You know, friends, Khazanov's work is undoubtedly weak... But the 'reply' of his opponents
Jean-Yves Lorant and Hans Ring - is more, more weaker!
That place:
"the disparate & incomplete nature of the Soviet archives precludes any objective analysis - who shot down who" - is so stupid that after them all other words are in vain... Had worked those men in "Soviet atchives" just one day?..