Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Links (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=19958)

RodM 14th February 2010 01:21

Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
5 Attachment(s)
Hello One and All,

stimulated by Nick Beale's authorative thread on ULTRA, this is an attempt to kick-start discussion on the availability and use of other archived British Y-intercept material. Firstly, because my own interest concerns the Nachtjagd in the late-war period, I have not actively investigated the availability of such information on other arms of the Luftwaffe or the availability and quality of such material in the 1939-43 period.

I will start by stating that A.I. (British Air Intelligence) produced a large number of reports based upon the collated intelligence from wireless intercepts and captured documents and aircrew. The attached PDF entitled 'Air Ministry AI Document Distribution List' surveys the type and scope of these reports. The document is a reproduction of a document found on an A series (A5400 from memory) microfilm held by The Air Force Historical Research Agency. It lists the A.I. reports being distributed to American commands by originating directorate. I have added known British National Archives file reference numbers for surviving copies of these reports. The various surviving reports held by the British National Archives are by no means neatly organised, easy to locate via an archive catalogue search, or complete.

A tremendous amount of Y-intercept material survives in the series AIR 51 - Mediterranean Allied Air Forces: Microfilmed Files. There appears to be material of wider interest in these microfilms, beyond just operations in the Mediterranean. The attached PDF entitled 'AIR 51 Int Sigint Index' provides a list of the Signals Intelligence files held within this microfilmed series. Others, such as Nick Beale, would be more qualified to comment on the general content of these files. The microfilm AIR 51/292 holds an incomplete selection of A.I. reports in the BAT, OWL-ROBOT, Pearl/Zip/FT/AI, Pearl/Zip/GAA, Pearl/Zip/GAM, Pearl/Zip/LS, and Pearl/Zip/TAC/N series, and I have indexed these in the AIR 51 PDF. I would expect that other microfilms contain a wider selection of reports.


Of wider interest are the daily Air Activity Summaries as prepared by A.I.4 throughout the war. A complete set of these documents is held at the British National Archives (there are also weekly summaries, but I haven't looked at these):

AIR 22/476-503 Air Ministry W/T Intelligence Service Daily Summaries Nos. 1-2076 (28 Volumes) September 1939-May 1945

At least in the late-war period, these reports cover a 24-hour period ending at 0600 hrs B.S.T. or 0700 hrs B.D.S.T., depending on the time zone in use.

The documents contain:

An executive summary on the first page of (a) Enemy Bomber Activity, and (b) Enemy Nightfighter Activity. Sometimes other information of interest, such as Y evidence of lost aircraft is also appended.

Part I - Enemy Bomber and Reconnaisance Activity. This section has information under the following column headings Unit; A/C (i.e. the number of aircraft heard); Times; Control (i.e. the ground control with which the aircraft were operating); Freq (i.e. wireless frequency); Remarks.

Part II - Enemy Bomber, Fighter Bomber and Miscellaneous Activity (V.H.F.) - when present, I presume that the format of the information is similar to Part III. below.

Part III - Enemy Fighter Activity (Day). this section contains the following sub-sections: 1. GAF reaction to Strategic Operations, GAF reaction to Tactical Operations, and 2. information on aircraft (usually nightfighters) heard operating during the day. Part one is usually in a narrative style with a summary of Allied operations, but can include specifics such as times, type and number of aircraft heard to be operating, location, along with instructions passed.

Part IV - Enemy Fighter Activity (Night). This section contains the following sub-sections: 1. Narrative of reactions to specific raids, and 2. Summary of messages intercepted and information on aircraft heard operating during the night.

Anyway, this will do for a start. If anyone has further information on the Y material available, especially in non-British archives, I would be very interested to heard from you. As with ULTRA, this material in isolation does not provide some magical all-encompassing view of Luftwaffe operations and organisation, but can combine well with information from all documentary sources. Then S/L G.R. Scott-Farnie, head of Y Section in Air Intelligence early in the war once summed it up beautifully: "Intelligence is rarely dramatic - the best results are obtained from the continous study of details, which although singularly of little value are collectively of great importance."

cheers

Rod

I've added samples of some late war reports concerning Luftwaffe activity on 7 April 1945.

The files are:

Pearl-Zip-BMP-D-844.jpg - the main narrative page from the Pearl/Zip/BMP/D report concerning daylight LW reaction to Allied raids. The D Reports at this stage of the war appear to be quite sparse, and certainly not as detailed as the N Reports. The report is contained in HW 13/86 at The National Archives, Kew.

Activity Summary No 2045 Pg 2.jpg & Activity Summary No 2045 Pg 2.jpg - two pages from the report described above. The report is contained in AIR 22/503 at The National Archives, Kew.

Nick Beale 14th February 2010 02:20

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
For the MTO in 1944–45:

The Operations Record Books of No. 276 Wing in AIR26/380–AIR26/383.

HW41/47: Daily Signals Intelligence reports from June 1944 through to February/March 1945 (with quite a lot of them missing). You will also find isolated one-off copies of these in AIR51 and in the 276 Wing ORB — and very frustrating that is. What happened to the rest of the ones for the first half of 1944?

AIR23/3479: MAAF Sigint Daily Reports, October 1944–May 1945 (these are the same reports you'll find in HW41/47 for the period concerned but I've never cross-checked to see if it fills any of the gaps in that file).

Steve Coates 14th February 2010 11:17

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
The 2nd TAF Y Intercepts for the last three months of the year are in AIR40/2371 -2373 and has its uses, primarily to back up other material rather than as a primary source.

edNorth 14th February 2010 19:32

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Rod. Great thanks for samples. Yes them (AAS 2045) are really useful for "full research" in certain areas, but as they never contain the actual codes (callsigns) much is lost in their "value". There are lots of these existing - I had seen sample from 10.1942 (but not had chance to look at more).

I had no prior confirmation Westa 3 flew that far West - but am not surprised. - Part I, Para 1 (Page 2) is what date? I can look in my files and check if it was detected from ground!

Adam 14th February 2010 23:02

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Some of these files are reproduced int he HW 13 series (around part 96 for bomber and recon). These have similar details and are set out in a similar fashion with the columns: unit, take-off, attack, landing, no., type, area references and other remarks.

Some of the information is quite detailed and contains specific times, number of aircraft and actual callsigns, for others it is rather meagre. The following units are mentioned to varying degrees (at least in HW13 96):

Recon:
1./120
3., 4./121
1., 3./122
1., 3./123
Recce Kette Africa

Maritime:
2., 3./125
2., 3./126
1., 5./196
1./406
1., 2., 3./506
1./706
1., 2./906

Bomber:
II., IV./KG 2
I./KG 4
I., II./KG 26
I., II./KG 27
KG 28 (?)
Stab., II., III./KG 30
I., III./KG 40
I., III./KG 51
I./KG 53
II./KG 54
II./KG 55
Stab., II., III./KG 76
SKG 210
KGr 606
I., II., III./LG 1
I./StG 1
II./StG 2
Stab./StG 3

Fighter:
7., III./ZG 76
II./ZG 76
NJG 2
1./NJG 3

The sort of information that can be gained can be as much as the following entry for 5.10.41 for 3./123: "4U+PL TO before 1100 for WR of East Coast between Yarmouth and Sunderland. This aircraft may have been the one unsuccessfully engaged by two Hurricanes 30m NE of Happisburgh between 1125 and 1230. A/C landed by 1500." Likewise it could be as little as "unknown unit. 3+?. no line."

Be warned, a) large files that will take a long time to sort through, and b) just because a unit is listed in the above, doesn't mean there may be any more than a single reference of inconsequential value in the files.

RodM 15th February 2010 00:12

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
1 Attachment(s)
Thanks Nick, Steve, Ed and Adam for the information.

Ed, the sample Air Activity Report is for the 24-hour period ending 0700 B.D.S.T. on 8 April 1945, so the daylight sorties were on the 7th. Times are also in B.D.S.T. which during this period was the same as M.E.S.Z. then in use by Germany.

Adam, thanks for the additional info.

It is a real shame that more of the raw intercepts have not survived (outside of the microfilmed AIR 51 files), as with knowledge of the callsigns and codes in use at the time, many very useful fragments of information could be gained. The various periodical internal reports used by the Y-organisation to update the monitoring stations on changes of LW signals procedure and the introduction of new codes and callsigns often contain snippets of raw intercepts, but they mainly serve to illustrate the richness of the information that has been lost. Many of the reports, however, do provide useful insight into the operational workings of the Luftwaffe.

Cheers

Rod

I've attached a page from a log found in AIR 51/292, concerning intercepts of Luftwaffe activity on 24 January 1945 in relation to the Allied landings at Anzio. It also has callsigns written in. I guess it serves to illustrate the sort of operational info that has been 'lost' with the destruction of the majority of the intercept logs...

edNorth 15th February 2010 00:18

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
This page was given to me some years back. Some "callsigns" (Stkz.) have checked "true" but I have been told others do not match. I just simply whould love to have all pages. Is this in HW or Y-Service 1944 files?

RodM 15th February 2010 01:02

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by edNorth (Post 101511)
This page was given to me some years back. Some "callsigns" (Stkz.) have checked "true" but I have been told others do not match. I just simply whould love to have all pages. Is this in HW or Y-Service 1944 files?

Hi Ed, as a guess, it looks like data prepared by A.I.3 (b) as a part of their order of battle forcasting... Sorry, I can't give any info on possible archive refererences; it's a shame you don't have the title page.

Cheers

Rod

Nick Beale 15th February 2010 10:05

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RodM (Post 101518)
Hi Ed, as a guess, it looks like data prepared by A.I.3 (b) as a part of their order of battle forcasting... Sorry, I can't give any info on possible archive refererences; it's a shame you don't have the title page.

Cheers

Rod

It looks very like some lists that I found in the 276 Wing ORB Appendices.

Bruce Dennis 1st March 2010 19:20

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Some of you may find these pages useful.

https://www.humyo.com/10203701/FILES...ts%20extracts/

They are extracts from subjects covered in the Western Front Committee Reports in HW14/2055, various dates in late 1942.

Bruce

Bruce Dennis 6th March 2010 01:17

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Download link for the Royal Navy report on the BV222 ...

https://www.humyo.com/10203701/ADM%20234%204%20Bv222/

Bruce

Bruce Dennis 7th March 2010 00:46

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Allied assessment of German Air Force dispositions October 1942 (includes German ASR) ...

https://www.humyo.com/10203701/GAF%2...%20Oct%201942/

Bruce

EDIT: LINK UPDATED, PLEASE ADVISE IF STILL UNABLE TO OPEN

RodM 7th March 2010 12:46

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bruce Dennis (Post 102602)
Some of you may find these pages useful.

https://www.humyo.com/10203701/FILES...ts%20extracts/

They are extracts from subjects covered in the Western Front Committee Reports in HW14/2055, various dates in late 1942.

Bruce


Hi Dennis,

thanks for posting these...I always wondered what a SALU report contained. Perhaps revealing is the stamp on the title page of the SALU report (DSCF3047), stating "SPECIAL NOTE. This document is based on the evidence available at War Station (Station X). It does not necessarily represent the views of the Ministries, or any one of them."

W/C John Stubbington, in his his excellent book, 'Bletchley Park Air Section. Signals Intelligence Support to RAF Bomber Command' (Minerva Associates, 2007), details the problems that existed between Air Intelligence in London and the Air Section at Bletchley over the analysis of raw data. The crux of the issue was that A.I. did not think it was the job of the Air Section to analyse data and produce reports, believing instead that this was solely their own preserve. The disclaimer quoted above highlights this difference of opinion...

Cheers

Rod

Don Caldwell 7th March 2010 15:49

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hello Bruce --

I have had no luck accessing your "humyo" files. Help, please.

Don

Bruce Dennis 7th March 2010 16:04

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hello Don,
Sorry you have problems: perhaps others have as well so let's use the board to tackle it. What happens when you use the link?

Bruce

Don Caldwell 7th March 2010 17:43

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Bruce --

I was told I wasn't authorized to view your file, and didn't I want to join humyo (for free)? I don't, but since the file you've posted there is in my current area of interest, I joined, re-logged in, and was told again that I'm not authorized to view your file. Enough time wasted....

Don

Bruce Dennis 7th March 2010 17:50

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hello Don,
I must ask if anybody else has had the same problem, because I cannot recreate it (I am the account holder so it gives me a different page when I access it). Also, does it happen with all of the links posted?

Each link only gives access to the specified file/folder, so sorry you wasted your time joining only to be turned away again. In the meantime, if you send me a PM with your email address, I will send a 'private' link to whichever file(s) you are after.

Bruce

Adam 7th March 2010 17:57

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Bruce,

I have the same problems with the October '42 disposition files. I can open everything else, but that link I don't have the "necessary privileges to access".

Cheers

Adam

Bruce Dennis 7th March 2010 19:19

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Adam & Don: try now, if no luck then I will repost them. I think it may have a been a rookie mistake on my part.

" Allied assessment of German Air Force dispositions October 1942 (includes German ASR) ..."
Don, is this the one you meant?

Bruce

Don Caldwell 7th March 2010 20:01

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Bruce --

Yes, that's the file that interests me. I can now pull it up on humyo. But my efforts to read it, by enlarging, saving, or printing it, does nothing but freeze my computer. Any more hints?

Don

Darius 7th March 2010 20:43

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hello Bruce,

1st - I can download, read & print the files,
2nd - very goot stuff

Thank you

Darius

Bruce Dennis 7th March 2010 20:57

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Don Caldwell (Post 102974)
Hi Bruce --

... my efforts to read it, by enlarging, saving, or printing it, does nothing but freeze my computer. Any more hints?

Don

Yes, and I only found out by trial and error: download it. Humyo doesn't seem to support viewing very well.

Darius, glad you find it useful.

HTH, Bruce

Don Caldwell 7th March 2010 21:10

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Bruce --

Still trying to download, and still hanging my trusty eMac. Something to do with applets... I'll try again, let the pinwheel spin a while longer, and go read the paper.

Don

Don Caldwell 7th March 2010 21:49

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Bruce --

I'm back in business. There's apparently a problem with my eMac-humyo-Java interface, and I can't download folders, but I stumbled on the correct humyo arrow & can download a page-at-a-time. This looks like a useful file.

Can you recommend anything else on Reich air defense activity from your HW-level ULTRA searches?

Thanks again,

Don

Bruce Dennis 8th March 2010 22:12

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
To continue the material relating to autumn 1942, here is a link to an Air Activity Summarry from October ...

https://www.humyo.com/10203701/AIR%2...%20Oct%201942/

This might also be of interest to Don.

Bruce

Don Caldwell 9th March 2010 22:26

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Thanks Bruce --

I'm OOT, but what I can see of this report looks very interesting. I'll continue fighting the humyo fight as soon as I get back home.

By any chance, do you have similar reports covering later months in the war, after the USAAF got into it big time?

Don

Adam 10th March 2010 02:12

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Many thanks, Bruce. I can see all the pags now. Thanks for posting the very useful files

Bruce Dennis 21st March 2010 00:59

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
A report on the Allied view of German aircraft reporting system including the German Y service.


https://www.humyo.com/10203701/Allie...20Y%20service/

The subjects covered range from chain-of-command to security procedures in place for coded messages.

Bruce

Bruce Dennis 21st March 2010 01:28

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
A January 1943 summary of Operation names known to have been used by German forces, prepared by the Admiralty.

https://www.humyo.com/10203701/Germa...ation%20names/

Bruce

Bruce Dennis 22nd March 2010 21:59

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
I'm hearing mixed stories about the HUMYO links on my files. Because I am the account holder, I do not see the same page, or get asked the same questions, as 'public' users who arrive at the site through the links I provide. The only way I will know if people have a problem is if you speak up. How easy or difficult are people finding it? (I have thick skin, so speak plainly please)

Bruce

AndreasB 24th April 2010 16:27

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
No problems here.

Does anyone know the signature of the files covering the Operation CRUSADER period in North Africa (Oct 41 to Feb 42 incl.)?

Many thanks!

All the best

Andreas

Bruce Dennis 24th April 2010 20:13

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hello Andreas, there are many files at TNA covering Operation Crusader: some are ...
AIR23/910, 946, 1181, 6479: HW50/42: PREM3/291/2: and many in the WO series. The operation is also part of the content of other files.

Is there anything in particular you are looking for?

Bruce

AndreasB 25th April 2010 00:17

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Bruce

Many thanks for the reply.

Primarily operational detail. I have started on the HW5 series, and have worked extensively with the WO series, HW1, and some AIR and ADM, as well as German records from Duxford. I was particularly interested in the Y-service intercepts for the period and where they could be found.

All the best

Andreas

Bruce Dennis 25th April 2010 10:06

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hello Andreas,
Based on other files viewed, I think HW50/42 is likely to have sources, possibly even transcripts, but I have not seen it myself. AIR41/25 has a lot of information concerning the plans for Crusader derived from Y, and can be taken as a summary of the AI picture based on Y. If you have not seen it already, I strongly suggest 'Spies of the Airwaves' by Hugh Skillen. He gives considerable detail about the Allied side of the North African ops. Let me know if you need access to the book.

Regards,
Bruce

Nick Beale 25th April 2010 11:21

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AndreasB (Post 105682)
I was particularly interested in the Y-service intercepts for the period and where they could be found.

Andreas

If the North African Y-service was organised as an RAF Wing (as it was in Italy in 1944 under No. 276 Wing) then the ORB and Appendices may have material you want. Equally you may find other reports made by the Wing.

AndreasB 26th April 2010 23:05

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Many thanks to both of you. The tip on the Wing is good, I'll look into this. Air 41/25 looks very very promising. I wonder if that could be part of Tedder's 'missing' despatch?

Book ordered!

All the best

Andreas

Nick Beale 27th April 2010 13:12

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
IIRC the presecessor of No. 276 Wing in the Med (i.e. before Autumn 1943) was No. 329 Wing but I don't know if they were there as early as the Crusader period.

Bruce Dennis 27th April 2010 16:25

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Hi Andreas/Nick: I have so far had no luck finding any 'mother lode' files of signals from North Africa. There are several files that give great descriptions of the Units and their organisation, but (I think) the daily output was handed straight to the AI officer who incorporated the findings into his reports.

I will bet someone reading this says something like '... but don't they know about ...' and Hey! Presto! the key document is identified. How about, as a suggestion, the people who have spent time looking for this information compare notes? It is always irritating to find that one has followed the wasted journey of another, and likewise rewarding to find that something already viewed is useful to someone else: I will gladly donate some on-line storage space to housing any files others want to share.

Maybe nothing will come of it, but what do others think?

Bruce

AndreasB 27th April 2010 22:17

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
Good idea, and I wish I could contribute to that.

As for 329 Wing, a quick trawl of the Catalogue at the National Archives shows no mention before 1943.

All the best

Andreas

AndreasB 27th April 2010 22:29

Re: Using Y-Intercepts to research the Luftwaffe
 
This may help a bit? From the OH, organisation of RAF Middle East on 11 November 41.

http://www.ibiblio.org/hyperwar/UN/U...AF-II-p382.jpg


According to this:

http://www.rafweb.org/Wings4.htm

Signals wing was only:

No. 250 and this wing is not given with any aircraft type.

But... I can't find any records in the National Archives.


All the best

Andreas


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 12:46.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net