View Single Post
  #34  
Old 24th September 2005, 23:38
Franek Grabowski Franek Grabowski is offline
Alter Hase
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Warsaw, Poland
Posts: 2,468
Franek Grabowski is on a distinguished road
Re: Bombing civilian targets by the Luftwaffe?

Marius

Quote:
The abilities of Vth column here are much to more exaggerated. If this is all you can provide as an evidence for experimental bombing so I have to retire... A serious discussion is going to an end now.
There was enough of them to attack Polish troops at Bydgoszcz/Bromberg. Also, how would you explain target markers visible on the original photos?
The claim that this was an experiment is by a Luftwaffe serviceman. Whom should I trust more, you or him?
No Marius, there is no serious discussion with you, there is simply no discussion with you.

Quote:
Sorry, but I do not understand. Can you prove what you are talking about?
What is your source giving you the certainty that a civilian town, without troops or strategic importance was targeted?
Just look at the photos courtesy of Luftwaffe. Please show me anything of strategic importance. Any trenches perhaps?

Quote:
Could you quote a document please? If you can not so I think this is your personal opinion only, perhaps even a soap-bubble, no more no less.
OK, prove there were Polish troops in Frampol. Stop your soap-buble.

Quote:
What about the frontline nearby the town?
Several toilets were near the frontline. Does it make them targets of military importance?

Quote:
What about the bombing missions between the 12-14th September in this area?
Nothing. Is it a proof of anything?

Quote:
What about the important road Janow - Frampol - Bilgoraj?
(by the way, Franek, not even a road through the city, great joke!)
Where it is on the photo and how it was affected in the result of attack?

Marius, you asked in this thread, why German authors manipulate and colourise. Why have you not asked them directly? I see another possible explanation, perhaps all the German authors are liars? Would you agree?

Martin
I am not sure of Guernica because it is much more controversial and unclear topic.