|
Allied and Soviet Air Forces Please use this forum to discuss the Air Forces of the Western Allies and the Soviet Union. |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
#1
|
|||
|
|||
Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
Dear all (Frank Olynik specially),
Can someone assist me on detailing the type of aircraft claimed by the 14 victories ace Robert Charles Curtis, from 52nd FG? 19/2/44 - 1 Bf 109 down (Oblt Klippigen from 7./JG 53) 24/5/44- 1 Bf 109 down + 1 Fw 190 and 1 Bf 109 damaged 06/6/44 - 1 Fw 190 11/6/44 -3 victories over Bf 109 23/6/44 - 1 victory 28/6/44 - 1 victory 06/7/44 -1 victory 08/7/44 - 3 victories 15/7/44 - 1 victory 23/8/44 - 1 Fw 190 I am particularly interested on the 15 AF claims on the 15th July 1944 and would like to know which kind of aircraft he claimed and where. Adriano |
#2
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
What I have from an old Excel file with no source listed:
440219: 1 Bf 109 N Lake Bolsena, Italy 440524: 1 Bf 109 440606: 1 Fw 190 Brasov, Romania 440611: 2 Bf 109 N Sofia, Bulgaria 440611: 1 Bf 109 Vis, Yugoslavia 440623: 1 Bf 109 NW Bucharest, Romania 440628: 1 Bf 109 SW Bucarest, Romania 440706: 1 Bf 109 Lake Garda, Italy 440708: 3 Bf 109 E Vienna, Austria 440715: 1 Bf 109 E Turnu-Severin, Romania 440823: 1 Fw 190 Vienna, Austria Probable source is the book "Spitfires and Yellow Tail Mustangs. The 52nd Fighter Group in World War Two" |
#3
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
He wrote an online article on his time with the 52nd FG In which he described his missions. Don't know if it is still online.
|
#4
|
||||
|
||||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
Mission dated June 11,44 escort to Constanza , 3 x ME-109 credited to him
Alex K Last edited by researcher111; 29th April 2018 at 12:08. |
#5
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
Alex K, KAKI and Laurent,
Thank you to both of you! I do not have the III/JG 77 total losses for the 15th July 1944, but guess that Captain Curtis (2nd FS, 52nd FG) may have been responsible (there were two other claims by 2nd FS airmen that day, one shared between two pilots) for the downing of Lt. Franz Trowal, Staffelkapitän of 8./JG 77 who was killed that day between Drobeta and Turnu-Severin. The location matches the claim of Captain Curtis... Thank you very much for the additional help and new information. Adriano |
#6
|
||||
|
||||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
La Chasse De Jour Allemande en Roumanie, Jean-Louis Roba Et Erik Mombeek, p77
Franz TROWAL Bf 109 G-6 (160347), Black 9, combat with P-51, crashed Cocorova, 20 km NE of Turnu Severin. An unknown pilot baled out safe of Bf 109 G-6 (163131) which crashed 20 km N of Tîrgu Jiu. |
#7
|
||||
|
||||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
Adriano
Looked up into the 52nd FG and JG 77 history books , both books are not very clear about the event dated July 15,44 . The 52nd FG attributes the kills to Curtis Art Johnson , Pretzer and Elmer Mendonca near Turnul Severin. The JG77 indicating that Franz Trowal crashed near Cocorova while an other pilot named N.N. of III./JG77 was also downed on the same battle near Targul Jiu though managed to bail out or crash without injuries . Also a Romanian pilot by name Popescu Georghe was KIA near Brasov on July 15,44 not sure however if was related to 52nd FG Do you or someone else have a photo of Frank Trowal ? Alex K |
#8
|
|||
|
|||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
According to the book "La chasse de jour allemande en Roumanie" by Roba and Mombeek:
USAAF claims: 52nd FG : 3 shot down and 1 damaged 31nd FG: 1 claim (I guess 1 shot down) German losses: I./JG 53: none III./JG 77: two total losses Bf 109 G-6 WNr 160357 "black 9" shot down by P-51 at Cocorova, 20 km NE Turnu Severin, Lt Franz Trowal KIA Bf 109 G-6 WNr 163131 crashed 20 km N Tirgu Jiu, pilot baled unhurt, name unknown (The Luftwaffe losses summary database confirm two losses that day, one shot down in air battle, one missing due to enemy action) And I also have three Rumanian losses that day 1) an IAR 80 of the Scoala de vanatoare (Fighter school) at Ghimbav, formation attacked by eight Mustangs. Slt. av. Gheorghe Popescu was shot down and killed when he crashed in the Postavarul Massif. 2) Six Bf 109 G-2 of Grupul 7 Vanatoare (7th Fighter Group) took off against this raid but only four returned to base. One landed in Turnu Severin, but there no new of last one until 28 July. The German command then informed us that the Romanian Bf 109 G-2 242, flown by adj. sef Gheorghe Hapaianu crashed near the village of Medvedja, Yugoslavia. Sources: http://www.aviatori.ro/articole_details.php?id=31 http://brasoave.blogspot.fr/2009/05/...tin-balta.html So we have 4 or 5 total Axis losses (3-4 Bf 109 and 1 IAR-80) against 4 US claims. So far so good, except if we have US gunner claims By the way, the four claims as I have them in my file: 31st FG: 1st Lt Robert E Riddle, 307th FS, 1 Bf 109 over Rumania (bringing score to 7 victories) 52nd FG: 3 Bf 109s E Turnu-Severin, Romania, by 2nd FS 1 by Cpt Robert C Curtiss (bringing score to 13 victories) 1 by 1st Lt Arthur G Johnson, Jr (bringing score to 7,5 victories) 1 shared (0,50 each) by 2nd Lt Willard C Pretzer (bringing score to 2 victories) and 2nd Lt Elmer J Mendonca (first claim, so score 0,50) So saying that Curtiss shot down Trowal is lacking proof, as any of the other US claims could be Trowal too. |
#9
|
||||
|
||||
Re: Major Robert Charles Curtis - 52nd FG ace
77 JG , 31st FG an 52nd FG history books as well "La chasse de jour allemande en Roumanie"don't
give a clear picture as into who shot down who and at this point in time and by no means I can agree with the statement that Curtis alone scored Trowal claim if at all ! Adding to the confussion are the 2 P-51's of 52nd FG which collided somewhere on the way back while entering a battle with ME-110's whereby the exact loss location is unknown to me. In addition the Popescu's IAR-80 is also claimed in form of a FW-190 by a few gunners of 483rd BG near Brasov (Gimbav ) further more the gunners of 464th and 465th BG's who were attacked by some 15 ME-109 near the target (Ploesti ) and who later on also claimed 2 ME-109 brought down making Curtis claim even more confusing . Alex K |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Spitfire JK171, 52nd FG | marcpoole | Allied and Soviet Air Forces | 2 | 7th April 2016 04:40 |
Bob Curtis 52nd FG P-51 | keith A | Allied and Soviet Air Forces | 0 | 25th April 2013 17:58 |
A P51 lost in February 1945 at La neuveville sous Montfort (Vosges Departmen=t | gilles collaveri | Allied and Soviet Air Forces | 19 | 15th January 2013 09:27 |
Bueligens P-38 kills, disputed | Black baron | Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces | 42 | 4th March 2011 09:18 |
52nd FG v. Ju 88s 9 April 1943 | Sylvester Stadler | Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces | 0 | 26th August 2010 03:38 |