![]() |
Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently for sale on ebay is a photo of Aviatik B.I 659/14 named Koblenz at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/AK-Deutsches...4AAOSwhD9eX93G Is anyone aware of the unit that operated this machine? There is a further image of an Aviatik B.347 at : https://www.ebay.de/itm/Foto-AK-Flug...kAAOSwz8teWgqw This may be noteworthy as B.347/14 seems a possible option as there is an immediately number range appearing to cover B.330/14 to B.344/14 but I have not previously seen serial B.347/14 assigned in published sources. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Quote:
The problem is that everywhere I look, the aircraft seems to carry the number 3347 (check the blow up). Not that that actually makes me any wiser, since I cannot find any B (or C) type carrying such a number either. Neither Grosz nor Herris is helpful with their publications. A very intriguing find Nick Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Stig,
Granted, the serial on the tail does look very like 3347. However, as your checks have already revealed the only year in which a serial for B.3347 exists is 1917 and an LVG B.III (Schul). As for a C.3347 1916,1917 and 1918 are already accounted for leaving only 1915. The nearest serial I have for 1915 is C.3309 for an LVG C.III so not promising either. Now C.3547/15 was a Aviatik C.I, but I don't believe either of use feel that the second figure on the tailplane is a 5. My question to you is, do you think the first two charecters on the tailplane are identical? Clearly having decided that the serial is B.347/14,I don't but I do understand your reservations.I read it as a cursive B. Am I sure I'm correct? Well frankly,no. But would the first charecter on the tailplane not logically be a letter rather than a number and the little that can be seen of the first charecter on the fuselage is while consistent with a 3 also consistent with a B. and B.347/14 is at least an option that fits with other known serials. I have photographic images of B.344/14 prior to B.347 and either B.350/14 or B.352 succeeding it. Were I to see any C series Aviatik machines in proximity to C.3347/15 at a future date I would necessarily have to reconsider and I very much understand your doubts. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
|
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Bertrand,
Thanks for the response. Is that image from the first photo of the seller or from the second close up image? If its from the second I'm not sure that we're any closer to being able to definitely say whether it is B.347 or 3347. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Clint/Bertrand
Don't know how you managed to twist the photo around that way Bertrand, but it makes me feel a bit more uneasy about the digits actually being 3347. I was comfortable enough to assign a certain fuzziness in the photo to dismiss the initial 3 as being a B, but now I am not comfortable at all. To be honest, I "hate" situations like this, where you are so close, just inches away to finally grab it when it gently slides away....if you know what I mean. Things don't get any better that whatever we choose we are still left wondering what it really was... :) Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Clint/Stig
The image came from the second close up. I do not know if it is an official factory made writing or an help for the ground crew. If it is the second way, you know that you can write very quickly and sometimes your writing is only for you and not the other people.... Bertrand |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Bertrand/Stig,
I've been checking some further images of Aviatik B.I in the serial range inthe vicinity of a putative B.347/14. Both B.342/14 and B.344/14 show the same type of tail insignia as the machine we're talking about. All three machines show the cross as composed of, as it were, four seperate triangles. This is not, as far as I'm aware the case for any Aviatik C.I. Definite evidence for identifying the machine as B.347/14? Once again no.As you say Stig "I "hate" situations like this, where you are so close, just inches away to finally grab it when it gently slides away" How very true. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Clint. I think a few more (not many) German aeroplanes used that style of insignia in 1914-16, this document is dated April 1916; sure I've seen one or two Albatros Bs with it.
Nick https://www.warmuseum.ca/firstworldw...a-recognition/ |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Nick,
Thanks for the response. What I was aiming at in my last post, was particularly that the type of cross appeared to rule out a Aviatik C type, specifically a putative 3347. What would interest me, is whether any of the other photos you've seen were carried by machines constructed later than 1914. So de facto ruling out an Aviatik C type. No doubt other 1914 built, machines did carry this style of cross, including the Aviatik B.659/14 Koblenz shown in the first link in this thread. While totally accepting Stig's view that a definitive identification of the machine in the photo as B.347/14 remains elusive, I would tend to regard the circumstantial evidence as pointing more strongly in that direction than for 3347, the style of cross being just one more eleement supporting the case, along with the serial fitting into a known series. I'm also increasing tending to view the first charecter on the fuselage as different from the second, but would readily admit confirmation bias is probably coming into play on my part! Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
This is an Albatros C.1 rather than Aviatik but with early cross; as luck would have it no serial on fuselage. Maybe you know when these C-types were built? I imagine training machines would keep their original markings longer than on operations.
Nick |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Nick,
Thanks for the photo.Well as you're probably aware the Albatros C.I dates from 1915. The first being C.15/15 although OAW, also part of the Albatros company had built their own different design with earlier serials. I worry about looking as though I'm nitpicking here,that is not my intenton, just clarity, but if you examine both B.659/14 and the possible B.347/14 it is the very tips of the apex of the triangles which meet. The execution of the cross on the Albatros C.I is subtely different. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Clint. I suspect the result depended on who was painting it , some made them more elaborate. There are 2 styles on this Albatros; the rules were followed more strictly in WW2 ( but by no means always).
I remember an RAF ground-crew telling how they hand-painted squadron code letters on their Typhoons and they all differed ( partly done to relieve the boredom). Looks like the tail numbers on your Aviatik were done by hand too. Nick |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay there is a photo of Aviatik B.I 664/14 of FEA 6 at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/SUPERSELTEN-...IAAOSwpB5enFV6 Aviatik B.I 661/14 'Bussard' at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/SUPERSELTEN-...kAAOSw8NNenFnA Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Clint
It is the same aircraft, ie B.661/14 You can faintly see the name Bussard on the photo from rear slightly right side. The environment is also the same. Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello Stig,
Thanks for the sharp eyes. I guess I rushed it as both serials do belong to the same batch of Aviatik B.I. Subsequent edit B.661/14 in any event a DFW B.II not an Aviatik B.I Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a photo of Aviatik B.I B.670/14 at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/Lot-2x-Foto-...kAAOSw0nlerFmE Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a photo of an overturned German aircraft which I believe may be an Aviatik P.13 at : https://www.ebay.com/itm/i109-German...4AAOSw5-hcBDzz I have may thoughts on what the serial number may be, but I'm wondering how other board users read it? Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
That is sticking my neck out a bit far Clint....
B.60?? No it is too much guesswork... Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Stig,
Well I was going to go B.59, so at least we're in the same ballpark. I believe I've seen B.55/13 and B.62/13 is in Peter M Grosz WDF 102 P.1. So potentially, but not definitely there is a possibility of a batch of P 13. Though it may stretch past B.62/13. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay there is a photo of, I believe, an early Aviatik B.I (P15) although frankly it might just be an LVG B.I in a tree at: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/WW1-Germa...YAAOSw3C5e09UQ Can anyone read the numbers on the tail at all? Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a photo of Aviatik B.I B.119/13 following a crash at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/original-Fot...AAAOSwu2Re4gRv Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a photo of Aviatik B.I (P 14) B.107/14 named Cassel at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/WK1-Foto-Aub...sAAOSwIW1fGfQ~ This is an interesting find as I've not previously seen this serial on any published lists (unless anyone knows otherwise). Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on eby are a series of photos of Aviatik B.I machines of FFA 34 at: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4927-Fot...UAAOSwr4VfOPof https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4937-Fot...AAAOSwhOJfOPyT https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4930-Fot...8AAOSw5~tfOPr1 The machine is probably B.707/14 Aviatik B.I B.352/14 can be seen here: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4920-Fot...UAAOSwDnlfOPf7 https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4921-Fot...UAAOSwKQNfOPhy Aviatik B.I B.66*/14 AT: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4922-Fot...QAAOSwj8ZfOPig Also, can anyone read the serial on this photo?: https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/X4918-Fot...oAAOSwcMxfOPd- Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
|
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Bertrand,
B.665/14 makes a lot of sense, in so far as it too was an Aviatik B.I. Thanks for the assistance. A nice little collection from that seller. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Interesting set of photos
Clint Given the more than usual useless information from the seller, how do you make the connection to FFA 34? Also why do you suggest B.707/14 as the plausible one? Bertrand Nice try as usual. With the known B.I batches, I would go for the B.665/14 Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello Stig,
As for FFA 34, both B.707/14 and B.352/14 are known to have served with that unit. Johan Ryheul in KEKs and Fokkerstaffels P.181 has a photo of B.707/14 having been shot down while crewed by Ltn.d.R. Fritz Rößler and Vfw Arntzen. The former name is on the back of one of the photos, as I believe, on another seperate photo is the writing B707, if I recall correctly. A photo of B.352/14 was posted on the Aerodrome in the past also.I think given Bertrand's photo we all agree B.665/14 and given the other aircraft I think we can provisionally asign that too to FFA 34. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Thanks Clint
I was just curious... :) Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a further Aviatik B.I B.268/13 at: https://www.ebay.de/itm/z32-Belgien-...8AAOSwAgpfOiwV Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on delcampe is a photo of the end Aviatik B.I B.707/14 of FFA 34 as referenced in post #24 of this thread at: https://www.delcampe.net/fr/collecti...106537182.html Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a photo of Aviatik B.I B.220/13 at: https://www.ebay.fr/itm/PHOTO-ORIGIN...UAAOSwCudfoatB Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is a photo of Aviatik B.I (P 13) B.63/13 of FFA 4 at: https://www.ebay.fr/itm/PHOTO-ORIGIN...cAAOSw~75fz7H0 This is a pleasing find as I don't believe that this serial has been previously published. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hello,
Currently on ebay is an intriguing photo AT: https://www.ebay.de/itm/X5813-Foto-W...MAAOSw0iRf1Qmm The aircraft is an Aviatik B.I (P 14?) The propeller has a cover with the script B 38 upon it (B.38/14?/ coincidence?) There is also some harder to read writing nearer to the spinner. Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
|
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Bertrand,
Thanks for trying. I can't make anything of it. How about you. Any thoughts on what it says? Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Even if the cover script can be deciphered, the evidence for that regarding the actual aircraft would anyway be circumstantial :)
Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Hi Stig,
Indeed, but I'll take three pieces of circumstantial evidence, rather than two when I can get them.:) So, I can't persuade you to take crack at what the wording actually is? Regards, Clint |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Sorry Clint
No walking on tight ropes for me.... :) Cheers Stig |
Re: Photo Aviatik B.I
Reasonable enough.
So related to this, not too tenuously I hope. Have you come across any Aviatik B machines in the range B.32/14 to B.39/14 other than B.32/14 and B.36/14? Or indeed anything in that range that is not an Aviatik? Regards, Clint |
| All times are GMT +2. The time now is 07:10. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net