ryheul (that I have). I think you have "milked" this book and put details in your data.

Very appreciated.

Bertrand

musec04 1st March 2020 12:56

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


Thanks to everyone for their responses.


There are some photographs and a colour profile of N1831 in German markings at:


https://www.pinterest.co.uk/pin/291959988326149761/


and speaking of Nieuport machines in foreign colours there is a photo of Italian Nieuport 17 N3242 (at least I assume that it is both a Nieuport 17 and Italian) at:


https://www.ebay.it/itm/Grande-Guerr...UAAOSwRsJeVZV0


and some less clear Italian machines here:


https://www.ebay.it/itm/n-2-foto-WW1...cAAOSwa5Rd~-m0



Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 1st March 2020 15:47

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Clint

It is not N3242 but Ni 3242. The latter looks like Model 11 to me and with such a high Italian serial number is most likely a Macchi built one. The Italian company started its days as Nieuport-Macchi with the sole pupose of building Niuport models under licence. They "advanced" up the ladder by also building the Hanriot HD.I....

They also designed some parasol types based upon the Nieuport fuselage.
A very interesting company

Cheers
Stig

Buckeye30 1st March 2020 16:12

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Stig. 3242 is in full Italian markings ie. cowling red-white-green sections and red-green panels under the wings. The serial style is Macchi. It was quite common for personal emblems to be painted over the fuselage cocardes.

I think the 2-seater pictured above with damaged tail is a Nie.10, the 12 had a large clear panel in the top wing, wider chord top wing and the tops of the "V" struts were further apart.
Regards
Nick

Stig Jarlevik 1st March 2020 16:39

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Indeed Nick

However since Macchi also imported some basic airframes before starting their own production and most likely painted them up as well in Italian colours, I simply was cautious :)

With regard to the Nie 10 or 12, I think you might be correct

Cheers
Stig

PS: Nice to see more individuals joining Clint and me in the discussion of real "oldtimer" airframes. Very rewarding!!

Buckeye30 2nd March 2020 16:43

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Stig. This shows the cowling markings in red-white-green which I mentioned (sometimes reversed); a Nie.11 from 78th Sqd. Mostly seen on Type 11s.
The propeller seems to be solid not laminated?



Nick

musec04 15th March 2020 22:19

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay a photo of a Nieuport serial N275. at:


https://www.ebay.fr/itm/Aviation-pho...UAAOSwClNeblG3


The seller has it as a Nieuport XII, but is it in fact a Nieuport 10?


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 16th March 2020 15:22

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Looks like a single-seater to me...
Model 11 perhaps??

Cheers
Stig

Buckeye30 18th March 2020 16:27

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Stig. It's a Nieuport 10C.1 single seater, this is N.237 from the same batch; unit is MS.12 (note parasols in background).
Nick



https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...cropped%29.jpg

musec04 18th March 2020 16:42

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello Nick,


Thanks for the response and particularly the image. I must admit my thinking when I identified the aircraft was based on the serial number. Apart from the useful site at :



http://albindenis.free.fr/Site_escad...fabricants.htm


can you recommend any good single source for Nieuport serials?


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 18th March 2020 16:48

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Thanks Nick

So they came as single-seaters as well.
No wonder I have problems with these early Nieuports.

Cheers
Stig

Buckeye30 19th March 2020 14:10

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Sorry Clint don't know of any on the net; Ray Rimell did a Windsock "Datafile Special" on Nieuports so probably had a listing (his Fokker and Albatros Datafiles did).
For future reference these are RFC Nieuports ( not RNAS though); "Type 20" was developed from the 12 and was very similar ( 21 went to RFC).


http://www.airhistory.org.uk/rfc/Nieuport.html


Squadron assignments....
Type 10. 1,39,45,46 Sqns.
Type 12. 45,46,,84,10(Naval) Sqns.
Type 20. 1,45,46 Sqns.
Some Nie.12s were transferred from RNAS to 46 Sqn. (20 I think).
The RNAS called them "Nieuport 2-seaters".
Regards
Nick

musec04 22nd March 2020 16:55

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello Nick,


Thanks for the info I've ordered both volumes of the datafile specials.


Additionally currently on ebay a photo of a line up of Nieuports including N1590 and N1420? currently at:


https://www.ebay.fr/itm/Aviation-pho...QAAOSw0yJed2iX


captioned as Nieuport 17, but is that a 16 I see low down on the rudder of the foremost machine?


Regards,


Clint

Buckeye30 22nd March 2020 19:00

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Clint. It's N1390 ( Type 16), this photo shows the difference between "3" and "5".



https://ww2aircraft.net/forum/media/...-1916-2.26683/


Could be N.124 at Bar-le-Sec in 1916, the Type 11 marked "RUM" looks like Laurence Rumsey's N.1290. Sometimes the type number was marked low on the rudder very small but not often I think (sometimes on 24s and 27s).
Wasn't N.1420 the captured Nieuport marked "V" you posted not long ago (Esc.103)? Maybe it's 1120.
I did some more digging and the 2 Windsock Specials cover the single-seaters, the Nieuport 10/12 were in a normal Datafile, no.68; maybe on e-bay but pricey now I reckon. Hope I didn't mislead you.

Nick

musec04 22nd March 2020 19:11

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hell Nick,


Thanks for the information and corrections. My first thought was actually N1120, but I thought I saw the bar of the 4. I guess not.


Fear not about the WDF specials its all good information and at the same time I've ordered Les Freres Nieuport et leurs Avions by the Pommier brothers. Hopefully it will be helful.


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 22nd March 2020 19:14

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Clint (and Nick)

As I very thoroughly have shown before, I have a great difficulty in seing any difference between various Nieuport single-seaters and two-seaters, I don't believe my help is very useful, but here we go...

I would say each serial visible have two basic interpretations
N1590 and N1420 or
N1390 and N1120

Taking them one by one
N1120 seems to be either a type 11 or 12
N1390 seems to be a type 16
N1420 is identified as a type 17
N1590 seems to be a type 17

Cheers
Stig

Buckeye30 23rd March 2020 16:44

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Stig. The 11s, 16s and 17s can be identified by a couple of details....
Type 11 "horseshoe" cowling, no headrest.
Type 16 " " , headrest added.
Type 17 full cowling, plus headrest.
.................................................. .

The first 3 here are 16s, the rest 11s, all camouflaged with unpainted cowlings.
N.1120 is a Nie.16; N.1420 was Type 17, definitely Esc.N.103 and captured. N.1590 would be Type 17.

"RUM" is N.1290 Type 11 ( Rumsey).
"R" probably Kiffen Rockwell N.1116 Type 11.
7th aircraft with "X" may be N.1585 Type 11 Didier Masson.
Lafayette / N.124 commonly used pilot's initials ( "C" =Elliot Cowdin, "P" = Norman Prince, "RL" = Lufbery). Sometimes repeated on top wing ( "RUM" had white chevron).
The Type 16s were "nose-heavy" due to the bigger engine ( 110 from 80 hp.).

Nick

Stig Jarlevik 23rd March 2020 21:52

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Thanks Nick

Yes I know some of the basics, but what does one do when the cowling is not visible?
How 'bout the model 24bis and the trainer versions in the 80 range?
No I still don't like designs with such subtle differences. :)

Also thanks for the ID of the aircraft we are looking at.
Somewhere I think I have seen this photo before, but it would take ages to find it (if I really do have it.....)

Good to have a couple of Aces around, when Clint is working overtime to find interesting WW I photos.
Everyone's efforts are highly appreciated by me!!

Cheers
Stig

PS: Since you identified the third aircraft as a model 16 (headrest) it cannot be N1116 which you say was a model 11, even if this one also carries a 'R'.

Buckeye30 24th March 2020 18:59

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Oops! I got confused, blame my age.
N1116 was an 11 but flown by Norman Prince as "P"; Rockwell's "R" was also an 11 but was N1454 (May 1916).
The "R" shown here is a 16 with a 4-digit number - possibly Adj. ROBERT Rockwell but the letter is a different style to Kiffin's.


The Nieuport 80s had an 80hp so hard to tell from the other 2-seaters if you don't know the serial. Some went to the USAS training bases, most Nieuports would have gone to the big general flying fields ( there were 15) at Issoudun. The others were...
Tours and Chatillon-sur-Seine (observers).
Clermont-Ferrand ( bombing)
St. Jean de Monte (aerial gunners)
Souse, Mencon and Coetquidan ( artillery ranging).
The single-seaters had different chord cowlings depending on the engine size but not always obvious.
Nick

Stig Jarlevik 24th March 2020 19:28

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Thanks for the update Nick

Can I also say "welcome to the Club", with that meaning those of us who also been there and done that... "darn mistake"...:)

Good to know I am not the only one....

Cheers
Stig

musec04 25th March 2020 21:23

Re: A Russian Nieuport
 
Hello,


Today on ebay at:



https://www.ebay.com/itm/Russia-Mosc...8AAOSwvTpaJNjH


is a photo of a Russian Nieuport


Regards,


Clint

musec04 26th March 2020 13:53

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a Nieuport 17 belonging to Charles Nungesser, Nieuport 17 N1895, perhaps? at:


https://www.ebay.it/itm/photo-ww1-pi...sAAOSw8RFed5-5


Regards,


Clint

Buckeye30 27th March 2020 00:00

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi Clint. I think more likely to be Nie.17 N1571 ( N65) 1916; it had a large spinner and fitting for Lewis gun and tri-colour bands on top wings.
His Nie.17 N1895 ( and re-serialled 24bis) didn't have a spinner.
Nick

musec04 13th April 2020 22:07

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


On 13.04.20 there are two photos of captured Nieuport scouts one definitely Russian, the other Italian? at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/M71-Beuteflu...0AAOSw59pelJAK


https://www.ebay.de/itm/M74-Isonzofr...kAAOSwl05elJM2



Any further information welcomed.Is the machine with the Horseshoe Nieuport 17 3625 of 81 Squadriglia reported captured intact?


Also I've identified the Russian machine a Nieuport 17 of 19 KAO. See http://vvs.hobbyvista.com/Research/N...eet1/index.php Although the serial number given is a little unusual. Anything more on that?




Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 14th April 2020 00:48

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Clint

If you look again at the captured Italian Nieuport you will see it is a Type 27.
In fact it is a French built aircraft sold (given?) to the Italians, N 5836.
It was given the Austrian ID 00.71 but I doubt it ever carried that serial number.

Cheers
Stig

musec04 14th April 2020 00:56

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello Stig,


Thanks. Well I'm improving at least I thought that it was a 27 when I first saw the photo before putting down the wrong information. I was too easily mislead by the 81 on the fuselage and then went straight to Gentilli and Varriale I Reparti which of course has the info on 3625.. I take it that N 5836 was a 81 Sqa machine though?


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 14th April 2020 01:09

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Must have been Clint

Can't see any other reason for that prominent 81 on the fuselage.

Cheers
Stig

musec04 14th April 2020 21:03

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


Today there is a photo of Nieuport 23 A6783 of 40 Squadron on ebay at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/Foto-notgela...sAAOSw931effhX


Regards,


Clint

musec04 24th April 2020 21:43

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


On 24.04.20 this is a photo of a Nieuport 24 No.3934 at:


https://www.ebay.com/itm/2-Lot-WWI-P...gAAOSw8gBeoxPt


Regards,


Clint

musec04 28th April 2020 16:49

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hello,


Today another Nieuport 24 photo, the remains of No.4406 at:


https://www.ebay.com/itm/Original-WW...cAAOSwkW5eS-tF


Regards,


Clint

Bertrand H 6th May 2020 09:02

Re: Photo Nieuport
 
Hi,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a Nieuport 11, N1135 belonging to Cne Jean de Sieyes de Veynes of Escadrille N26 who landed in German lines on 3 july 1916.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/i117-German...wAAOSwIKNcBD06

Bertrand


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 00:18.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net