Lt A.D. Neely, 825 Sqdn, POW on 28 or 29 May 1940?

[B.F.M. Droog]

On 28 and 29 May 1940 FAA 825 Squadron, flying with Swordfishes, was in action above Dunkirk. On these two days the squadron lost approx. nine planes, but the information I found is rather contradictory.

Especially regarding Lt A.D. Neely, Lt R.G. Wood, Naval Airman V.S.A. Moore and S/Lt (A) J. T. Nicholson.

According to Fleet Arm Archive, FAA Prisoners of War, Lt A.D. Neely was taken prisoner on 28/05/1940, flying in a Swordfish with:
Lt R.G. Wood, POW
Naval Airman/Telegraphist Air Gunner V.S.A. Moore, POW.

The same source however names (on another page) JT Nicholson as pilot and is unsure whether or not V.S.A. Moore was 'recovered'.

Another source, Naval History.net, states for 29/05/1940, 825 Sqdn:

Lt A. D. Neely and Naval Airman F. G.Rumsey were taken prisoner when their Swordfish was shot down.

Lt Cdr J. B. Buckley and Lt R.G. Wood were taken prisoner when their Swordfish crashed landed. Buckley died in POW camp on 21 March 1943.

S/Lt (A) J. T. Nicholson and Naval Airman V. S. A. Moore were taken prisoner when their Swordfish crashed.

Which source to believe?

Regards,

Bart

[Chris Goss]

According to Cornwell, it was 28 May-you really ought to get his book! Crew were Neely, Wood & Moore. The other Swordfish was Capt Aston & S/Lt Rylands

[B.F.M. Droog]

I know Chris, but I've to buy a whole load of books and don't have the money to buy them all at once.
Anyhow - thanks for the info. But it leaves me still in doubt, since all other Swordfishes that crashed on those two days had a crew of two.