Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum  

Go Back   Luftwaffe and Allied Air Forces Discussion Forum > Discussion > Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces

Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces Please use this forum to discuss the German Luftwaffe and the Air Forces of its Allies.

Reply
 
Thread Tools Display Modes
  #1  
Old 1st December 2013, 19:29
Clint Mitchell's Avatar
Clint Mitchell Clint Mitchell is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 457
Clint Mitchell is on a distinguished road
20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

Gentlemen,

I have a query regarding the entry in the GQM - list (RL 2 III-1175 [03.09.40 to 02.01.41]):

Stab II./JG53 - St.Inglevert - Notlandung - Bf109E-1 - 4112

Does anyone know if the details of the above loss are correct? For example was it actually a Bf109E-1. Also Heinz Bretnütz has sometimes been attributed as the pilot at the time of this St.Inglevert loss. Although Bretnütz later flew WNr.4112 as a possible Bf109E-7. I'm trying to establish if Bretnütz's WNr.4112 was a brand new Bf109E-7 and the WNr. details of the GQM entry above are in error and a different aircraft was involved. Or whether the above GQM entry is correct and Bretnütz took charge of the aircraft after this 5% loss with the aircraft being upgraded to E-7 standards whilst being repaired? Interestingly the Übersichtliste states that WNr.4112 was an Erla built (4091-4222) Bf109E-3!

Any help would be greatly appreciated.
Reply With Quote
  #2  
Old 1st December 2013, 20:11
Chris Goss's Avatar
Chris Goss Chris Goss is offline
Alter Hase
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: UK
Posts: 11,194
Chris Goss has a spectacular aura aboutChris Goss has a spectacular aura about
Re: 20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

According to Jochen, it was Bretnütz, E-1, 4112. However, I am surprised he was flying such an old variant when the likes of Mayer was flying E-7, 4138 when he was shot down 3 days previous
Reply With Quote
  #3  
Old 1st December 2013, 20:37
Clint Mitchell's Avatar
Clint Mitchell Clint Mitchell is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 457
Clint Mitchell is on a distinguished road
Re: 20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

Chris, thanks. I've had a look at some other aircraft close to this WNr. That came down in the UK:

WNr.4101 Wolgang Teumer's E-4 (plate found describing E-1 & E-3 ? but clearly had a later canopy)
WNr.4103 Viktor Mölders E-4/B
WNr.4124 E Busch E-7
WNr.4132 K. Sauer E-7

I suppose it would be a help if we could establish exactly what batch WNr.4112 was in and the date it was built. These aircraft appear to be a bit of a mixed bag so I'm wondering if the E-7s are upgraded older E-1s/E-3s?
Reply With Quote
  #4  
Old 1st December 2013, 23:03
Larry Hickey Larry Hickey is offline
Alter Hase
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Boulder, Colorado USA
Posts: 2,982
Larry Hickey
Re: 20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

Clint,

I saw your post on TOCH this morning, and wondered why this is still an issue. This caused me to look into my source more closely, Prien's JFV 4/I P.56, which clearly lists the production batch of 106 E-7s in the W.Nr. block 4091 - 4222 were E-7s produced at the Erla Maschinenwerk, Liepzig, as I'd previously reported. Then, for some reason I happened to look at the E-4/B page (P.53) and, to my surprise, found the listing for the same factory as 26 E/4Bs from the same production block of 4091-4222. So obviously, there were BOTH E-4/Bs and E-7s produced from the same production block in that factory.

This led me to do a translation of the explanation published on the E-7 information, which I'd never taken the time to analyze, since I don't read fluent German.

It says:

"Die genaue Zahl der Tatsächlich hergestellten Bf109E-7 Neubaumaschinen wird sich vermutlich niemals genau bestimmen lassen, da die bruchstückhaft erhalten gebliebenen Werks-und RLM Unterlagen widersprüchliche Angaben enthalten; die insoweit letzte verbindliche Zahl ergibt sich as dem C-Amts Programm Jäger vom 1.11.40, ausweislich dessen bis zum 31.10.40 ingesamt 186 Bf109E-7 abgeliefert worden sind, während die Fertigung der verbleibenden 266 geplanten Maschinen bis zum Februar 1941 erfolgen sollt. Der Auftrag an WNF, der aüf 102 Bf109E-7 lautete, wurde nach 89 Machinen abgebrochen; bei den Bf109E-7/N und E-7/Z handelte es sich um nachträgliche Umbauten an bereits fertiggestellten Flugzeugen. Offenbar ergaben sich auch bie der Fertigung der Bf109E-7 in allen Werknummerblöcken mehr oder weniger grosse Fehlstellen."

Google Translations give a somewhat awkward translation (with a couple of minor modifications by me), but the content is clear:

"The exact number of new Bf109E-7 aircraft actually produced will probably never be determined exactly, since the fragmentary surviving plant and RLM documents contain contradictory information, and the existing final figure is calculated as the C-Office Fighter program from 1:11:40, as evidenced by its reporting of up to 31.10.40 a total of 186 Bf109E-7 were delivered, while the production of the remaining 266 scheduled machines would take place through February 1941. For the contract awarded to WNF, the production run was 102 Bf109E-7, but it was canceled after 89 machines at the Bf109E-7 / N and E-7 / Z and there were subsequent modifications to already completed aircraft. Apparently also during the production of the Bf109E-7, there were more or less large voids in all work number blocks."

So clearly, my dogmatic statement that W.Nr.4112 was produced as an E-7 was not necessarily accurate, and it could also have been factory produced as an E-4/B.

I really want to acknowledge you for sticking to your guns on this, when the engineering visible in the profile package photos did not match what you were being told to do. The other bit of info that I'd previously sent you from Gerhard, is that 4112 was produced in August, 1940. I believe that this a/c probably came to II./JG53 sometime in September, 1940 as a new aircraft, and was taken over by Bretnütz shortly thereafter as "his" aircraft, probably at the time that he transferred from Sta Kap of 6./JG53 to Gr Kdr of II./JG53 on 08.10.40.

We know that he was flying on 20 October 1940, and engaged in air combat, claiming his 20th victory, a Hurricane that day. W.Nr.4112 was reported (in JFV 4/II, P.238) as an "E-7" damaged in an air battle and subsequently made an emergency landing (Notlandung) at St. Inglevert with 5% damage. The a/c was reported in that source as black <<+, which is the subject of our profile. The "E-7" could have been an erroneous entry if the photos of the a/c you are working with show details for other than a textbook E-7. Or it's werk plate could have listed it as an E-7, but due to the production changeover, it could have had mixed characteristics of both an E-4/B and an E-7. Call it by what you see in the photos.

So does this clear up the issues with the profile of this a/c?

Regards,

Larry
__________________
Larry Hickey
Eagles Over Europe Project Coordinator
http://airwar-worldwar2.com
Reply With Quote
  #5  
Old 2nd December 2013, 02:31
Clint Mitchell's Avatar
Clint Mitchell Clint Mitchell is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 457
Clint Mitchell is on a distinguished road
Re: 20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

Larry,

Thanks, email sent.
Reply With Quote
  #6  
Old 2nd December 2013, 18:09
Norbert Schuchbauer's Avatar
Norbert Schuchbauer Norbert Schuchbauer is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Location: Orangevale, California
Posts: 687
Norbert Schuchbauer
Re: 20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

Hi All,
there are good indications that the loss report had a typographical error and it should have read E-7. The same aircraft was lost on 22-Apr-41 while with 2./JG 27 SE Tobruk. This time reported as a E-7 in the loss report.

Regards,
Norbert
Reply With Quote
  #7  
Old 2nd December 2013, 18:54
Clint Mitchell's Avatar
Clint Mitchell Clint Mitchell is offline
Senior Member
 
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 457
Clint Mitchell is on a distinguished road
Re: 20 October 1940 - Bf109E-1 - WNr.4112 - 5% loss - Notlandung at St.Inglevert (GQM loss list entry)

Norbert, thank you for the extra info.
Reply With Quote
Reply

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Forum Jump

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Do17 Loss on October 11 , 1940 . schnellmeyer Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces 6 25th April 2012 04:03
Do17 Loss on October 11 , 1940 . schnellmeyer Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces 4 14th January 2012 01:50
29 October 1940 - Hurricane loss at Wallington Andy Saunders Allied and Soviet Air Forces 2 11th December 2009 20:37
Italian loss on 24 October 1940 Laurent Rizzotti Luftwaffe and Axis Air Forces 2 25th October 2009 10:55
Fighter pilots' guts Hawk-Eye Allied and Soviet Air Forces 44 8th April 2005 15:25


All times are GMT +2. The time now is 17:37.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2024, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright ©2004 - 2018, 12oclockhigh.net