Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book" (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=18574)

Andy Saunders 19th October 2009 11:12

Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
I attach without comment scans of a logbook attributed to Flt Lt E Campbell of 601 Squadron, 1940.

This on the back of the recent "release" of "genuine" Battle of Britain paperwork into the marketplace.

Peter Cornwell 19th October 2009 11:43

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Andy,

Fantastic ! Many previously unrecorded sorties by No.601 Squadron are detailed. Truly an incredible document.

Andy Saunders 19th October 2009 12:30

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
History is being re-written as we speak!

Next week, on special offer; Douglas Stanford Tuck's Flugbuch and Adolf Bader's Log Book.

Andy Saunders 19th October 2009 17:27

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Evidently I am way off track on this and it is not a fraud after all.

See here:

http://disc.yourwebapps.com/discussi...ussion%20Forum

Monty's Double 19th October 2009 22:12

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Andy, how much evidence to you have to put infront of someone? RD's stance is ridiculous, he'd gain more respect by admitting that he'd not looked at the scans before sounding off.

Andy Saunders 19th October 2009 22:41

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
I think the whole problem is that the vendor will say that he didn't know it was a fake and was selling it in good faith. Or he will say that he has no idea where he got it from. Even if he is the forger then that has to be proven, and that might be tricky unless they are caught in the act with forged or partly completed forgeries or with the materials and equipment and things like rubber stamps, re-printed forms, blank log books and old typewriters.

We all know that this and other material is blatantly (and patently) forged - notwithstanding the pronouncements of others on the issue. Many of us have a pretty good idea as to the source. Proving it is another matter of course.

north_weald 19th October 2009 22:42

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Im confused. Is it fake or real?

Andy Saunders 19th October 2009 22:48

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Well, its very fake in my view.

Others may not agree. Apparently.

(PS - read the other posts in that thread and not just the one the link directs you to)

Monty's Double 20th October 2009 00:41

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Has this come from the infamous Louth fake factory?

Andy Saunders 20th October 2009 08:15

Re: Battle of Britain 601 Squadron "Log Book"
 
Since it was bought from a (now) unknown antique trader I am afraid that tracking its source of origin might be difficult if not impossible.

Whilst some may have suspicions about its source I think that making a definite link with anyone will mean that they will remain just that - ie privately held suspicions.

Incredibly, the debate about this Log Book rumbles on elsewhere....with one firmly held view that the Log Book is neither a fake nor a fraud!


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 22:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net