View Single Post
  #5  
Old 13th November 2007, 16:45
NickM NickM is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 610
NickM is on a distinguished road
Re: What's the future of WW2 historical writing?

Quote:
Originally Posted by tcolvin View Post
Surely 'hindsight' is not the concern. Writing history by definition is to benefit from hindsight.

The concern, surely, is the increasing prevalence of anachronism.

For example in films; the GIs in 'Saving Private Ryan' behave like the potsmoking generation in Vietnam. In the film 'Atonement', a Lancaster flies overhead in 1935, while an infantry soldier kicks off his army boots and arrives in Dunkirk without his rifle. None of these could happen.

Tony
How odd...I would have thought Dale Dye (the Guy who trained them to 'act like proper soldiers' ) would have kicked the 'current attitude' out of them while he was still putting them through their basic training';

NM
Reply With Quote