|
Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces Please use this forum to discuss the German Luftwaffe and the Air Forces of its Allies. |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#11
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Quote:
|
#12
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Hans
I have my own theory about how these 38 'claims' came about. Nothing exiting just a human reflection on why people tell white lies, not knowing or realizing they will pop up in historical circumstances later. In 1945 he was quite young (18 years sounds a little too young but may perhaps indicate when he joined the Luftwaffe?). A little odd he stayed for 8 months with an advanced fighter pilot school like JG 108 and never filtered through any of the Ergänzungsunits available or sent quicker to a frontline unit, who were constantly screaming for more pilots, which may indicate he was not the "born" fighter type. Anyway the reputed three claims for B-17s must have been made while with this unit since there is no way they can have been scored with JG 54. Somehow they feel very unlikely to have happened. He must anyway have been a very inexperienced pilot when arriving to JG 54. It feels extremely unlikely that this youngster would all of a sudden start to outshine the 'veterans'. He may have made a few claims, but going from nothing to suddenly make an average claim of some 3-4 per week is at least to me simply not believable. I suggest you contact Andrew Arthy (send him a PM) and ask if he has got anything on Nitsch. He is deep into research with regard to the Kurland/Courland pocket. Cheers Stig |
#13
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Very interesting thread! I can add that JG 54 claimed quite a number of victories on several days in 1945. These are not mentioned in any known [to me] claim lists. For example:
17 February 1945 - 15 victory claims 21 February 1945 - 25 victory claims There were also days when no operations were flown at all. So it is quite possible that Nitsch could claim a number of victories.
__________________
Regards, Andrei |
#14
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Hi Stig
Regarding JG 54 and the B-17's, I agree very unlikely, but not impossible Gunther Toll of JG 52 got one in 1945........very unlikely, but happened........but then again three sounds very unrealistic/fantastic. In my opinion no claims for the man. Lets face it, it's based on his hearsay only. At this stage of the war fuel was hard to come by, sometimes only the best pilots were allowed to fly. Why would this unknown/new pilot be the top scoring pilot of 1945. I believe Helmut Lipfert was charged with wasting fuel by taking-off without permission, but it was a case that an emergency flare had been fired by mistake. Kind Regards Johannes |
#15
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Johannes
Quote:
And there are more examples of high number of claims made on several occasions. On 23 February 1945 thirty (!) victories were claimed (26 reported initially and in a later report corrected to 30) No doubt these totals include not only claims made by fighters, but also those made by ground-attack pilots. Nevertheless, they allow to draw a conclusion. There were some pilots in JG 54 and SG 3, of whose successes we currently know nothing. So why Nitsch couldn't be one of them?
__________________
Regards, Andrei |
#16
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Perhaps it's all a miss-understanding, perhaps he made thirty-eight combat sorties, of which three were against B-17's.
Regards Johannes |
#17
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
The information about his decorations would be most helpful. If he had scored some victories, he must had been awarded at least EKII
__________________
Regards, Andrei |
#18
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Andrei
Nothing is written in stone, but sometimes I find these late Heeres reports rather fanciful. In just three days, Luftwaffe fighter aircraft should have wiped out almost an entire Pulk of aircraft. Did anyone actually believe them anymore? Perhaps the report(s) also included AA-claims? Personally, I would like to have a little bit more to it than just these reports. I also expect that the (hopefully) soon to be published book by Jessen/Arthy will provide, if not the full answer, at least much more details than I myself have available. Johannes I doubt very much any B-17s were involved in any missions into the Courland Pocket area in 1945. I think everyone took this area as being entirely within the Soviet sphere of interest. Since there also must have been a clear lack of strategic targets I cannot see what good use any B-17s would have done. The tactical aircraft mostly used by the Soviets were very capable in handling the situation. Cheers Stig |
#19
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Stig
The information about German aerial activity in all Heer reports had been supplied to Army formations by Luftwaffe itself, in this case by Lfl.1. These are official Lfl.1 totals of victories for the given date. If the numbers in these reports were corrected in a later report, it was usually towards rasing the score, as the information of the combats in the latter part of the day not always got through to HQ by the time report was compiled. Quote:
Personally I think these outbursts of furious aerial combats have correlation with the arrival/unloading of important convoys or supply transports, which Soviets tried to destroy by launching heavy air raids. And, as a rule, the bigger combat, the more overclaiming by both sides. The claims of AA units were listed in these reports separately. I've already posted on this forum some time ago excerpt from such a report for 16 Feb 1945, which reads: jaeger schossen 3 flugzeuge ab One of these three victories was Kittel's last. But who were the other two victorious pilots? And example for 17 Feb in attachment. There was a big aerial battle over German convoy on this date. One steamer from this convoy - Eifel, was sunk by Soviet aircraft with heavy loss of life.
__________________
Regards, Andrei |
#20
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Ludwig Nitsch 38 "kills"...?
Thanks for the updates Andrei
Perhaps I then should have said I find these late Luftflotte reports rather fanciful And I still wonder if anyone really believed in them. Perhaps they were issued as moral raiser for the troops? The latter is perhaps to stretch the facts a bit too far.... However I found Johannes theory about 38 missions rather than 38 claims far more valid in Nitsch's case. But who knows? The one who really knew is gone, and we are left to our own conjectures and beliefs. Without further evidence I'm afraid we get no further. Cheers Stig |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Were 38 Group claims and losses included in Fighter Command Combats and casualties | phasselgren | Allied and Soviet Air Forces | 1 | 23rd July 2017 20:15 |
two combats in SCW 21 and 22 february 38 | GMichalski | Pre-WW2 Military and Naval Aviation | 2 | 17th January 2015 00:35 |
IAR 37 and 38 info | James A Pratt III | Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces | 0 | 3rd November 2014 22:46 |
Ludwig Meister's claims 22/23 March 44? | rlapes | Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces | 1 | 9th May 2009 12:39 |
Fw. Herbert Ludwig - 6./NJG 101 | Lebowski | Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces | 6 | 29th January 2007 11:38 |