View Single Post
  #14  
Old 19th December 2012, 18:11
ChrisS ChrisS is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Oxford England
Posts: 727
ChrisS is on a distinguished road
Re: Need help with eagle/hawk insignia of fuselage of Bf109Es for Jochen Prien book insignia artwork

Dear Jochen

Thank you for the reply. Axel may be wrong but the similarity between the 'concept' of the eagle carrying a clutch of roundels over a set of waves, which must have been a pain for the ground crews to paint, and the simplified eagle with only one distressed roundel, much easier for busy ground crew to apply, seems to me to have a strong resonance as both emblems have such similarity.

One of the arguments for 1./JG52 is that the two photographs in LiF 19/2012 are both of wheels-up landed JG52 Bf109-F's, one carries a '4' and the other '10' in a light colour outlined in black which would suggest 1./JG52 who used white numbers outlined black whereas 3./JG52 numbers were yellow outlined in white. I accept that this is a very strong argument however tonally both the 4 and 10 are darker than white especially when compared to the white of the adjacent balkankreuz and that the numbers are far closer in tone to the Russia rumpf/theatre band. With regard to the new emblem, one must ask why would 3./JG52 'pinch' an emblem so similar to 1./JG52 with an eagle and roundell? Could they not have been more 'original'? Then also why would 3./JG52 take a new emblem that contained the emblem of a country they fought almost a year in their past? Why not have the eagle carrying a soviet red star? No, I still believe that the previous emblem in LiF 19/2012 belongs to 3./JG52 and that the second emblem that you seek a better image of is in fact a modified variant of the earlier emblem.

But I look forward to Vol 12/11 with great anticipation!

Best Regards

Chris
Reply With Quote