View Single Post
  #33  
Old 10th August 2007, 21:05
Rasmussen Rasmussen is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Lower Saxony, Germany
Posts: 691
Rasmussen is on a distinguished road
corrections and additions on volume II JG 300 history

At first ... it's an fascinating and well done book. I think it's hard (or impossible?) to write an third JG 300 history. It's an book full of interesting facts and stories, in an excellent quality.

But from view of "Erla" I have to do some corrections and additions:

p.166
The designation "G-10/ASM" in the strenght box (or "G-10D" in the loss list) irritate because this wasn't an official designation. Maybe it was used in GQM lists but it had nothing to do with an factory designation.

p.194
The W.Nr. of the colour scheme is in contradiction to the description on p.204. Maybe it was inspired by the newest colour scheme of Mr. Poruba, maybe not .... fact is the W.Nr.151965 is correct. Wrong is the date "January 1945" because the pictures were taken in the End of March/ April 1945 at the earliest.

p.197
The W.Nr.491310 isn't "provisional" but in all probability wrong. The a/c had the features of an "late months 1945" produced Erla G-10 (tall tail wheel, great wing bumps) ...but the W.Nr.491310 left the factory in December 1944.

p.226
I doubt that's an G-14. Have a look on the "umbrella holder" - it's an typical sign of an Trop.-version and the G-14 wasn't produced as "G-14 trop.". I believe it's an old G-6 trop.

loss list

W.Nr. 150 742 was mentioned twice (01.02.45/ 03.02.45) both with 100 %

W.Nr. 191 167 was IMHO W.Nr. 491 167
W.Nr. 154 807 was IMHO W.Nr. 150 807

missing losses:

04.02.45
- W.Nr.150 747, III./ JG 300, crash during the start, later blow up by own troops, 100 %, airfield Märkisch Friedland

09.02.45
- W.Nr. 150 793, III./ JG 300, air combat, 100 %, near Wörlitz (maybe the a/c of Hptm. Fritz Lonzius ?)
- W.Nr. 150 874, III./ JG 300, air combat, 30 %, Stackelitz near Dessau
- W.Nr. 150 844, III./ JG 300, enemy fire, 30 %, Stackelitz near Dessau
- W.Nr. 491 268, I./ JG 300, crash landing, 15 %, unknown
- the a/c from Ofw. Franz Knoll I have: G-10, W.Nr. 150 799

02.03.45
- W.Nr. 151 541, III./ JG 300, air combat, 100 %, near Großenhain

(these only some losses I hadn't the time to check the complete lists in Freiburg)

wrong names of towns

05.12.44, W.Nr. 464 300 it was Burg Stargard and not "Stagard"
02.03.45, W.Nr. 151 554 it was Kranepuhl and not Kranepühl

the airfield was Amberg-Schafhof and not Amberg-Schäferhof

(I checked the Erla-a/c only and not complete)

G-14/AS (in the loss list):
I'm not sure if the W.Nr. 462 787, 461 993, 464 300 were G-14/AS because these a/c's not belonged to the official Erla G - 14/AS batches but .... nothing is impossible...

Best wishes
Rasmussen
Reply With Quote