Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Hs129 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 loss date 5.Apr.43 - typo probably? (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=42171)

Andrey Kuznetsov 15th July 2015 18:56

Hs129 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 loss date 5.Apr.43 - typo probably?
 
Hello,

According to GQM returns, Hs129 W.Nr 0377 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 was downed by land forces fire (Erdabwehr) on 5.Apr.1943 in L.Qu.7526 (near Krymskaya, Kuban, Ostfront), Obgfr Gerhard Sembritzki WIA. It seems the date is erroneous, because:

1. 8.(Pz)/SchG1 was in Pawlograd (far from Kuban) up to the middle of April.
2. Bad weather in the Kuban area on 5.Apr.43. Only rare recce sorties were mentioned by both sides, nothing about air strikes.
3. No Soviet claims about downed German planes (war diary of Nord-Caucasian front has mentioned a damaged aircraft but that claim wasn’t mentioned in the lower echelon units documents and it probably about the case of the previous day).
4. No German land forces reports about the downed German planes (Krymskaya was close to frontline)

In the next line of GQM return (2.Jun.43, page 8, lines 100-101) the next lost Hs129 from 8./SchG1 is placed with date 5.5.43. Maybe the plane in question also was downed on 5.5.43 (not on 5.4.43) or on 15.4.43? (Both alternative dates are probable due to heavy air battles in these days).

In NVM (thanks a lot to Matti Salonen for the extracts!) loss date for Hs129 W.Nr 0377 is 5.Apr.43 as in GQM but anyway the date seems erroneous.

Best regards,
Andrey

udf_00 15th July 2015 20:56

Re: Hs129 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 loss date 5.Apr.43 - typo probably?
 
According to Martin Pegg's Hs 129, there are also 6 losses for 8.(Pz)/SchG1 on 15 & 16 April 1943 :
Werch railway station, near Werch-Bakanskaya, Kerch, Anapa;
near Krymskaya, over Werch-Bakanskaya.

P.S. And another on 3 May 1943, hit by ground fire in Map Grid Qu 75266.

Matti Salonen 15th July 2015 21:29

Re: Hs129 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 loss date 5.Apr.43 - typo probably?
 
Andrey, this loss info in my database is based only on GQM! I have not found a NVM for it. Therefore your suggested dates 5.5. or 15.4. are plausible.

Matti

Andrey Kuznetsov 15th July 2015 21:53

Re: Hs129 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 loss date 5.Apr.43 - typo probably?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matti Salonen (Post 203770)
Andrey, this loss info in my database is based only on GQM! I have not found a NVM for it.
Matti

Thank you, Matti. The suppositive presence of the loss in question in NVM was the most embarrassing factor for me.

Andrey Kuznetsov 15th July 2015 21:55

Re: Hs129 from 8.(Pz)/SchG1 loss date 5.Apr.43 - typo probably?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by udf_00 (Post 203768)
According to Martin Pegg's Hs 129, there are also 6 losses for 8.(Pz)/SchG1 on 15 & 16 April 1943

Thank you, I have the Martin Pegg's book.

Best regards,
Andrey


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 14:34.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net