Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Post-WW2 Military and Naval Aviation (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=35)
-   -   MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=61074)

knusel 25th November 2021 21:31

MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Good evening Gentlemen,

the Mikoyan-Gurevich MiG-29 is such a good-looking plane.
One of the more succesful pilots is G. Chiber from India, who scored twice in 1999. Can anybody tell me his first name ?

Cheers,

Michael

Luc Vervoort 25th November 2021 21:49

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Hi Michael,

Gaurav was his first name.

See for more details :http://www.bharat-rakshak.com/IAF/Database/22926

best regards

Luc





knusel 26th November 2021 00:01

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Dear Luc,

thanks for your answer.
On the website I cannot find his two kills mentioned, can you ?

Cheers,

Michael

Leendert 26th November 2021 11:18

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
It seems he (Chibber) claimed 2 x PAF F-16s in 1999.

Leendert

knusel 26th November 2021 17:26

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Good afternoon Leendert,

that's interesting.
He seems to be the only Indian pilot who scored in the MiG-29:
http://aces.safarikovi.org/victories...-pakistan.html

Have a nice weekend,

Michael

knusel 29th July 2023 14:14

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
The current war has provided us with a borderline MiG-29 ace: Vadim Voroshilov has shot down 5 UAV's and 2 cruise missiles, so far.

GoranA 5th October 2023 00:24

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
According to Kargil 1999 by Sanjay Badri-Maharaj (and also in the link posted by Luc Vervoort) FlLt Gaurav Chibber only acquired a lock on two Pakistani F-16s and drove them away, while escorting Mig-27 strike package.
Looks like translation/interpretation error that echoed through the internet...

knusel 5th October 2023 22:17

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Hello Goran,

this website
https://migflug.com/jetflights/the-c...rently-in-use/
indicates the MiG-29 scored a total of only 6 kills (by 2018): 2 Brothers in Rescue incident (Cuba), 3 Ethiopian-Eritrean War (Eritrea), 1 Georgian border violation 2008 (Russia). Are the dates and the names of the scorers known?

Cheers,

Michael

GoranA 9th October 2023 01:21

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Hello Michael


According to Ethiopian-Eritrean Wars vol.2 by Fontanellaz & Cooper, Eritrean Mig-29 haven't shot down anything. Ethiopian Su-27s shot down 2 and damaged 1 out of 6 delivered Erithrean Migs. Out of 4 Eritrean pilots, 2 were killed and 1 imprisoned for voicing his dissatisfaction to Eritrean command.


In Badme war, there was a lot of overclaiming on both sides, because they both used "tactics" of launching long range R-27s at maximum range (+ the Ukraine/Russia missiles were old and not maintained properly)

knusel 11th October 2023 12:13

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Good morning Goran,

that's interesting. Currently, the Ukrainians use MiG-29's. Have you heard anything about their achievements ?

Best greetings,

Michael

I also have a MiG types thread:
http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showth...ghlight=nguyen

GoranA 11th October 2023 23:18

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Actually there is only one air to air victory against manned aircraft attributed to Ukraine AF up until now, and that is Su-25 shot down by UAF MiG-29 on the first day of the war over Hostomel airport (Mig-29 was then shot down by a S-400 from Belarus - well known video of burning wreck in the Kiev reservoir, with pilot parachuting next to it).


UAF stopped any attempts at air combat already in May 2022, because they didn't have anything comparable to Russian R-77 and R-37 missiles.


Ukraine MiG 29s are used either as UAV/cruise missiles hunters in the western part of Ukraine or as HARM shooters

knusel 12th October 2023 11:19

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Hello Goran,

oh, I didn't know that.

I found another guy who might have scored twice in the Mig-29:
http://aces.safarikovi.org/victories...ries-cuba.html
http://www.urrib2000.narod.ru/EqMiG29-e.html
albeit against Cessnas.

Regards,

Michael

GoranA 12th October 2023 22:26

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Hello Michael


Yes, it does seem that those two Cessnas are the only substantiated claims by Mig-29


Another strong candidate is Armenian Su-25 shot down over Vardenis during Second Nagorno Karabah war. Armenians tried to spin this loss as shot down by Turkish F-16-s based in Azerbaijan, but it is much more likely, that it was shot down by Azeri MiG-29 (S-300 was less likely because of mountainous terrain). That Su-25 was trying to catch Azeri drones, that were attacking buses with Armenian "volunteers" moving to Karabah.



https://theaviationist.com/2020/09/3...-turkish-f-16/

knusel 20th October 2023 13:10

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Hello Goran,

are the names of the possible victorious MiG-29 pilots from Azerbaijan and/or Ukraine known ?

Have a good Friday,

Michael

GoranA 22nd October 2023 00:04

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by knusel (Post 333306)
Hello Goran,

are the names of the possible victorious MiG-29 pilots from Azerbaijan and/or Ukraine known ?

Have a good Friday,

Michael


Regarding the Ukraine claims. several UAF MiG-29s from 40th Tactical Aircraft Brigade were involved in combat on the first day od invasion and 6 of them were lost. They claimed 2 RuAF Su-25,while Russians admitted one loss ("lost because of pilot's error"). The claimant may be the unknown two-seater pilot, who ejected from SD plane, or Lt. Colonel Yerko, who was killed.


In connection with Armenian loss, even less is known. Azerbaijan has claimed this aircraft, but without any details. The reason may be, that it was shot down by Azeri fighter operating over Armenia proper and not over Karabakh. That would be contrary to Azeri claims, that their operation was limited only to Karabakh. (They did attack several Armenian S-300 and Scud launchers in Armenia later, but allegedly only in response to the missiles they fired into Azerbaijan).

knusel 25th October 2023 13:47

Re: MiG-29 - Mr. Chiber
 
I sum up the tally of the MiG-29 might look like this:

3 - Eritrea in the Ethiopian-Eritrean War (1999/2000): three unknown 5Sq pilots but likely not valid
2 - Cuba in the Brothers in Rescue incident (1996): a pilot named Lorenzo Alberto Pérez Pérez
1 - Russia im the Georgian border violation (2008): unknown pilot
1 - Azerbaijan in the Azerbaijan-Armenian War (2020): unknown pilot
1 - Ukraine in the Ukraine War (2022): unknown pilot
0 - Yugoslavia in the Slovenian and Croatian War
0 - Syria in the Lebanon War
0 - Iraq in the Gulf War
0 - Moldova and Russia in the Transnistria War
0 - Serbia in Bosnia and Kosovo
0 - India in the Kargil War (Gaurav Chiber's two claims not valid)
0 - Sudan in the Darfur War
8


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 11:45.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net