Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Ivan Shamanov (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=43182)

knusel 12th July 2017 10:31

Re: Ivan Shamanov
 
Good morning Kirill,

thanks for your assessment.
I'm always interested in successful pilots of multiseat aircraft, also in those who were not credited with the kills of their gunners.

Hmmm...Krapiva, Kulbatskiy, Kostyushin, Kirilenko...
Were the crew members of aircraft composed alphabetically ?

;-)

Michael

kirche 12th July 2017 13:30

Re: Ivan Shamanov
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by knusel (Post 236226)
Hmmm...Krapiva, Kulbatskiy, Kostyushin, Kirilenko...
Were the crew members of aircraft composed alphabetically ?
;-)

Michael

)) + Kutsai ...
But Gorbunov spoils the entire system)

knusel 14th July 2017 12:27

Re: Ivan Shamanov
 
Hello Kirill,

yeah.
To resume the original topic:
As far as I understand that website with my very limited Russian skills
http://airaces.narod.ru/all14/shamanov.htm
the connection of Ivan Shamanov to the Douglas A-20 is explained like this:
  • the Ilyushin and the Douglas were available at his unit
  • Shamanov scored 8 kills
  • it's not known if these kills were scored by him personally or by his crew
  • in the former case he might have been flying a Douglas because the Ilyushin has no guns for the pilot
Have I understood it correctly ?

Michael

kirche 16th July 2017 13:47

Re: Ivan Shamanov
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by knusel (Post 236382)
Hello Kirill,

yeah.
To resume the original topic:
As far as I understand that website with my very limited Russian skills
http://airaces.narod.ru/all14/shamanov.htm
the connection of Ivan Shamanov to the Douglas A-20 is explained like this:
  • the Ilyushin and the Douglas were available at his unit
  • Shamanov scored 8 kills
  • it's not known if these kills were scored by him personally or by his crew
  • in the former case he might have been flying a Douglas because the Ilyushin has no guns for the pilot
Have I understood it correctly ?

Michael

Hi Michael,
You understood correctly. About Shamanov and A-20G on that resource is only a guess. The authors do not take into account that Shamanov commanded the third squadron until the end of 1944, and the squadron flew to Il-4t until the end of the war.
http://www.airaces.ru/stati/1-jj-gva...-mtap-kbf.html

I think that such an experienced crew as Shamanov-Lorin in the last months of the war did not retrain to the A-20G - especially the unmodified version with a nasal machine-gun installation. Making of such a navigator as Lorin an ordinary navigator for a top-mast bomber is stupid.
Kirill

knusel 20th July 2017 12:27

Re: Ivan Shamanov
 
Hello Kirill,

I have gathered some possible Il-4 aces.
However, their scores might represent the kills of the crew they were part of:
  1. Y. Kochelaevskiy (navigator), 11 kills
  2. S. Kretov, 10 kills
  3. I. Shamanov, 8 kills
  4. M. Badyuk (gunner), 7 kills
  5. I. Loktyuhin (navigator), 6 kills
  6. A. Zhestkov, 6 kills
Cheers,

Michael

knusel 12th April 2023 09:04

Re: Ivan Shamanov
 
Good morning Kirill,

have you ever heard about a guy named Горин Василий Алексеевич ?
He has alledgedly 8+9sh kills. What aircraft did he fly ?

Have a nice Wednesday,

Michael


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 04:10.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net