Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Missing Short Stirling over Poland? (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=65088)

Blitz45 3rd June 2024 00:00

Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
I am trying to clarify the fate of a Short Stirling which crashed near Gdansk, I don't know from which squadron it could have come?
So far I have checked all the lost Shorts on this list:
https://www.rafcommands.com/database...ling&serialno=
but none have gone down in this area. I also checked the raids on Szczecin in which they took part.
29/30 09.1941 participation of 10 Stirlings from 7 Squ. 2 lost, one crashed in Jutland the other missing.
20/21 04.1943 11 Stirlings, 1 lost over Denmark.
29/30 04.1943 ?
18/19 07.1943 ?
5/6 01. 1944 ?
I suspect the Stirling sought, must have been doing a special mission (SOE), I know there were various aircraft flying to Poland, some more suited to a long two way trip than others. Initial routes were over Denmark, then the southern tip of Sweden, the Baltic Sea and then to Poland. Later flights were launched from Italy and over the Caucasus and Hungary to Poland.
Special squadrons that used Shorts: 138 from June 1944 to March 1945, 161 from September 1943 to June 1945, 192 ?, 299 from January 1944 to February 1946.
Does anyone perhaps have a list of losses of these squadrons? I would be grateful for any help.
Peter

kaki3152 5th June 2024 03:08

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Looked through "The Secret Squadrons" by Robert Jackson. It does not mention any Stirling losses over Poland.

AndyMa 5th June 2024 11:35

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Can you give us any context to your request?
Any rough time (year)?
Has the wreck been found?
What makes you say it was a Stirling?

Blitz45 7th June 2024 17:58

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyMa (Post 338610)
Can you give us any context to your request?
Any rough time (year)?
Has the wreck been found?
What makes you say it was a Stirling?

This is 100% Short Stirling because its component, which we found near Danzig, was identified by the people working on the Stirling restoration. Unfortunately I have no information on the circumstances of the loss of this machine? But I think this story may have something to do with this machine? These graves are close to the route taken by the bombers on SOE missions.
http://strefahistorii.pl/article/294...icach-gostomka
Of course I could be wrong? But I hope that with your Knowledge and help the circumstances of the loss of this machine can be established. I will be grateful for any help you can provide.
Regards
Piotr

Blitz45 7th June 2024 18:01

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kaki3152 (Post 338605)
Looked through "The Secret Squadrons" by Robert Jackson. It does not mention any Stirling losses over Poland.

Unfortunately, I do not have this item in my collection. This Stirling is also a big surprise to me, they never flew over Danzig or Gotenhafen. An element of this aircraft, proves something completely different?

Blitz45 7th June 2024 18:08

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
I don't know if they didn't carry out mine missions over the Bay of Danzig Privet area?

FrankieS 8th June 2024 00:38

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
interesting case !

Blitz45 8th June 2024 08:41

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by kaki3152 (Post 338605)
Looked through "The Secret Squadrons" by Robert Jackson. It does not mention any Stirling losses over Poland.

I found this book, thanks for the recommendation.



https://archive.org/details/secretsq...p?view=theater

Buckeye30 8th June 2024 12:34

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
You might also like to check this book if still available, the 2- Special squadrons at Tempsford ( 138 / 161). I looked at a lot of 138's pages on their ORBs for 1944 ( from June when they received Stirlings from Halifax's but didn't see any reference to Poland, all I saw were France, Belgium, Norway, Denmark and Germany. I think there's a list of losses in there. It may be relevent that 138 had a Polish Flight.

Hope this helps a little.
Nick



https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/1326098403

Blitz45 8th June 2024 17:06

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Buckeye30 (Post 338660)
You might also like to check this book if still available, the 2- Special squadrons at Tempsford ( 138 / 161). I looked at a lot of 138's pages on their ORBs for 1944 ( from June when they received Stirlings from Halifax's but didn't see any reference to Poland, all I saw were France, Belgium, Norway, Denmark and Germany. I think there's a list of losses in there. It may be relevent that 138 had a Polish Flight.

Hope this helps a little.
Nick



https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/1326098403


Thank you Buckeye30 for your help, of course I will review.

Stig Jarlevik 9th June 2024 10:04

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Our friend Geoffrey Sinclair offers his opinion here:

Bomber Command records indicate Stirling furthest east mine operation appears to be Swinemunde, only Lancasters to Gdynia.
138 Squadron started losing Stirling IV in August 1944, Denmark operation the furthest east loss. Similar for 161 squadron.


Geoffrey Sinclair

Alex Smart 9th June 2024 17:21

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
This may help ?
https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase...na=&yr=&page=1

Or better still -

Only one.
W7514 - 15 Sqdn lost 26 /04/1942 - Crewman died a POW on 29/07/1944 in Poland.

However What was the fate of the Stirling captured and flown by the Luftwaffe ?

RSwank 10th June 2024 01:46

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Fate of Stirling flown by the Luftwaffe (N3705):
https://captured-wings.fandom.com/wiki/N3705

"The aircraft was photographed, in colour, by the German propaganda magazine Signal when its flying days were over. Three of the engines had been removed, and it appeared to be in the far corner of Rechlin, having suffered another crash landing,[7] and was presumably scrapped."


List of planes lost on Special Operations (shows no Stirlings lost in Poland).

https://harringtonmuseum.org.uk/wp-c...-20.5.2022.pdf

FrankieS 10th June 2024 03:03

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
http://www.flensted.eu.com/194211.shtml

Alex Smart 11th June 2024 03:20

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Thank you Frankie,
Your post confirms the death of Stephen that he was hit by lightning whilst a POW in Poland.

Alex Smart 11th June 2024 03:24

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
This is 100% Short Stirling because its component, which we found near Danzig, was identified by the people working on the Stirling restoration

Question - Is it known which actual mechanical part is said to have come from a Stirling. Further were those parts fitted into other aircraft ?

Blitz45 11th June 2024 21:37

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alex Smart (Post 338668)
This may help ?
https://aviation-safety.net/wikibase...na=&yr=&page=1

Or better still -

Only one.
W7514 - 15 Sqdn lost 26 /04/1942 - Crewman died a POW on 29/07/1944 in Poland.

However What was the fate of the Stirling captured and flown by the Luftwaffe ?

28-AUG-1943 Short Stirling Mk III EF451 620 Sqn RAF 5 missing
only about this one there is no information, does anyone know what mission it performed?

Blitz45 11th June 2024 21:51

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alex Smart (Post 338680)
This is 100% Short Stirling because its component, which we found near Danzig, was identified by the people working on the Stirling restoration

Question - Is it known which actual mechanical part is said to have come from a Stirling. Further were those parts fitted into other aircraft ?

This is a component from the bomb ejector, which was not present on the Lancasters that took part over Danzig and Gotenhafen.

Blitz45 11th June 2024 21:59

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Thank you to all the contributors to the thread for the effort you are making to clarify this story. My special thanks go to Carsten Petersen for the material provided.

Blitz45 11th June 2024 22:24

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
On one Polish forum I found such an entry: , ‘My grandfather and his family lived on a peninsula on Lake Mezowski near Kartuz during the war. My mother recalls that during the war, in their house, which was situated on the outskirts of the village, English airmen from a downed plane were probably hiding. It is not known for how long, but in the vague recollections of my mother, who was a toddler at the time, they hid in the attic and sometimes went down to listen to the radio news. The story seemed so incredible that no one took it seriously...".
Unfortunately, I cannot verify this information as this person's grandfather died a long time ago.
I can perfectly understand why he did not tell the story after the war. He could have suffered severe consequences from the communist authorities of the time for his contacts and assistance to the English. The location would fit in this story, and it is certainly not about the pilots from the downed Lancaster PB723, which took part in the raid on Gotenhafen on 18/19 December 1944.

Blitz45 11th June 2024 22:30

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
The question is: which English aircraft might these airmen have come from?

Blitz45 11th June 2024 22:57

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Perhaps they are the same airmen I mentioned earlier? http://strefahistorii.pl/article/294...icach-gostomka
What do you guys think about this?

Franek Grabowski 12th June 2024 14:38

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
The supposed grave of RAF airmen reputedly contains bodies of escapers from a nearby PoW camp. As far as I know, this has not been positively and formally verified. The only possibility for a Stirling in the area is a damaged aircraft. There are no reports of crash that far east, so possibly the aircraft was abandoned and flew on auto pilot. Of course, assuming the information about crash site is correct.

Pat Atkins 12th June 2024 16:01

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
138's Polish flight became 301 (Polish) Sqdn which flew out of Brindisi in 44-45, along with 148 (SD) Sqdn RAF. Both flew Special Duties ops to Poland, using Halifaxes. 148 had one or two Stirlings in later 1944 but I don't think they ever flew operationally.

Alex Smart 13th June 2024 02:49

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Did we "Gift" a Stirling to Russia ???

FrankieS 13th June 2024 23:45

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
"The U.K. refused to supply the Soviet Union with Lancaster and Halifax heavy bombers, despite repeated Soviet requests.[1] However, the Soviets were supplied the earlier Short Stirling Heavy Bomber.


Stalin tasked Tuppavare with cloning the Stirling and Soviet industry was to produce 47 copies of the aircraft in just two years. The three Stirlings were flown to Moscow and delivered into Tuppavare OKB. One Stirling was fully dismantled, down to the smallest bolt, the second was used for flight tests and training, and the third one was left as a standard for cross-reference.




"Stirling B.Mk.III
Unit: LII VVS
Serial: ex LK615
The only British heavy bomber ever officially delivered to the Soviet Union, Short Stirling Mk.III LK615 was built by Austin Motors at Long Bridge in 1944, and is seen here in the colors it wore while undergoing tests at Kratovo, near Moscow, in the autumn of 1944. It was Later it was declared as not perspective and transferred to UPA (Department of Polar Aviation) and got serial SSSR-N-415. But it still outdated and not used until SOC in the end of 1947. Artist: © Anrey Yurgenson
Source: Aeroplane Magazine, January 2007
Source: Sent by Ezz Eldin"


source:
https://www.key.aero/forum/historic-...ling-in-russia


bye bye
FrankieS

Blitz45 14th June 2024 18:38

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
And does anyone have knowledge of the claims of Flak Units in this area Karthaus, Berent.

Blitz45 14th June 2024 18:42

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Franek Grabowski (Post 338704)
The supposed grave of RAF airmen reputedly contains bodies of escapers from a nearby PoW camp. As far as I know, this has not been positively and formally verified. The only possibility for a Stirling in the area is a damaged aircraft. There are no reports of crash that far east, so possibly the aircraft was abandoned and flew on auto pilot. Of course, assuming the information about crash site is correct.

one version speaks of refugees, the other of airmen from a downed Allied bomber. It is difficult to say which version is closer to the truth?

Blitz45 14th June 2024 18:49

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
why can't I add photos?

Alex Smart 14th June 2024 20:26

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Thank you FrankieS,
Your link may hold the answer.
Quote-
Stirling B.Mk.III
Unit: LII VVS
Serial: ex LK615
The only British heavy bomber ever officially delivered to the Soviet Union, Short Stirling Mk.III LK615 was built by Austin Motors at Long Bridge in 1944, and is seen here in the colors it wore while undergoing tests at Kratovo, near Moscow, in the autumn of 1944. It was Later it was declared as not perspective and transferred to UPA (Department of Polar Aviation) and got serial SSSR-N-415. But it still outdated and not used until SOC in the end of 1947.

Stig Jarlevik 14th June 2024 21:19

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankieS (Post 338718)
Stalin tasked Tuppavare with cloning the Stirling and Soviet industry was to produce 47 copies of the aircraft in just two years. The three Stirlings were flown to Moscow and delivered into Tuppavare OKB. One Stirling was fully dismantled, down to the smallest bolt, the second was used for flight tests and training, and the third one was left as a standard for cross-reference.
FrankieS

This cannot be correct
By the time the single Sterling arrived to USSR nobody wanted it. It had departed from UK
in Feb 1945 and arrived via Iraq in March. (SOC by RAF in March 1945)

It was more or less dumped into the hands of the Polar Aviation Division and when a British mission
arrived to help with the introduction during the Spring 1946 it was finally taken into service,
but little used.

What was Tuppaware OKB? Never heard of it. Why would anyone build 47 useless Sterlings postwar?
Makes no sense what so ever.

Cheers
Stig

udf_00 15th June 2024 14:29

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
https://www.key.aero/forum/historic-...ling-in-russia :
"The Tuv-75P was a planned produce cargo development using non-strategic materials, with high content of plastics in its construction, based on a Soviet theory of keeping produce fresh by storage in plastics."

keeping produce fresh by storage in plastics courtesy of Tuppa'ware : don't you get it brotha' ????

Stig Jarlevik 15th June 2024 18:15

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by udf_00 (Post 338744)
https://www.key.aero/forum/historic-...ling-in-russia :
"The Tuv-75P was a planned produce cargo development using non-strategic materials, with high content of plastics in its construction, based on a Soviet theory of keeping produce fresh by storage in plastics."

keeping produce fresh by storage in plastics courtesy of Tuppa'ware : don't you get it brotha' ????

Jesus what crap on that site.
Tuppa'ware is Tupolev and the "47 Tuv-4" are presumably Tu-4 of which a lot
more than 47 was built (1296 to be exact)
It had nothing to do with the Sterling what so ever (being a B-29 copy)
The Tuv-75P was the Tu-75 of which one was built
Not a single source mentions any derivative called Tu-75P. Can I have a Russian source for that please?
Cheers
Stig

Blitz45 21st November 2024 17:39

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Welcome after a long absence. I came across a claim by pilot Leopold ‘Poldi’ Fellererz of the 5th Staffel of Nachtjaggeschwader 2 that on 29.03.1942 at 01:02 he reported shooting down a Stirling in PQ 75884, which matches the presumed location of my fall . Which I don't think can be true, however, as the only suspect from that day https://asn.flightsafety.org/wikibas...TFNxpsgdE6QEGA
returned happily to its base. Can someone please verify, clarify this information about quadrant PQ75884?

Chris Goss 22nd November 2024 16:40

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Location was sea 20km SW Helgoland according to Theo Boiten but W7507 got back to base

Blitz45 22nd November 2024 21:25

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Goss (Post 341316)
Location was sea 20km SW Helgoland according to Theo Boiten but W7507 got back to base

Thank you Chris for the quick reply, that means it's all clear, a mistake in the numbers :( So we keep looking.

Blitz45 23rd November 2024 23:20

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
I'm starting to run out of ideas http://www.harringtonmuseum.org.uk/w...Operations.pdf

Blitz45 30th November 2024 12:45

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
Based on the numbers that are on this part, am I able to determine this Stirling? The only sensible number on this part is: R2371.
Others: 9292902 , 92992901, 9292551,
60MF
There is a V on the top of the screws

Blitz45 30th November 2024 12:52

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
circular punches HCM62

Blitz45 30th November 2024 18:25

Re: Missing Short Stirling over Poland?
 
It was created at Short Brothers, mark I May 1940 to May 1943. Can you establish where it went?


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 05:27.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net