Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Allied and Soviet Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943 (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=42689)

Nick Hector 8th September 2015 09:30

Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Another Lipfert query:

On 7.3.43 he and Friedrich Barnickel downed a total of 3 R-5s in the Popovichevskaya/Ivanovskaya sector but I haven't been able to locate who the opponents were. Can anyone assist?

Nick

Andrey Kuznetsov 8th September 2015 18:54

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Hello Nick,

Some transport and liaison missions of "R-5"-like planes (U-2, PR-5, K-5) were in the area. Low activity due to bad weather.
No losses in operative reports of 4.VA and 5.VA. Can't find any personal loss in OBD also.
Maybe wrong date in German primary source or the Luftwaffe pilots were too optimistic in that case.

Best regards,
Andrey

Nikita Egorov 8th September 2015 23:32

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Both victims (no third plane recorded) belonged to female 46 GNBAP of 218 NBAD. Serzhants Belyakova and Serebryakova's crews were attacked by Bf-109s on transfer flight from Novodzhereliyevskaya to Pashkovskaya. Both U-2s managed to land due to low altitude and were sent to PARM. Nobody was hurt.

Nokose 8th September 2015 23:34

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Andrey, I have noticed that the GVF civilian pilots don't always show up in the OBD. I saw a Russian website (which I don't have at this time) listed civilian pilots killed and missing but it only provided the month and year with their names. Wouldn't those aircraft be outside the scope of the 4 and 5 VA?

Andrey Kuznetsov 9th September 2015 00:32

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Hello Nikita,

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nikita Egorov (Post 206273)
Both U-2s managed to land due to low altitude and were sent to PARM. Nobody was hurt.

I almost haven't step down from army-level documents for March 1943, it is beyond the scope of my present interest. It seems the damaged planes without personal losses were omitted in army op.reports, at least in some cases.

Andrey Kuznetsov 9th September 2015 00:35

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Hello Nokose,

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nokose (Post 206274)
Wouldn't those aircraft be outside the scope of the 4 and 5 VA?

Civil aviation (GVF) front units were within air armies, at least in 1943.

Nick Hector 9th September 2015 08:11

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Gentlemen,

A big thanks for your assistance on this one, especially Nikita with his info on the 46 GNBAP losses.

Also, Nikita, I eagerly await the release of your Stalingrad book

Nokose 9th September 2015 22:56

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Andrey, I found the site again, http://www.stela-vnukovo.narod.ru/spisok_1.htm . I looked at two civilian pilots on there and tried to find them in the OBD but they didn't show up. This site didn't give information on the location of the loss and only some of the date.
examples:
Pilots: Konstantin Semenovich Vasil'ev June 1942 MIA
Vladimr Aleksandovich Vasil'ev August 1943 MIA

Andrey Kuznetsov 10th September 2015 14:57

Re: Lipfert and Barnickel 7th March, 1943
 
Hello Nokose,

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nokose (Post 206356)
Andrey, I found the site again ... I looked at two civilian pilots on there and tried to find them in the OBD but they didn't show up.


The source of the site info is unknown, so reliability is unclear.
But it is possible that some GVF losses are absent in OBD, especially for units not attached to the military structures (fronts, air armies etc). As it was for civil railway organizations etc. In the course of nature, GVF (even its front units i.e. transport units) shouldn't be in the area with the sufficient danger of the enemy attacks. So GVF losses were negligibly small in comparison with VVS losses.

Some (many?) documents of the civil aviation (GVF) front units are located in TsAMO. I have worked with operative reports of 9.AP GVF, for example. Also, activity of GVF front units is usually described in air armies documents (operative reports etc). So overall picture of GVF front units is available from TsAMO documents usually.

Bulk of GVF documents for 1941-45 is located in Civil Aviation archive as far as I know.

Best regards,
Andrey


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 21:05.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net