Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=5722)

Jim P. 17th August 2006 17:59

17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
On 17-May-1940 2./JG 76 was involved in a scrap with GC I/5. According to 'Die Jagdfliegerverbände, III' and, I think, the loss, Joachim Schypek was WIA and baled out of his machine. However, in Gillet's 'Les victoires de la chasse francaise, II' on page 35 an entry Schypek's logbook shows that he was flying WNr. 6127 and did not report him taking to his chute. As a matter of fact looking at my own copy of the Schypek FB he continued flying WNr. 6127 on the 18th & 20th of May. Gillet continues and appears to be quoting from French documentation to the effect that the actual pilot shot down was Bernd Schulten.

My French being not so good, I was wondering if any members of the board from France or other French speakers who may have this book could give a more exact translation/synopsis of this event.

christian 17th August 2006 23:20

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Hi

It was Lt. Bernhard Schulten. He was shot down at Hirson-Area and came to the Reserve Lazarett Frankfurt/Main with wounds. The I./JG 76 became the message about Schulten at the 19.05.1940. On the 25.05.1940 he came back to his unit.

Greetings Christian

Jim P. 18th August 2006 18:07

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Thank you Christian.

Chris Goss 18th August 2006 18:16

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Jim: Same story is repeated in '12 Days In May' which was not substantiated by Schypek when I interviewed him some years ago

Jim P. 18th August 2006 18:59

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Gettin' old bites - read the book several years ago and have absolutely no remembrance of reading about that incident. Thank you.

However, your statement 'not substantiated by Schypek' leaves me somewhat confused. Did he just not remember the incident or was he indeed WIA (even though his FB says otherwise)? Trying to clarify as part of a database project. We can take this off-line if you'd prefer.

Chris Goss 18th August 2006 19:53

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
He was not shot down nor was he wounded. As his logbook says, Lt Schulten abgeschossen!

Jim P. 23rd August 2006 01:42

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Having had a chance to review '12 Days in May' it appears, unless there is a later edition than the one I have, that the authors attribute the 2./JG 76 loss in question on 17-May-1940 to Schypek. So far it appears that only Gillet has noted and corrected the conflict in a published source - Schulten vs. Schypek. At least amongst the sources I know. I have a copy of Schypek's FB and certainly hadn't noticed the conflict between this and other sources. Cudos to Mr. Gillet. Hope it adds to the recording of an accurate record of the campaign in May 1940.

ouidjat 15th September 2017 11:16

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Actually, "Raucourt bei Origny" or "bei Origny" alone, "Bei Hirson" means nothing.
1st you have to discover which Origny you're talking about from Normandy to Alsace and, 2nd ... Same thing with Raucourt.
...
Here is your place: Raucourt-au-Bois. And old auction.

Cheers, Franck.

Peter Cornwell 16th September 2017 10:35

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Franck,

Interesting. I have another view of this aircraft captioned as 'La Raminoise', which is SE of Artaise-le-Vivier, a little west of Huttes-de-Raucourt, SSW of Raucourt-et-Flaba ?

Location apart, exactly what other evidence is there to connect SCHULTEN with this Black 7 ?

robert 16th September 2017 12:25

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Peter I think we have also then and now photos confirming our location.

Regards

Robert

Peter Cornwell 18th September 2017 10:35

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Yes, location of the belly-landing of Black 7 is well established but the exact date and identity of the pilot still remain open to question.

ouidjat 21st September 2017 10:26

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter Cornwell (Post 239748)
Yes, location of the belly-landing of Black 7 is well established ...

Hummmm .... Thank you Peter,

Interesting!
And HOW it has been "well" established; I mean by which way(s) ?
And this well known - by who? - has been published somewhere? I'm curious to know that ... And a lot of French guys, friends, fans, writers, historians ... with me :)

Regards, Franck.

PS I forgot, what is that place? As for the pilot it's written in the first two posts.

robert 21st September 2017 19:46

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
It`s had been established by one of our team members. He found the place and took photos of a farm, which could be seen in background of some of the photos showing this aircraft. It will be published in our forthcoming book.
So stay easy.

Regards

Robert

bn785371 21st September 2017 21:15

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Hi,any idea when this forthcoming book will be published?

robert 21st September 2017 23:26

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Hope that in a couple of years.

Robert

ouidjat 22nd September 2017 17:46

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by robert (Post 239927)
It`s had been established by one of our team members. He found the place and took photos of a farm, which could be seen in background of some of the photos showing this aircraft. It will be published in our forthcoming book.
So stay easy.

Regards

Robert

Thank you Robert.
I'm afraid I'll be dead before . :) Ah, by the way: your "team", EOE?..

steve sheridan 22nd September 2017 18:00

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
With regards to Franck and the EOE project, I note nobody responded to my appeal for an update on the 3.7.17.
Its gone very quiet on this project and I wonder whether we will ever get to see
the final outcome of this work.
Rgs,
Steve.

robert 22nd September 2017 22:05

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Hi Steve,

we just working on the first volume - 1.9.39. It`s no easy to write a new book on this subject because day for day you get new materials. Just think how many actions, losses and claims you must take into regard and found details of them in many languages. You must select photos (we have now approx. 70.000 but it`s still too less to document e.g. all losses, make profiles, maps, airfield and squadron leader roosters as well as many, many other things. It took me over 10 years to gather materials for Polish Campain and I`m still disappointed with some subjects like German long-reconnaissance units. But of course I understand your disappointment.

Regards

Robert

ouidjat 23rd September 2017 10:27

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Thank you for your direct answer Robert.
Still the same team I see! But doesn't matter any way ... :)

steve sheridan 23rd September 2017 10:54

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Good morning Robert, thank you for explaining the situation regarding EOE.
The fact nobody has spoken on these pages for so long was concerning, I applaud the team for taking the time and effort to secure hopefully, the finest publication ever seen on our favourite subject.
Best regs,
Steve.

ouidjat 12th September 2018 14:01

Re: 17-May-40 2./JG 76 Schypek or Schulten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter Cornwell (Post 239696)
Franck,

Interesting. I have another view of this aircraft captioned as 'La Raminoise', which is SE of Artaise-le-Vivier, a little west of Huttes-de-Raucourt, SSW of Raucourt-et-Flaba ?

Location apart, exactly what other evidence is there to connect SCHULTEN with this Black 7 ?

Dear Peter,

I never took time to answer you. Indeed, it's the place.
Thanks very much.
Regards,
Franck.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 14:52.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net