[Peter Cook]

Hi Brian,

This is what have:

Mason - 1969 - Battle Over Britain - p. 195
I./LG 1 - Junkers Ju 88A-1 - Combat Mission - Shot down by 43 Sqn. Hurricanes 20 miles S.W. of St. Catherine's Point at 16.50 hrs. 100% damage. One killed; Ltn. Stahl + 2 missing.

Ramsey/Cornwell - 1980 - BoB Then and Now - p. 570
1/LG1 - Junkers Ju 88A-1 - Failed to return from sortie over southern England and combat with enemy fighters. Lt. Stahl, Uffz. Lehmann and Uffz. Poppe missing. Gefr. Neff killed. Aircraft a write-off.

Taghon - 2004 - Die Geschichte des Lehrgeschwaders 1 - p. 443 (approx. translation)
1./LG 1 - Ju 88A-1 L1+ - Operational Flight, Bristol - Bristol Kanal - Dogfight 18.00 hr with fighters - 100% damage - FF Lt. Werner Stahl missing, BO Uffz. Reinhard Lehmann missing, BF Gefr. Karl Neff killed, BS Uffz. Heinz Poppe missing

Parry - 2017 - BoB Combat Archive - Vol. 4 p. 429
16.00-18.30 hrs - Combat B - West Country - 2/LG1 - Ju88A-1 - Fell into the sea 20 miles south-west of St Catherine's Point, Isle of Wight. Ff: Lin Werner Stahl, Bs: Uffz Heinz Poppe and Bo: Uffz Reinhardt Lehmann all missing. Bf: Gefr Karl Neff killed - body washed ashore in France.

Balss - 2018 - Luftwaffe Losses & Claims - Vol. 3 p. 252
1./LG 1 - OP - Kanal
Take off Orleans-Bricy - Bristol-Channel - Shot down in aerial combat (609.Sq.), 6:00 pm
Ju 88 A-1 - 100% damage
P Ltn. Werner Stahl MIA, B Uffz. Reinhard Lehmann MIA, Bf Gefr. Karl Neff KIA, Bs Uffz. Heinz Poppe MIA

Comments and Source Discrepancies
All of the sources list this loss with variations in the identification of the crew, the time and the possible claimants. It is likely that Lt Stahl's Ju 88 was shot down by Hurricanes of 43 Squadron as S/L Badger's combat report describes seeing their victim crash into the sea. Only two Ju 88s were shot down during this series of engagements and it is known that the other Ju 88 crashed near Middle Wallop, probably the victim of Sgt Feary of 609 Squadron. However, several other claims were made for Ju 88s by pilots of 92 and 609 Squadrons, and so it is not possible to be absolutely certain about the identity of the claimants.

Peter