[Many Souffan]

Dear Mr Many Soufflan,
Dear Monsieur Gillet
I will answer to your last post word by word.

I do not want to discuss about the combat.
Sorry, if you say that 7 French Pilots shot by mistake 4 Battle of 142 Sqn. We are discussing about this combat, not another one. Please this discussion is very serious for me because we speak about the memories & the honor of French, German & British Pilots

I need 30 pages to describe it in a book to be published this year.
I should be happy to write these 30 pages, but I will publish an article in Avions Magazine, then you will have all infos for your publications

I will also publish a testimony of a German officer who has seen this air combat between Morane 406 in the middle of the Fairey Battle. I have not one single doubt.
Please, This German officer, did hetook some photographs? Did he Write an official report? Because if not, I have some doubts, maybe a new invention from you, as we can find some in your books.

Those french fighter did shot down those Fairey Battle of No 142 Squadron.
OK. Why not? If you are so sure, share your documents with all the gentlemen of this forum and if I made a wrong answer I will apologize in public.

So here is the same question : Henschel 126 shot down by french pilots on the 14th May 1940 :

What evidence ?

Would you be kind enough to give :
1. the references of those Henschel 126 losses stored in Bundesarchiv or
2. give the copy of the original documents or
3. the name of the historian you mention ?
If I give you other infos, it will be not necessary to write my article, you will do.But more seriously I don’t Want now, it is my free will after all I have written, it is not enough for you.Incredible.

Your silence is not a problem because the Henschel 126 you mention are not those shot down by GC III/7...
These are exactly the Hs 126 which were shot by The III/7, the hours and the places are perfectly the same in French & German documents.

But to complete my researches, I just need to see the list you mention. You gave this list to french newspapers and historians who have published your informations without any evidence...
Make the researches yourself great Mr Arnaud Gillet

A serious historian gives their sources...
Why you didn’t put your sources in yours books? Did you read the English books about the Battle & the AASF ? No!

if not this is doubtful...
I will begin to doubt about the serious of your researches

I am so sorry but I don't believe you at all until I see your documents you mention.
I let you to be sorry, it is your problem not mine

I am sure they do not exist as you write it.
You are so funny! So what Brian Cull have written in twelve days in May do not exist, so what Norman franks has written in Valiant wings do not exist? So the citation of the DFM of sergeant Spears do not exist?

I am also sure you have changed some data to match with GC III/7 claims...
I invite you to go to the SHD-Air (Service Historique de la Défense AIR) to see by yourself in the files G7889 & G7890 of the GC III/7 the complete reports of the seven pilots, some of them were in Armée de l’Air since 1935. There were not very young pilots. And I repeat a mistake for one Battle why not, but 4 Battle? Did you the profiles of the 2 Aircrafts? You Forget that it was the main aera and the critical moment of the attack of the Panzers of Guderian
If I was a child, I will tell you, if you said I changed some data, That you did in your books… it is not the words of a true searcher

Please say that I am wrong, but give those documents... I promise then I will shut up... PROMISE...
So I repeat you have taken a wrong way, but I don’t want to give you any documents, it’s my free will, you are not serious, please continue to write, I am laughing about your one man showand maybe not me only.

Warmest regards