Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Kittyhawk Found in Sahara (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=29445)

Leo Etgen 23rd April 2012 02:06

Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Hi guys

In case any of you have not seen these they appear to show a Kittyhawk fighter of 260 Sqn, RAF that has recently been found.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CFe8CsOdoG8
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M9LsK74J_W0

Hopefully this aircraft can be recovered in time before it is picked apart by souvenir hunters.

Horrido!

Leo

John Beaman 23rd April 2012 04:04

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Unfortunately, Leo, it would seem to have been picked apart the same day the video was made. :(

Andy Saunders 25th April 2012 09:40

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Some astonishing images here...

https://picasaweb.google.com/1146825...eat=directlink

Pilot 25th April 2012 12:08

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Interesting news :)

VtwinVince 27th April 2012 01:14

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Incredible, appears to be the mount of my old friend 'Stocky' Edwards of 260 RAF.

Doug Norrie 27th April 2012 02:38

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Fascinating pictures of a Kitty

Re the Picasaweb pictures:
Photos 16 and 19 show faint signs of HS in front of roundel. This would make
it a 260 Sqd RAF aircraft.
Photo 10 shows it as H-87A3 - a P-40E model or Kittyhawk I (RAF
equivalent). RAF Serials (AK591 to AK999) and (AL100 to AL230) a 3 wing gun model. RAF Cam Scheme only. Users: RAF (Desert).

Doug

Leo Etgen 27th April 2012 20:30

Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Hi guys

There is some speculation online that this might be Kittyhawk Ia (ET574) flown by F/Sgt Dennis Copping of 260 Sqn, RAF who went missing on 28 June 1942 during a ferry flight possibly due to a navigational error. I suppose that time will tell if this is correct or not.

Horrido!

Leo

Alex Smart 27th April 2012 23:21

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Hello Doug & Leo,

Doug, I was wondering why you did not include the ET/EV serial range, wasit due to delivery dates ?

Leo, ET574 would have been 41-35928. Ref Ab's "The BAC & Lend-Lease" page 234.
So maybe the US number would be on the a/c somewhere ?

Alex

Doug Norrie 29th April 2012 06:39

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
In photo 10 of the picasaweb series of pictures it clearly shows the ref. H-87A-3 stamped in the wing and a part no. starting with 87....which would in indicate it was one of 540 Kittyhawks produced with the a/c serials in my previous thread. According to 'Curtiss Fighter Aircraft 1917-1948' by Francis Dean and Dan Hagedorn, page 294, the 540 aircraft were bought by the British government in Contract A-1835 commencing with AK591, before Lend Lease took effect.

The pipe type exhausts indicate an early model Kittyhawk, Mk I or IA.

Looking through my Air Britain serials book (through the 540 a/c), assuming it is a 260 Sqd a/c, I could see only two possibles that could be considered:
AL134 lost on 7.9.1942
AK693 lost on 16.5.1942

If someone could check the 260 Sqd RAF ORB there may be some clues from the above dates.

I look forward to seeing if anyone can add any further info to what I have put forward.

Doug

Larry 1st May 2012 00:23

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
I look forward to the Libyan's transporting it to the Uk as a gift (to say thanks to the modern RAF for helping in their fight for freedom) and seeing it being resored to flying condition at Duxford.:D

ahafan 1st May 2012 00:44

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Larry (Post 147082)
I look forward to the Libyan's transporting it to the Uk as a gift (to say thanks to the modern RAF for helping in their fight for freedom) and seeing it being resored to flying condition at Duxford.:D

in our Dreams;

ahafan 1st May 2012 00:47

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Doug Norrie (Post 146971)
In photo 10 of the picasaweb series of pictures it clearly shows the ref. H-87A-3 stamped in the wing and a part no. starting with 87....which would in indicate it was one of 540 Kittyhawks produced with the a/c serials in my previous thread. According to 'Curtiss Fighter Aircraft 1917-1948' by Francis Dean and Dan Hagedorn, page 294, the 540 aircraft were bought by the British government in Contract A-1835 commencing with AK591, before Lend Lease took effect.

The pipe type exhausts indicate an early model Kittyhawk, Mk I or IA.

Looking through my Air Britain serials book (through the 540 a/c), assuming it is a 260 Sqd a/c, I could see only two possibles that could be considered:
AL134 lost on 7.9.1942
AK693 lost on 16.5.1942

If someone could check the 260 Sqd RAF ORB there may be some clues from the above dates.

I look forward to seeing if anyone can add any further info to what I have put forward.

Doug

Hello
excuse me but nearly a month and no ONE-as ID who it belong too.
just the 2-what about engine changes etc serial numbers.
im not tryin to start a war' but for one P40 found its takin a long time to ID the pilot.
sharon

DaveM2 1st May 2012 02:42

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Larry (Post 147082)
I look forward to the Libyan's transporting it to the Uk as a gift (to say thanks to the modern RAF for helping in their fight for freedom) and seeing it being resored to flying condition at Duxford.:D

Since it belongs to the Egyptians that probably won't happen. And heaven forbid it is 'restored'

Dave

paulmcmillan 1st May 2012 10:18

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
HTML Code:

[html]
[/html]
Quote:

Originally Posted by Doug Norrie (Post 146971)
In photo 10 of the picasaweb series of pictures it clearly shows the ref. H-87A-3 stamped in the wing and a part no. starting with 87....which would in indicate it was one of 540 Kittyhawks produced with the a/c serials in my previous thread. According to 'Curtiss Fighter Aircraft 1917-1948' by Francis Dean and Dan Hagedorn, page 294, the 540 aircraft were bought by the British government in Contract A-1835 commencing with AK591, before Lend Lease took effect.

The pipe type exhausts indicate an early model Kittyhawk, Mk I or IA.

Looking through my Air Britain serials book (through the 540 a/c), assuming it is a 260 Sqd a/c, I could see only two possibles that could be considered:
AL134 lost on 7.9.1942
AK693 lost on 16.5.1942

If someone could check the 260 Sqd RAF ORB there may be some clues from the above dates.

I look forward to seeing if anyone can add any further info to what I have put forward.

Doug

Doug

I have AK951 AK999 C/N 18695 18743 as H87-A2 (Kittyhawk I) and AL100 AL230 C/N 18744 18874 as H87-A2 (Kittyhawk I) not not H-87A-3

ET100 ET519 C/N 19287 19706, USAAF 41-24776 41-25195 as H87-A3 P-40E-1 (Kittyhawk IA) and ET520 EV699 C/N 19707 20786 USAAF 41-35874 41-36953 as H87-A3 P-40E-1 (Kittyhawk IA)

- Also one of the worlds best P-40 experts has tentively identified its a P-40E CU-1 subtype which is a H87-A3

paulmcmillan 1st May 2012 10:33

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ahafan (Post 147084)
Hello
excuse me but nearly a month and no ONE-as ID who it belong too.
just the 2-what about engine changes etc serial numbers.
im not tryin to start a war' but for one P40 found its takin a long time to ID the pilot.
sharon

Sharon

This aircraft is in the middle of no where.. Was found by people with no knowledge of aircraft serial numbers or construction numbers or how to find these experts initially (someone got his mate to post the first pictures on his modelling site probably because he was the only person he knew with an interest in aircraft - looking at the friends models he appears more interested in concept flying models anyway) and with no visible ID on it other than HS-B (and the 'B' only came later) - we will have to wait until the site is visited by people who know what to look for

People have a suspect ID, but it is only that..

Paul

markjsheppard 1st May 2012 14:22

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Sharon,

As Paul said, it is not as though you can just pop down the road to have a look. It is in the middle of Egypt, you need a vehicle, drivers and escorts. These guys are workers, not tourists and don't work 9-5, 5 days a week.

One month! Considering the 'news' on the web is only 2 weeks old, I think we have a staggering amount of information. 15 years ago the news would be trickling through about some plane with roundels found in the desert and would have taken 6 months to get to where we are now!

The ID is at the top of a list of very important questions/requests. If I asked you if you could tell me the engine number on a Ford Focus with number plate AF54 RFS located on the Shetlands, how long would it take you to get it to me?

It is frustrating (you have no idea) as there is a lot wanting to confirm the identity and status of the pilot above anything else!

Yours frustrated

Mark

Revi16 1st May 2012 17:05

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
From some of the other forums,

"On 28/6/42 ET574 Piloted by F/Sgt DCH Copping 785025 left 260 for a ferry flight to an RSU . The A/C flew with u/c locked down due to damage . An incorrect course was set and the A/C was thought to have crashed in the Desert due to fuel exhaustion.
F/Sgt Copping is listed as missing on that date
Now I'm not saying this is the A/C , just that it MIGHT be, in view of :-
a) there being no apparent signs of Battle damage
b) the fact that the U/C was wiped off in the crash"


"Have also been given the OK to confirm that the Royal Air Force Museum, Hendon. London are actively pursuing this P40 with the intention to recover and conserve. This is being dealt with at the highest levels."

ahafan 1st May 2012 19:42

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by markjsheppard (Post 147114)
Sharon,

As Paul said, it is not as though you can just pop down the road to have a look. It is in the middle of Egypt, you need a vehicle, drivers and escorts. These guys are workers, not tourists and don't work 9-5, 5 days a week.

One month! Considering the 'news' on the web is only 2 weeks old, I think we have a staggering amount of information. 15 years ago the news would be trickling through about some plane with roundels found in the desert and would have taken 6 months to get to where we are now!

The ID is at the top of a list of very important questions/requests. If I asked you if you could tell me the engine number on a Ford Focus with number plate AF54 RFS located on the Shetlands, how long would it take you to get it to me?

It is frustrating (you have no idea) as there is a lot wanting to confirm the identity and status of the pilot above anything else!

Yours frustrated

Mark

Hello
I agree but remember 1956 lady b good found on newspapers.
yet we have one of ours..you dont see it plastered today in the news-
WW2 P40 FOUND INTACT IN THE DESERT.)even On the- News at Ten..
pathetic'''many moons ago circa 1988 -you would have seen a snipet in the newspapers or radio..RADIO ONE-as i recall mentioned flight 19 found have this on tape-/turned out not to be them...but at least we folks would have known..and BBc1s newsround featured them..
you wonder why kids-and erm -um-decent folks dont care .better been down the pub's..
where his the -MOD-not a whisper''
you got our army lads.fighting ' yet..this fellow died 70 years ago..and No One cares.
sharon'

Nick Beale 1st May 2012 20:11

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ahafan (Post 147126)
...
you wonder why kids-and erm -um-decent folks dont care .better been down the pub's.. where his the -MOD-not a whisper'' you got our army lads.fighting ' yet..this fellow died 70 years ago..and No One cares.
sharon'

Not the clearest piece of reasoning I've ever seen. Are we even sure that the aircraft's pilot died? If he didn't and since this is not the only P-40 in existence, the story would probably be little more than a curiosity to the mass media.

markjsheppard 2nd May 2012 10:10

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Nick but mainly pointed at Sharon

News Agencies are asking about the P40 but I want to confirm the ID's first to see if there is a pilot missing.

Then I am sure it will be reported in the main press shortly after and RAFM are happy to report there interest and ongoing discussions.

Mark

ahafan 10th May 2012 23:12

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Hi.
looks like the MOD are gettin there hands dirty..an some have reported it his coming here home..the pilot ID his coppin''Flak damage? daily telegrapth. says.
sharon

Buz 11th May 2012 10:41

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ahafan (Post 147685)
Hi.
looks like the MOD are gettin there hands dirty..an some have reported it his coming here home..the pilot ID his coppin''Flak damage? daily telegrapth. says.
sharon

Hi Sharon

Apart from a lovely story, the only piece of good information in the story is that the aircraft was found. AFAIK it still hasn't been identified as Copping's aircraft (although many know it is - even missing that one small part called a serial number...but hey let not facts get in the way).

I would love this to be confirmed as Copping's aircraft, and that a search of the surrounding area located and gave FSGT Copping his final resting place amongst other Allied Members.

Buz

ahafan 11th May 2012 15:12

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Buz (Post 147699)
Hi Sharon

Apart from a lovely story, the only piece of good information in the story is that the aircraft was found. AFAIK it still hasn't been identified as Copping's aircraft (although many know it is - even missing that one small part called a serial number...but hey let not facts get in the way).

I would love this to be confirmed as Copping's aircraft, and that a search of the surrounding area located and gave FSGT Copping his final resting place amongst other Allied Members.

Buz

yes great ..one thing there are bullit holes..and flak? .was he flying on a solo combat mission..if he was with his flight? then why didnt he stay with them;? ferry flight.-

sharon

Revi16 11th May 2012 16:01

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ahafan (Post 147706)
yes great ..one thing there are bullit holes..and flak? .was he flying on a solo combat mission..if he was with his flight? then why didnt he stay with them;? ferry flight.-

sharon

It wasn't a combat mission. He was ferrying a broken aircraft to the repair depot for repairs. That is why the landing gear was locked in the down position. It is presumed he got lost and landed in the desert.

markjsheppard 12th May 2012 00:07

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Nick,

Think it is more than a passing interest.

Media have been bombarding RAFM, Andy S, Peter A and myself as well as the surveyor who found (as part of a team) who discovered and posted the photos. I'll stick to my day job and do this as a hobby with an article at the end. News broke yesterday and in nearly all UK papers, BBC, ITN news, now CNN etc.

Think there is a bit more than a passing interest.

Only concern is they are talking about it being Copping's aircraft - evidence supports it but still have no serial (just squadron codes and other hints).

It is gradually being stripped. Most loose items, radio, IFF, battery and all tags and ID plates have already gone.

Lets hope it gets secured. Otherwise we are just going to have 100 photos and two videos as memories.

regards

Mark

Nick Beale 12th May 2012 00:38

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
It was included on ITV News At Ten tonight, so I imagine the item will be available on the web somewhere before long.

Dénes Bernád 12th May 2012 08:25

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Yes, indeed. CNN's web site runs it as a front page story (including comments by "British military historian Andy Saunders"):
http://edition.cnn.com/2012/05/11/wo...html?hpt=hp_t3

Empiricist 13th May 2012 09:44

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by paulmcmillan (Post 147103)
This aircraft is in the middle of no where

Not "in the middle of no where" but in the El-Wahat el-Bahariya region.

byron- 16th May 2012 14:42

Interesting find of a curtiss P 40 in the desert of Egypt
 
http://pierrekosmidis.blogspot.com/2...g-post_14.html

The RAF pilot Denis Hopping lost his life in the desert, 300 km away of an inhabited area.

dp_burke 16th May 2012 15:42

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Byron,

please read some of the thread above, the SUGGESTED name of a the possible pilot is Dennis COPPING. Nothing is confirmed yet.

Andy Saunders 20th May 2012 13:56

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
I would echo what Mark Sheppard says in his post.

As of yet, the pilot i/d has not been confirmed. Thus, when CNN and BBC World Service asked to talk to me about it (just bcause they wanted to tal to someone!) I made it clear that I wouldn't talk to them about the name of the pilot for obvious reasons. However, the supposed name was already out there on the net and thus the news outlets used it anyway. I'm afraid that some of the media did manage to rather garble what facts they were given, anyway!

C'est la vie.

Ludovico Slongo 21st May 2012 22:01

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Hello to all,
I received from my friend Daniele Moretto
the request to publish this link

http://www.qattara.it/60-173%20Kittyhawk.htm

Ciao

Ludovico

markjsheppard 23rd May 2012 22:38

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Ludovico,

Now that 1035 has been reported and with the link, it is safe to report that the P40E Kittyhawk in the desert is now confirmed as Curtiss P40E-1-CU Curtiss shipping number 1035, construction number 19761, US serial 41-35928 and British serial ET574.

From the loss card for ET574 we know F/Sgt Dennis Copping was flying this plane.

The Copping family were made aware of the confirmation early last week but although the Kittyhawk has been found, F/Sgt Copping is still missing.

RIP

Mark

Leo Etgen 27th June 2012 23:00

Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Hello

It appears that quite possibly the remains of F/Sgt Dennis Copping have been found. If true at least his family can now inter him with the respect and honor he deserves.

http://www.qattara.it/versione%20in%...ESTO%20_1_.pdf

RIP

Leo

Andy Saunders 28th June 2012 08:59

Re: Kittyhawk Found in Sahara
 
Some caution needs to be exercised until these have been confirmed as human.

The artefacts found with the reported remains contain nothing RAF-specific or aviator related, apart from the oddly positioned parachute part and with the remainder of the 'chute being with the P40 a long distance away.

The copper disc seems to be from a 127lb box of some kind of cupro-related ore and, again, hard to associate this with the P40 or its pilot.

Time will tell, but it would be wrong to jump to conclusions at this stage.

Today is the 70th anniversary of the pilot's sad demise. RIP.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 17:22.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net