Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   French Beute Aircraft (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=59301)

musec04 1st February 2021 22:09

French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a Potez 25 in German hands. at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/T660-Foto-We...IAAOSwPnpgGFNZ


Does anyone recognise the marking aft of the roundel?


Regards,


Clint

musec04 2nd February 2021 01:36

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


On delcampe is currently a photo of Nieuport 622 in German hands at :


https://www.delcampe.net/fr/collecti...363372558.html


Regards,


Clint

Bertrand H 2nd February 2021 09:14

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Nice fin Clint ;

#2 : Looks like very much for the "cat" of SPA 69 for the 4e escadrille of 3eme RAC at Chateauroux.

Later will become the 2eme escadrille of GC I/3

Bertrand

musec04 2nd February 2021 12:48

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello Bertrand,


Thanks for the reply. Interesting that the aircraft retains the markings of its previous owners as late as 1940. I wonder what unit had been operating the machine immediately prior to its capture by the Germans?


Regards,


Clint

musec04 3rd February 2021 22:39

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of another Potez 25 of l'Ecole de mitrailleurs ? at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/Fotos-Westen...AAAOSwjs1gGwbc


Regards,


Clint

musec04 19th February 2021 20:37

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of Caudron C.59 F-APOV at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/FOTO-franzoe...gAAOSwxepgLj~X


As usual this is a long shot but does anyone have any information on which unit operated this machine in 1939-40?


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 19th February 2021 20:56

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
No answer to your question Clint

I think this is actually F-APQX or Y (no record of F-APOV being issued)
Seems the last letter is more like X or Y even if F-APQV also was a C.59

Cheers
Stig

musec04 19th February 2021 21:13

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hi Stig,


It certainly could be either of the two registrations you mention. I've had a look at Aviation Populaire ou Aviation Proletaire since posting and looking at the C.59 serials he gives for machines delivered to the S.A.P I'm actually probably going to have to go for F-APQV.


Having said that, so what follows is probably irrelavant, I notice looking at the french serials on the ab list the compiler does list a F-APOV, but with no details at all - seemingly meaning that the registration may have been issued. But as I say probably irrelevant anyway.




Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 19th February 2021 21:31

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
I doubt you will find a CdN for F-APOV

French researchers has so far not found anything on that registration and I believe it was simply skipped.

Wasn't both F-APQX and Y on loan from Adl'A?
They must both have been much easier to request back.... :)

However I have chosen to keep it with the last letter unknown

Cheers
Stig

musec04 19th February 2021 21:42

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hi Stig,


Probably prudent, but you can deduce how I will have listed it and as far as the other two registrations, now they are not among the ones listed by Vittal Ferry in any case, although http://www.airhistory.org.uk/gy/reg_F-18.html has F-APQY as one loan from the french state, but F-APQX is last listed there as in Hanoi.I wonder why F-APOV is listed on that page at all?


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 19th February 2021 21:53

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Ahhh

I should look before writing from memory......
So it was F-APQV and F-APQY which were on loan in France....

Well, at some point, the French stopped to issue their CdN in a straight order, ie following a logic sequence meaning there now are very large gaps in the French civil register.

Most likely they were intended to be filled in at some point but never were, hence most listings keep them even if nothing was ever issued.

Cheers
Stig

musec04 19th February 2021 22:45

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay are further French beute aircraft as follows:


ANF Les Mureaux 115


https://www.ebay.de/itm/FOTO-franzoe...EAAOSwoWBgLkAv


Cierva C.30


https://www.ebay.de/itm/FOTO-franzoe...QAAOSw0QlgLj7n

Potez 580/585

https://www.ebay.de/itm/FOTO-franzoe...gAAOSwSUBgLkIU

Potez 600


https://www.ebay.de/itm/FOTO-franzoe...kAAOSwcTJgLj5m

Regia Aeronautica LeO 451


https://www.ebay.it/itm/FOTO-BEUTE-L...wAAOSwLIhgLxev


Regards,


Clint

rof120 20th February 2021 15:13

AA not Adl'A
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Stig Jarlevik (Post 302531)

(...)

Wasn't both F-APQX and Y on loan from Adl'A?
They must both have been much easier to request back.... :)
However I have chosen to keep it with the last letter unknown

Cheers
Stig

Hello Stig. Please don't believe I'm trying to make you feel miserable. I don't think that Armée de l'Air ever was called Adl'A in France. After all I was a combat aircrew with the AA. It was long ago but I don't think AA changed in the meantime similarly with awful German abbreviations during WWII with lots of /, ( ) etc.

Here is an example from today:

Contacts ⋆ L'École de l'airwww.ecole-air-espace.fr › ... › Réglementation
Points de contact DRH-AA/SDEF/BAF/DESC/CELLULE OFFICIERS TOURS. Direction des ressources humaines de l'armée de l'air (DRH-AA) Sous-direction ...

I looked quite hard on the Internet but I never found Adl'A even though foreigners (non-French people) seem to love it.

PS: L'École de l'Air is not a school for children aged 3-10 but it's the French Air Force's officers academy. When they leave it they are promoted to sous-lieutenant and very often pilots (but there are other kinds of officers of course).

Stig Jarlevik 20th February 2021 15:42

Re: AA not Adl'A
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rof120 (Post 302570)
Hello Stig. Please don't believe I'm trying to make you feel miserable. I don't think that Armée de l'Air ever was called Adl'A in France. After all I was a combat aircrew with the AA.

I know that already
My friends in France tell me that all the time!

However I have just written it that way for 100+ years (guess I didn't want people to think all French pilots are with the Alcoholic Anonymous and FYI we also use the same short form in Sweden for those who can't stop drinking)

So you can take it any way you like. To me it is a small token of respect!
Cheers
Stig

rof120 20th February 2021 17:20

AA...
 
Oh I see, thanks. There is a problem when you have a good command (or not so good) of several languages for there are innumerable possibilities of coincidences, sometimes not really wanted, like:

AA in Germany is the same as the Swedish baj. (As you know the German A is the same as in Washington or the first a in Galland.)

I often wonder about the reactions of Swedish people living in France (I'm sorry for them) and hearing all the time "Nathalie Baye" (pronounced "baj"), a famous cinema actress, or "la baille" (quite rare in fact because most people say "la flotte" instead, which is wrong) - la baille is sea water. If you want to let a flat or a house you'll have to write a "bail" (say baj), a bail de location (a contract for letting the flat etc.).

There is a river called Prut or Prout in Eastern Europe. The sound of this is the same in Swedish as in French. I'd better stop here.

I fear there are thousands of such collisions between different languages including Spanish, Russian or whatever, you name it. The best solution is to ignore them and to stick to the original version in the (main) country of the language. So I'll stick to AA for Armée de l'Air (after all I am still an AA officer: lieutenant honoraire - not active any more). There are often several different explanations for one single abbreviation anyway.

PS: a last one for those who read English. Perhaps you happen to know the English word "after". In German this word has quite a different meaning, believe me. So it's useless to try to make changes because of such "accidents".

rof120 21st February 2021 15:26

AA or AA?
 
I fear we all forgot a wonderful example of AA. I am the main culprit: stupid rof120.

Did you ever hear of AA in a war? I guess so. It means anti-aircraft (defenses, guns, fire...) not Anonymous Alcoholics or some. Nobody ever suggested to change this abbreviation.

Did you ever change it into something else because of alcohol? Why not At-Act?

I am aware of the Swedish Systembolaget, the state network of shops which has a monopoly for selling any alcohol in Sweden including beer and wine - and rather expensively. So you poor Stig are unhappy and frustrated, and think that any AA must have a connection to alcohol. In France and certainly in many other countries they also have a big problem with alcohol but luckily in spite of this they don't change their air force into a society of alcoholics, which wouldn't be ideal would it.

rof120 22nd February 2021 13:19

AA - cont'd
 
Just a last little one:

What about American Airlines, aka AA? I just saw that it was the biggest airline company in the world 2018. It seems to be still strong and kicking.

I never heard or read that we shouldn't call them AA because of Alcoholic Anonymous.

There are most probably other meanings to AA. It depends in which field and I think everybody makes the necessary adjustments. So why not Armée de l'Air = AA? There is no reason.

QUOTATION from Wikipedia:

American Airlines, Inc. (AA) is a major American airline headquartered in Fort Worth, Texas, within the Dallas–Fort Worth metroplex. It is the world's largest airline when measured by fleet size, scheduled passengers carried, and revenue passenger mile. American, together with its regional partners, operates an extensive international and domestic network with almost 6,800 flights per day to nearly 350 destinations in more than 50 countries.

musec04 1st March 2021 20:43

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay are the following French aircraft :


Potez 60


https://www.ebay.de/itm/org-Foto-Fra...gAAOSwGAhgPE80


Romano R.82


https://www.ebay.de/itm/org-Foto-Fra...4AAOSwawxgPE9K


Regards,


Clint

musec04 2nd March 2021 22:03

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photoo f a Caudron C.714 captioned as Beute at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/S103-Foto-We...oAAOSwpJNgPhqg


Regards,


Clint

musec04 3rd March 2021 20:29

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a DH.60G, or MS.60 named Palombe in German hands at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/Foto-Frankre...MAAOSwr9RgP9JF


Two questions:


1. Does anyone have any further details of this particular aircraft including its full registration?


2. What is the aircraft to its rear?


TIA,


Clint

musec04 4th March 2021 09:54

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Is the aircraft to the rear of the MS.60 a member of the Farman F.230 family or a derivative of the same? Did any member of the F.230 family have a fairing behind the rear cockpit and a Townsend Ring over the engine cylinders?


Regards,


Clint

musec04 25th July 2021 20:29

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay are photos of Caudron G.III F-ABEW in 1940.Seemingly based at the Caudron flying school:




https://www.ebay.de/itm/363475872124...sAAOSw8aZg9-Aq



https://www.ebay.de/itm/313610779008...YAAOSwOA1g99~G




Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 25th July 2021 21:10

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
I doubt it was in use

In Feb 1939 it was bought by René Caudron himself.
Maybe he intended to open a small museum based on his own products?

Cheers
Stig

musec04 25th July 2021 21:20

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Yes, seems unlikely.Though who knows perhaps he still enjoyed flying it.



A pity,when I first saw the photos I was hoping for roundels! the Force de Frappe vintage 1940!


Regards,


Clint

musec04 1st August 2021 20:52

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay there is a photo of a captured MS.406 at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/324735968987...wAAOSwp65hBoV3


Potez 63.11 at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/324735972422...IAAOSw4NlhBocA


NA.64 at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/324735971043...AAAOSw7gdhBoaB



Regards,


Clint

musec04 3rd August 2021 21:16

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a Caudron C.714 bearing a fuselage cross,however,seemingly too damaged to be flyable at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/194269477480...cAAOSwaLdhCVV6


Also on ebay is a photo of a AMNF Les Mureaux 115,Caudron C.635 Simoun and a Leo 20 at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/144137826245...8AAOSwNRRhCTcD


The same seller also has the following photos captioned as being taken at Rennes:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/144137812733...oAAOSw6vJhCTSb


https://www.ebay.de/itm/144137783498...EAAOSwVPRhCTHI




Regards,


Clint

musec04 3rd August 2021 22:16

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on delcampe is a photo of a Bloch 210 at:


https://www.delcampe.net/fr/collecti...650214877.html


Regards,


Clint

musec04 4th August 2021 17:23

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


I'm looking for some assistance with the id of this machine. A member of the Pou de Ciel family? :


https://www.ebay.de/itm/294312615219...wAAOSw6NxgpWMm


Regards,


Clint

musec04 19th August 2021 22:06

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay there is a photo of a french Curtiss H75A Hawk in German hands at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/294312094094...YAAOSw1e1hCkAr


Would someone please be kind enough to explain the unusual roundel? Is this from a German propaganda film?



Regards,


Clint

musec04 15th September 2021 15:04

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a Caudron C.275 W-301 (civilian registration F-ARVC) at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/224610641764...oAAOSwAgBhQc5e




Does anyone know which unit had operated this machine prior to capture?



Regards,


Clint

John Beaman 15th September 2021 17:32

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
mistake

musec04 21st September 2021 23:39

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a phto of a Dewoitine D.520 captioned as Italian and based at Catania:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/363551014496...oAAOSwDMlhSiUj


I'm uncertain about the caption and the white stripe along the length of the fuselage is of the type seen on french machines. So my question. Is this machine in Italian service,and if so,with which unit?


Regards,


Clint

Bertrand H 8th October 2021 18:28

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hi Clint,


No Italian but D. 520 GC III/6

On left side of the rudder the bottom of « Masque de tragédie » of 5ème Escadrille of GC III/6

Bertrand

musec04 8th October 2021 18:51

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hi Bertrand,


Thanks for the info. A little surprised that the link was still visible given the time having passed due to the sad,but thankfully temporary,loss of the site.


Regards,


Clint

musec04 26th October 2021 17:55

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a Morane Saulnier MS.138 at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/384465312450...UAAOSwpkphd7JT


Can anyone assist in identifying the unit?. The marking on the fuselage shows a pelican (I think,it could even be a swan,but looks a little portly) riding upon a wave,if that helps as I appreciate that the image is a little unclear.


Regards,


Clint

musec04 10th November 2021 21:43

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a photo of a damaged french aircraft alongside a FCM 36 at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/393693842104...EAAOSwlkJhi74o


Has anyone an opinion on the atype of aircraft shown in the photo? Caudron C.60 F-AJPS, perhaps?



Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 11th November 2021 15:54

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
It is
At least two more photos exist showing the complete registration.

Cheers
Stig

musec04 11th November 2021 19:32

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Thanks Stig,


Do the photos show the rear of the aircraft at all? Any tricolor on the rudder or purely civilian markings?


Regards,


Clint

Stig Jarlevik 11th November 2021 20:01

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
As far as I can judge, pure civilian markings

Cheers
Stig

musec04 15th November 2021 14:51

Re: French Beute Aircraft
 
Hello,


Currently on ebay is a nice photo of a CAMS 37 flying boat with a red cross emblem on the tail at:


https://www.ebay.de/itm/185165083988...gAAOSwOvthkkI4


Regards,


Clint


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 18:30.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net