Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Pre-WW2 Military and Naval Aviation (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=34)
-   -   USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=47790)

Leendert 4th April 2017 20:50

USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
In the first days of July 1918 some newspapers in Holland report that a Dutch trawler had picked up a crew of 5 men who had came down in the North Sea (near Buoy 4) "in a water plane of sizable proportions (and) of American nationality"
Airplane apparently had had mechanical problems.

Crew said to be American and men were taken on board of the fishing vessel. On request of crew the trawler then ran through the aircraft to let it sink.

The trawler later transferred the crew to a passing British warship.

Who has an idea of the identity of this presumably USN flying boat and crew?

I know of RAF Felixstowe losses and damages etc. over the North Sea on both 4 June and 4 July 1918, but the stories around these don't quite match with the newspaper stories as above.

Were there any USN a/c losses in early summer 1918, either thru enemy action or accidental, that resemble what was written in the newspapers?

Thanks for any thoughts.

Regards,

Leendert

Nick Beale 5th April 2017 11:09

Re: USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
Coincidentally, there's a new post in the books section about a book on aircraft interned in the Netherlands during World War One.

Leendert 5th April 2017 13:36

Re: USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
Nick,

Yes, I have that very informative book. The newspaper article is mentioned, however without further investigation as to possible identity of a/c or
crew.
(American?) crew wasn't interned and flying boat was sunk by trawler....

Regards,

Leendert

Stig Jarlevik 6th April 2017 16:04

Re: USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
Hi Leendert

No answer I'm afraid, but checking my notes, the aircraft must have been either a US built Curtiss H-16 (a total of 158 was sent abroad) or a British aquired Curtiss/Felixstowe aquired flyingboat (nine taken on charge). I cannot think of any operational floatplane which could carry as many as five individuals.
The number of individuals rescued is also a slight problem since the H-16 had a crew of four and presumably did its British counterparts as well. Presumably there was no problem to increase the number to five individuals, but it is a bit odd.
We can also disregard all French flyingboats since all of those were smaller in size.

If I understand you correctly the incident must have happened in June (or possibly very early in July?) unless, the trawler's crew rushed into the newspaper the minute they arrived into harbour.

The most likley NAS should be Killingholme. The first US aircraft arrived on June 1, 1918 (22 H-16 onboard USS Jason) and if it was an American built aircraft I believe it has to be one of those.

However, since Killingholme at this stage still was a 'mixed' station, ie used by both RAF and US Navy, we cannot dismiss the thought that a US crew had 'borrowed' a RAF flyingboat when the incident happened, since there seems to be no US record of any incident like this.

As I said, no help but perhaps a way of narrowing down your search.

BTW I have no record of any RAF/Dutch incident on 4 July 1918. Can you please enlighten me?

Good luck
Cheers
Stig

Leendert 6th April 2017 20:50

Re: USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
Stig,

Thanks for your ideas. Unfortunately (the) newspapers weren't always exact when it came down to dates, so when the incident has happened isn't all too clear.

I gathered that on 4 July 1918 RAF Felixstowe N4513 was lost and another damaged after a skirmish with German airplanes from Zeebrugge. No Dutch involvement here..!
See e.g. https://livesofthefirstworldwar.org/lifestory/6831030 and scroll down to appropriate date.

As with the big RAF/German air combat on 4 June 1918, the story in my thread doesn't fit with regard to fate of the aircraft.

I checked online Dutch newspaper archives and the story first appeared on 3 July 1918 and was repeated with the very same words in several other papers on 4 July 1918.
First date reportedly when the fishing vessel ('Neutraal') had returned in her home port of IJmuiden, Holland and crew had given their account.
The incident with the 'water plane' most likely therefore not more than a week before up to 3 July, assuming that under the wartime conditions the fishermen stayed in home waters and wouldn't be out for a lengthy period.

Regards,

Leendert

Stig Jarlevik 7th April 2017 10:49

Re: USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
Thanks Leendert for the update.

Sorry about my misunderstanding. I guess I was too focused on a Dutch connection....

And yes I agree the basic events from June 4th does not fit this description.

Cheers
Stig

Leendert 9th April 2017 09:57

Re: USN flying boat loss - early summer 1918 - North Sea
 
It seems that the trawler 'Neutraal' was not only involved in this water plane mystery of June/July 1918 but also in the still not resolved ditched seaplane of 17 July 1919 with pilot Murphy..
This pilot was picked up by a passing Dutch freighter and put ashore in N.Germany, while the 'Neutraal' salvaged the engine of this also still unknown airplane.

Regards,

Leendert


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 21:29.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net