Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum

Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/index.php)
-   Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/forumdisplay.php?f=8)
-   -   Collision P-51 Bf 109 Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA (http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/showthread.php?t=67679)

Snautzer 9th November 2026 12:47

Collision P-51 Bf 109 Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA
 
Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA P-51 42-106483 (352nd Fighter Group 486th Fighter Squadron) crashed in Bf 109 while diving and attacking 50-75 enemy aircraft crashed Zarnekla Gr. 13-05-1944 14:25
Buried 15-05-1944 Zarnekla Gr.


From MACR
Captain FRANK A. CUTLER, O-732178, AC, this organization, was flying Yellow One, and I was flying Yellow Two. The undersigned was flying Captain Cutler's wing. At approximately 1415 hours in the vicinity of Tribees (note:Tribsees), Germany, I saw Captain Cutler peel off into a screaming dive, and go down between two clouds. I followed and lost him as he went into a big cloud. This was the last visual contact I had with him.
Leo W. Northrop
1st Lt., AC-Res.,
O-732323.

In the vicinity north of New Brandenburg I dove from the rear on a formation of from fifty (50) to seventy-five (75) bandits. I observed at approximately two hundred fifty (250) yards in front of me and a little to the left a P-51 Mustang crash into the tail of a Me 109. Both began burning, but I saw neither explode nor can I say definately that the Mustang had a blue nose.
MARION J. NUTTER,
1st Lt., Air Corps,
O-732324, 487th Ftr Sq.


Who was the German pilot he crashed in to the tail of?

KM1957 9th November 2026 17:45

Re: Collision P-51 Bf 109 Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA
 
From Day Fighters In Defence of the Reich, pilot was Fw. Alfred Bindseil, 6./JG 1. His report is on page 296 and states the P-51 crashed into Kieler Bucht. Lt. Nutter in the MACR say Cutler hit the Me 109's tail, but Bindseil says his prop hit the right stabilizer and vertical tail of the P-51.

Kent

Rottler 9th November 2026 19:27

Re: Collision P-51 Bf 109 Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA
 
Fw Bindseil flew a Fw 190, yellow 10. According to Jagdfliegerverbände Vol. 13/I and footnote 1272 his Fw 190 remained under control. He made a subsequent dive and was able to shoot down the P-51. He landed at the airfield Hamburg-Fuhlsbüttel. Two propeller blades had forward-bent tips, the tip of the third propeller blade was torn off.

Leo

Karoband 9th November 2026 20:25

Re: Collision P-51 Bf 109 Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA
 
http://forum.12oclockhigh.net/album....pictureid=2010

No. 4 is the claim of Fw. Bindseil for a Mustang at 13.38 hrs. on 13 May 1944. However, I bring your attention to claim No. 1 on the above page. A Fw. Hans Fritz of 3./JG 3 is claiming a Mustang at 14.17 at "UF Tribsees" according to both Michael Balss and the authors of Luftwaffe OKL Fighter Claims. While these match almost exactly the testimony of Northrop, I do not read the word "Tribsees" under Ort.

Also, there is no definite proof that Cutler's Mustang was the one in the mid-air collision seen by Nutter.

Snautzer 9th November 2026 22:19

Re: Collision P-51 Bf 109 Frank Allen Cutler 732178 Pilot KIA
 
Captain FRANK A. CUTLER, O-732178 vicinity of Tribees (note:Tribsees), Germany, I think one could give him some slack of his notion of were he was. Being in a big fight, not pin point.

Tribsees is very small few houses town. Perhaps not even on a luftwaffe map. On the ground almost always refer to a bigger town if needed.

Hans Fritz of 3./JG 3 is claim i think is most bang on the money. Time and place.
I would say, most probable, not certain but...

Thank you all.


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 14:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2026, 12oclockhigh.net