|
IMHO here is one weak point in the Caldwell table, that is the late starting date which is likely to color the picture in favor of the West.
In terms of fighter pilots the real question would be if there was a significant difference for the rookie who started in the East or the West at that late date. What were his statistical chances to survive his first 5 to 10 combat sorties respectively for the East and for the West?
These statistics would proof a point.
Why does the Caldwell table start so late? It would probably be easier to collect data from the first two thirds of the war?
There are two issues being mixed.
1. Respective quality of Western Allies and Soviets
2. The role of quantity in determining the outcome
Some (in this thread) argue that although late war western pilots might on average have been inferior to those on the Soviet side, their numeric superiority made up for that. Although I don't recall where, I've read such remarks from more than one Jagdwaffe pilot.
__________________
Ruy Horta
12 O'Clock High!
And now I see with eye serene
The very pulse of the machine;
A being breathing thoughtful breath,
A traveller between life and death;
|